Read a NJ paper and Caliknights's post. Enough said.
If Cal Coach Sonny Dykes was in NJ he would have been pushed to be run out of town within his first 2 years. Article after article would question his ability to coach and recruit. Article after article would have covered how Cal was doing everything wrong while Stanford had it all right. Article after article would have focused on kids leaving and a few trouble spots here and there that would have been blown into "What is wrong with Cal." We got none of that. Dykes is now 4-0 and the team is playing real well. There were a few articles about his and the team initial struggles here and there, but 100x fewer than would have been written in NJ. In turn, I think that helped him recruit and turn things around.
In contrast, in NJ he would never have a chance. NJ revels in the negative and garbage mindset (Real Housewives of NJ anyone? How about Snookie?). It oozes negativism (crap like Bridgegate happens everywhere - including out here in California -- its politics --- everyone is out for themselves in that game). I am beginning to think the NJ kids and their parents see all this and think of the benefits and getting the hell out of the state. Can't blame them.
Ain't no one of proven or up and coming value dumb enough to take this head coaching job without big guaranteed dollars. Maybe someone with something to prove (Bo Pellini?). Ultimately, you have to look for a Eddie Jordan type (strong ties to the University). Maybe a Steve Shimko or someone else in coaching circles rises to that level in 5 to 10 years. Until then it'll be a long wait.
A Cal grad works in our office, and we talk a lot about Cal and Rutgers. Dykes is interesting. Coached under Mike Leach at Texas Tech, and was co-OC with Dana Holgorsen.
His first year at Cal he was 1-11. In 2013 Sonny Dykes became the first Cal head coach since the University began playing football in 1886 to fail to defeat a single D-1 opponent in a season that has lasted at least five games. Could you imagine this board if that happened? NJ.com? The professors and administration at Rutgers?
2014, Cal went 5-7, but most of their games they lost were competitive.
We will see how the rest of the season turns out for Dykes and Cal.
Our coaching situation is a morass. I agree with everything you said in bold. I don't think another Rutgers homer or someone with ties is the answer. If Kyle Flood is gone at the end of this year, our best shot is to take a bet on a guy like Rod Carey at NIU who is making $600K per year and we double his pay. But some think we are going to get a head coach with P5 head coaching experience. Doubtful. Pelini would be interesting, but I don't see it happening here--too volatile, and the professors and administration would hate him--and that seems to matter a lot in the hiring process--just ask the candidate for AD Frazier who got skewered in the interview process.