I would guess they are also docking him for having incredible talent around him which is foolish to me. If the eagles defense held up in previous Super Bowl he would have 2 mvps.
from the PI
“Now, is he perfect? No. There’s a reason he’s at No. 10. There’s still flaws in his football game that need to be addressed, need to be fixed. They win the game still with him not playing perfect. … There’s no quarterback in football that has more advantages on the field at the position than Jalen Hurts. They’re a super team and that’s not a shot on him, but he gets the advantages of not having to worry about all these other things, right? And with all the greatness of the Philadelphia Eagles, he cannot play great and they can still win.
He gets a lot of great looks on defenses where I go, ‘Wait, no one would ever play this defense against Lamar [Jackson] or [Patrick] Mahomes or anybody like that.’” I am not sure what this means?? Does he mean they play very vanilla against him?
“If you just went purely on passing and throwing, he’s below 10,” Simms said. “It’s one of the slower releases in all of football. Like, he’s not in the top half of football as far as being able to get the ball out of his hands and do that. Arm strength, it’s not in the top half of football with arm strength either.
“Decision making wouldn’t be in the top half of football, as far as what he does in the pocket, but the other stuff that he brings to the table — hanging in the pocket tough, scrambling and making big plays there, making plays on the run with big throws, buying time in the pocket at times, handling pressure … his ability to rise to the occasion in big moments, his ability to not mess up games in big moments — yeah, those are things that are all taken into consideration here.”