Good voice and talented but damn man sing the 17n song the way it was meant to be. Guess I’m a traditionalist, get off my lawn and ****.
Chris Stapleton smh
- Thread starter tired
- Start date
Hell of a lot better than some of the versions have that have been sung.
He hasn't got the kind of voice range to sing it completely traditionally.
He did fine. Not special, but fine.
He did fine. Not special, but fine.
Yeah not a fan of the unnecessary runs. Basically the male/country version of Fergie with a less grating voice.
I thought it was very respectful of the proper feeling of the song. I liked it.
Yes he does. He is the best vocalist I have ever heard live. You ask most artist now days and they will tell you the same thing. He just put his spin on it with his guitar.
He's a fine singer. That's not the same as having a wide vocal range.
Watch Whitney hit all the notes and compare it.
He can't hit the notes she hits, so he doesn't try. Smart.
It's a very difficult song to sing for even good vocalists.
Whitney set an extremely high bar. I thought a woman would have been a better choice to get the range needed.
He was good, but not outstanding.
Whitney was on a different level than everyone else.
Was? Is Whitney okay?
I hope you are joking. That was the best version I have ever heard of the the Star Spangled Banner. People were crying for God's sake. It was AWESOME!
We can't all agree about the singers so let's just go full instrumental from this point forward. Here's my recommendation. I've heard this live and it's outstanding.
Whitney's was the best vocalist version but Jimi's was the best guitar and it ain't even close even if was done in a protest fashion.
They don't perform this often. Not sure they teach very many patriotic songs or pretty much anything patriotic these days when they already feel that commercials about Jesus are MAGA or benign fascism. Gotta keep a reign on this stuff.
I thought it was great. One of the best I've heard, and I, too don't care for singers who take too much liberty stylizing it. I felt his improvisations/runs were just right...not too much, not completely traditional, but not at all disrespectful.
My chest swelled with pride listening.
My chest swelled with pride listening.
I understand what you’re saying about vocal range and he has great range. However, if you are just straight comparing him to Whitney Houston, she was a unicorn. She had the greatest performance of the national anthem ever.
Well I'll say it was better than Roseanne when she sang it at that Padres baseball game. Where was Kaepernick, taking a knee somewhere so he could sponge a paycheck off somebody?
Frances Scott Key wrote it to the melody of an English tavern song that would have commonly been played on a mandolin and harpsichord or something. Not sure we want to hear it as it was meant to be.. Unless Gordon Lightfoot is singing it of course.
I like Stapleton (I have four of his albums on my phone), but that was horrible. If you can't sing it right, don't do it.
Define right? As it was written to be sung or as you prefer to hear it sung?
Here's what it was originally written to sound like..
Original FSK Version
John Philip Sousa changed it 80 years later to what you may like...
John Philip Sousa Version
Whitney Houston's version was arranged by John Clayton Jr. Listen to it with and without Whitney to see how different it sounds... Cause Whitney Houston's voice distracts you from everything else.
With Whitney
No Whitney
History shows there's no right or wrong, just some are better than others at a given point in time. And for what it's worth, Whitney could sing Baby Shark and bring the house down.
Last edited:
I define it as singing it by the traditional melody and emphasis that has been around a long time.. Stapleton's version was terrible. It's NOT a country song. Neither is it a rap song, soul song, rock song, alternative song, hip hop song, or any other modern pop style song.
While I agree that Whitney Houston’s version is the gold standard…..it was pre recorded and lip synced sung into a dead mic on the field.
If you don’t like Stapletons version that’s fine but at least he did it live.
If you don’t like Stapletons version that’s fine but at least he did it live.
Never knew Whitney's was lip synced; bummer. I liked Stapleton's version as it created a lot of dust around the world. I've liked previous versions by others as well as long as you feel patriotic pride coming outta the microphone. Others have trashed it which is disgusting when you can tell they don't give a 17 about the country and all they want is individiual acclaim.
It was 1991 man. Sound technology has come a long way in the last 32 years. That was how it had to be done back then.
No not really. Harry Connick Jr sang it live the next year.
It was 1991 man. Sound technology has come a long way in the last 32 years. That was how it had to be done back then.
I'll take his approach any day over the Whitney Houston style of adding syllables to every other word. And this is from someone who finds 99.9% of country music to be low brow, intolerable garbage.
Whitney Houston's version is by far the best. Some really close seconds: the dixie chicks in 2001 (i think), faith hill's version, leann rimes version at the UT/USCw national championship.