and I'm just being honest here- I would choose MSU and Mullen if I already had a good relationship with him and knew what what I was getting into, and then on top of that, Mullen has developed more QB's that have gone on to the NFL than Mahlzahn, and I also think that Mullen's offense is much more compatible to transitioning to an NFL offense than Mahlzahn's. Supposedly, Newton asked Mullen about putting in some pro-style plays, and I could see Dan doing that, but I'm not sure that I could see Mahlzahn doing that since he likes to do Hurry up offense all the time. Those would be huge factors to me.
Now, I don't know how much money is getting passed under the table, and I have gone to both MSU and Auburn for football games before. And I'll be honest, I think both are pretty darn good as far as atmosphere. Auburn has more tradition and a bigger stadium for sure, but we're filling our stadium up and it's just as fun and rowdy as just about anywhere in the SEC.
Both QB situations seem to about the same as well, which also would be huge. To me, though the difference would be Mullen's history with QB's. Mahlzahn has developed who? Mullen has developed Alex Smith into a first round pick, Tebow into a Heisman winner whose production dropped off significantly after he left, and just about every QB under Mullen has been successful in college. Unless Tulsa put someone on the NFL that I'm not aware of, I think Mullen would have the edge there.
But that's just me, and I may be looking through Maroon colored glasses, but the only thing I can see as far as Auburn having any huge edge would be the proximity to home.