Hypothetical Friday question - If Mullen were to leave - would you be...

dawgstudent

Heisman
Apr 15, 2003
38,676
16,478
113
disappointed if Stricklin didn't even interview anyone or do a search and went straight to Hudspeth and offered him the job.
 

tenureplan

Senior
Dec 3, 2008
8,307
922
113
I would be dissapointed

But only because Keenum was letting Stricklin make the sole decision
 

coach66

Junior
Mar 5, 2009
12,662
274
83
I would talk to Hud first and gauge his interest. If I got the sense he was

ready to jump in the boat then I would work with him and get it done, if I felt he was playing me then I would open up a normal search and include heavy hitter boosters in the decision making process to insure consensus and unity. If Hud was ready to jump I would still get buy in with heavy hitters before I pulled the trigger.
 

hullabaloodog

Redshirt
Jul 10, 2008
1,238
0
0
Yes. I'd want a national search.

Hud's a good coach and I'd be happy with that hire, but I'd be pissed if we didn't at least look at all of our options.
 

War Machine Dawg

Redshirt
Oct 14, 2007
2,832
24
38
As I said yesterday, I'd be highly pissed. I'm not even sure Hud should be in the top 5 for candidates right now, much less the slam dunk choice to the exclusion of even interviewing other candidates.
 

TheOMlawdog

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2012
269
0
0
If you had your choice who would you hire: Dykes or Hud?

Its an interesting question. I think most national pundits may take Dykes, but Hud has a lot of appeal from an in-state level especially as far as recruiting.
 

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
7,782
2,202
113
I wouldn't, but I'm sure he would at least give the appearance of doing a complete search.
 

aTotal360

Heisman
Nov 12, 2009
20,809
12,149
113
I'd be pissed, but quickly get over it.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

MSDawg34

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2011
1,080
0
0
I'd like to get a more traditional pro-style guy that actually knows how to use the given personnel wisely. Also someone who has the ability to effectively recruit. Also someone that is proven aka Not Tim Brewster, Not Jim McElwain. Also someone who was a good player. Also someone that was a QB. So yeah I'd like a nationwide search please.
 

Railin Jemmye

Redshirt
Oct 29, 2012
1,937
0
0
Yes. I would love Hud as head coach, but you have to still do a search to evaluate all your options. If Hud were still on our staff and we promoted him, I'd be less likely to be disappointed.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
54,089
21,894
113
Why would you care how good a player our coach was? Most great coaches weren't great players.
 

jamdawg96

Redshirt
Feb 27, 2008
1,523
0
36
What kind of question is this? Any AD worth a **** ALWAYS takes the opportunity to gauge national interest in his program, whether it's public or not.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
Wow, I thought the responses would be mostly in favor of just going with Hud. Did we not learn anything from Stricklin's last search? I would almost be scared shitless if he started a search committee....we may end up with the Assistant Coach of Nevada or some **** like that. I like Stricklin, but his last search gave me no reason to believe he would find someone better than Hud. Granted, football is a different animal, and Ray may turn out to be a diamond in the rough, but I feel like we know what we're getting with Hud. If Strick would go out and see what, if any, big names may be interested and then mark off the list until he got down to Hud, I'd be ok with that...but do we think he would do that? Or would he try to find another surprise guy, like Ray? I'd like to think not, but I have no reason to think otherwise at this point.

Again, I'm not saying I want Hud without a search, but I AM saying I am not super confident in a search led by Strick right now.
 

MSDawg34

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2011
1,080
0
0
Not a great player, but actually played. I want the same mindset as Harbaugh damnit! Winning at all cost and knowing how to run the pro style, not the Worst Coast, Gulf Coast, Croom Coast ****.

I'm a Mullen supporter but changes need to be made.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
54,089
21,894
113
Well that's not what you said the first time. And why does he have to be a QB? Again, most great coaches weren't.
 

MSDawg34

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2011
1,080
0
0
Enough with this meme, from the limited sample Ray has looked like a good hire. Our entire culture has changed and it shows On The Court. Obviously we're depleted but that would face anyone coming in when he did. Sword Thomas and Ware will be an excellent base to build off of.

But to somehow say Strick messed up with the Ray hire is retarded. Of course you have to go along with the board consensus on everything. I can tell on your posts that it's never your own words rather regurgitating the majority opinion or conventional wisdom on everything. The real question is why do you care about image on a board as if posters are actual people you come in contact with. Youre a good psychological study Cad Dawg
 

tcdog70

Sophomore
Sep 24, 2012
1,322
186
63
Just get Hud. He could bring Campbell at Gulf Coast back to State. Forget a search. on Easter if you find the GOLDEN EGG quit looking.
 

MSDawg34

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2011
1,080
0
0
No I said a good player.. Doesn't have to be great but to be good means to have played. Example. Harbaugh. It's just my preference that I would like a former QB calling the shots that has proven offensive credentials. If Dan were to leave I would hope we would go after Petersen at Boise with a blank check for him to sign. Id also look at his 2 fmr OC, the one at UF and TX. All 3 of those were quarterbacks.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
Enough with this meme, from the limited sample Ray has looked like a good hire. Our entire culture has changed and it shows On The Court. Obviously we're depleted but that would face anyone coming in when he did. Sword Thomas and Ware will be an excellent base to build off of.

But to somehow say Strick messed up with the Ray hire is retarded. Of course you have to go along with the board consensus on everything. I can tell on your posts that it's never your own words rather regurgitating the majority opinion or conventional wisdom on everything. The real question is why do you care about image on a board as if posters are actual people you come in contact with. Youre a good psychological study Cad Dawg

Radio, you're such a stalking little *****. Knowing how you stalk my posts, you should know very well that I think Ray "may" turn out to be a good hire....but a name we wanted to get as a fan base? He is not. Once again, Ray may end up good and he has my full support, but I don't want an experiment like Ray as a football coach. May not happen, but what do we have as information to base that on??
Quit putting words in my mouth **********. If you want to post after every post I make, that's fine, but don't make **** up. Better yet, get a hobby other than following my every word on a message board. Your little ***** feelings got hurt bad when I called you out during baseball season last year and you can't let it go.

By the way, you're pointing me out for questioning the Ray hire, while you wanted Cohen gone the entire season last year? I think you proved how great your points were during baseball season. 17 you.
 

ckDOG

All-Conference
Dec 11, 2007
9,477
4,772
113
Dykes - IF he can bring seasoned DC with him.

His numbers on offense are just flat out sick. Everywhere he's gone, they've put up major points on offense. He's from the Mumme/Leach tree of scoring an *** load of TDs. Hud would have a head up on him with recruiting, but it's not like Dykes would come in with no connections. Knowing Louisiana and Texas recruiting grounds counts for something. I'd give him a hard look if he could bring a solid DC with him.

I'm not knocking Hud, either. I wouldn't be unsatisfied at all if he was our guy. I just want to see some crazy wide open Air Raid offenses at MSU before I die.
 

jamdawg96

Redshirt
Feb 27, 2008
1,523
0
36
The circumstances were hypothetical. The question, itself, seemed rather shallow to me. But hey, whatever pays the bills.
 

BiscuitEater

Redshirt
Aug 29, 2009
4,178
0
36
To me ...

But only because Keenum was letting Stricklin make the sole decision

a lot depends on timing. I would like to see a national search to see 'who' might be interested. In today's world, it doesn't hurt to have a list of those interested. But, I would not want a search to drag out or to sacrifice a recruiting class just to do a search.
 

dawgstudent

Heisman
Apr 15, 2003
38,676
16,478
113
Well no one is stopping you from offering us more in depth questions.

It was a basic question in a round about way of saying if Mullen left - would you be fine with hiring Hudspeth without looking anywhere else?
 

MSDawg34

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2011
1,080
0
0
1. Find where I wanted Cohen gone (you can't that was a lie)

2. I was overwhelmingly proven right on my single baseball issue the entire season. Cemented as fact in our final game as an issue. Anybody on here during baseball can attest including the most reliable (Engie and Coach).

Go back to your room while the adults talk sports. Again with the name calling. Haha you really take this message board personally don't you. For your own sake go make some friends.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
a lot depends on timing. I would like to see a national search to see 'who' might be interested. In today's world, it doesn't hurt to have a list of those interested. But, I would not want a search to drag out or to sacrifice a recruiting class just to do a search.

This is the best answer^^
 

esplanade91

Redshirt
Dec 9, 2010
5,656
0
0
It's an SEC gig. I would imagine that the shape it's in now would attract good coaches at other BCS level schools. If the guy from Rutgers, Utah State, or WKU wanted to come here (not saying they would or anything, just throwing coaches out there), I think they should at least get an interview. Hud might not have the national attention those guys have, but what he does have over them is knowledge of Mississippi, Louisiana, and Alabama... Our 3 recruiting states.

I don't care if he was the 4th string holder, 2nd string long snapper, or water boy. A coach is a coach. Todd Haley played college golf and he's one of the hottest commodities in the NFL at OC. Leach is a similar character.

I wouldn't be upset if we hired Hud the very next day, but I would have at least like to fish around a little.
 

jamdawg96

Redshirt
Feb 27, 2008
1,523
0
36
Easy pal, I answered the question and suggested it shouldn't take much thought. Don't put too much thought into my criticisms, either.
 

CadaverDawg

Redshirt
Dec 5, 2011
6,409
0
0
Go back to your room while the adults talk sports. Again with the name calling. Haha you really take this message board personally don't you. For your own sake go make some friends.

Ha, this coming from a student at MSU that spends all day on his computer on a message board? Even gets on here drunk? Riiight.. Do you realize how insecure you look? Letting me get under your skin to the point you stalk my every post on a message board....there's one person in this conversation that takes things personally, and it's you. That time I made you look stupid was over for me the day it happened, but you have let it linger for a year because you were so upset. It's sad really. By the way, a guy with your South Park pic calling someone a child is quite ironic.
 

MSDawg34

Redshirt
Aug 30, 2011
1,080
0
0
You have 3X as many posts in 4 monts less time than me... I was and still am completely right about the entire baseball season last year. You fail to give examples, quotes etc because you are just less knowledgeable. Please leave baseball to me Coach Todd Engie and Bruce this season. We don't need your 6.7 new threads a game.
 

RocketDawg

All-Conference
Oct 21, 2011
17,989
1,391
113
Yes. Not that familiar with Hudspeth, but being HC at a small Louisiana school doesn't necessarily qualify him for the SEC. I've seen a couple of their games and didn't see anything spectacular. I believe he lost to Malzahn at Arkansas State in one of the games I saw.

We should do a national, name brand search. Petersen comes to mind, perhaps the guy at Rutgers ... he had a good year ... Strong at Louisville, perhaps the Kent State coach, Baylor coach ... talk to Malzahn. There are many that should be looked at.

And hiring a Southerner is not even a criterion in my book. The Civil War was over almost 150 years ago.
 

Indndawg

Senior
Nov 16, 2005
6,921
462
83
If I KNEW Hud would

disappointed if Stricklin didn't even interview anyone or do a search and went straight to Hudspeth and offered him the job.

1) keep Dan's 'crootin class
2) Expand Dan's 'crootin class w/a few cherry picked of his own, headed of LA direc tional school
3) He'd end Wilson and Heav's contracts w/MSU

It would be fine.

Otherwise, I'd want a natl search, if anything to give us something more to speculate about
 

DAWG61

Redshirt
Feb 26, 2008
10,111
0
0
I'd be disappointed and pissed. 1. Isn't that illegal nowadays? I might be wrong here but don't you have to atleast interview one minority or is that just in the NFL? 2. I want Cliff Kingsbury so yea I'd be pissed. 3. We'd miss out on all the Gruden to MSU fun.