If Iran detonated a dirty bomb in Washington DC, would the US be justified in responding with a tactical nuclear strike on Iran? I think so.
I have no doubt that would happen. Would think you'd need (or should) confirm it was actually them of course.If Iran detonated a dirty bomb in Washington DC, would the US be justified in responding with a tactical nuclear strike on Iran? I think so.
I agree, if Trump doesn't have the stomach for militarily winning the war - doesn't want collateral deaths - I can't see him being strong enough to use a nuclear weaponNo,... Take out any remaining IRGC targets, governmental positions, and infrastructure,... Then continue with the economic strangulation.
there are tactical nukes.....I’d say we prob would in that scenario, but I don’t ever think the use of a nuclear weapon is justified considering there’s not really any military target large enough to justify it.
Yes, but you still have to worry about nuclear fallout that is carried to possible civilian areas. It's not just the blast to be concerned with - it's the radiation/fallout that the wind can carry miles away.there are tactical nukes.....
If a dirty bomb went off among civilians in Washington DC, I don't think anyone is worried about fallout and/or Iranian civilians.Yes, but you still have to worry about nuclear fallout that is carried to possible civilian areas. It's not just the blast to be concerned with - it's the radiation/fallout that the wind can carry miles away.
I don’t disagree in the slightest. Just pointing out why I don’t think a nuke is ever “justified.” Just a personal stance about it.If a dirty bomb went off among civilians in Washington DC, I don't think anyone is worried about fallout and/or Iranian civilians.
I agree, if Trump doesn't have the stomach for militarily winning the war - doesn't want collateral deaths - I can't see him being strong enough to use a nuclear weapon
if you use a nuke, you're already beyond the point of worrying about collateral damage.Yes, but you still have to worry about nuclear fallout that is carried to possible civilian areas. It's not just the blast to be concerned with - it's the radiation/fallout that the wind can carry miles away.
the "interesting" part of this debate, and JMO, we should never have gotten to this point. Our kinetic effort was making extraordinary progress. We should NEVER have agreed to the ceasefire...I don’t disagree in the slightest. Just pointing out why I don’t think a nuke is ever “justified.” Just a personal stance about it.
I’m sure we have a nuclear doctrine on when use is appropriate, but I would have to think the answer is yes. At that point, it’s either us or them.
“A”? “Tactical”?If Iran detonated a dirty bomb in Washington DC, would the US be justified in responding with a tactical nuclear strike on Iran? I think so.
The strategy is to cause the regime to implode internally from cutting off all sources of funds. The alternative would be much costlier and more impactful to the innocent civilians suffering under the regime.the "interesting" part of this debate, and JMO, we should never have gotten to this point. Our kinetic effort was making extraordinary progress. We should NEVER have agreed to the ceasefire...
I have no idea what Trump is doing in Iran...he has allowed them to seize the momentum and it would be destabilizing for the region to restart bombing now. I can't for the life of me think that the military commanders/advisors chose this strategy (if you want to call it that).
This quagmire is all on trump.
the "interesting" part of this debate, and JMO, we should never have gotten to this point. Our kinetic effort was making extraordinary progress. We should NEVER have agreed to the ceasefire...
I have no idea what Trump is doing in Iran...he has allowed them to seize the momentum and it would be destabilizing for the region to restart bombing now. I can't for the life of me think that the military commanders/advisors chose this strategy (if you want to call it that).
This quagmire is all on trump.
If Iran detonated a dirty bomb in Washington DC, would the US be justified in responding with a tactical nuclear strike on Iran? I think so.
Don't give Israel any more false flag ideas.If Iran detonated a dirty bomb in Washington DC, would the US be justified in responding with a tactical nuclear strike on Iran? I think so.
Maybe Iran was closer than people think
And Trump had to do the war to save a part of the country
Most folks on here are one eyed
This is the whole problem. I don't know what to think anymore. When Iran says something, as far as I'm concerned, it has the relevance of a fart in a whirlwind. You can't believe them. The PROBLEM here is that in the past when the POTUS said things about foreign policy, I felt like I could believe them. That was true of Biden, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Bush. When they were speaking officially to the country about our actions around the world, I generally believed it.Maybe Iran was closer than people think
And Trump had to do the war to save a part of the country
Most folks on here are one eyed
No,... Take out any remaining IRGC targets, governmental positions, and infrastructure,... Then continue with the economic strangulation.
This is the whole problem. I don't know what to think anymore. When Iran says something, as far as I'm concerned, it has the relevance of a fart in a whirlwind. You can't believe them. The PROBLEM here is that in the past when the POTUS said things about foreign policy, I felt like I could believe them. That was true of Biden, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Bush. When they were speaking officially to the country about our actions around the world, I generally believed it.
I don't believe Trump. He told us that Iran was close to having a bomb. Then he (and Israel) bombed the **** out of them. Then he told us that Iran's nuclear program had been Obliterated. Not damaged, not delayed, obliterated... And 6 months later we are in a war to keep Iran from getting a nuclear weapon AGAIN? Both of those things can't be true.
So maybe you are right... Maybe Trump is telling the truth here and it had to be done. Just because Trump is a lying sack of shiit doesn't mean he doesn't tell the truth some (or even most of the time). But it means that when important things are going on, that Trump WILL lie if it suits him.
Exactly. How can you trust somebody that repeatedly contradicts himself? We obliterated their nuclear program until we didn't. We wanted the regime gone until we decided to negotiate with them.This is the whole problem. I don't know what to think anymore. When Iran says something, as far as I'm concerned, it has the relevance of a fart in a whirlwind. You can't believe them. The PROBLEM here is that in the past when the POTUS said things about foreign policy, I felt like I could believe them. That was true of Biden, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Bush. When they were speaking officially to the country about our actions around the world, I generally believed it.
I don't believe Trump. He told us that Iran was close to having a bomb. Then he (and Israel) bombed the **** out of them. Then he told us that Iran's nuclear program had been Obliterated. Not damaged, not delayed, obliterated... And 6 months later we are in a war to keep Iran from getting a nuclear weapon AGAIN? Both of those things can't be true.
So maybe you are right... Maybe Trump is telling the truth here and it had to be done. Just because Trump is a lying sack of shiit doesn't mean he doesn't tell the truth some (or even most of the time). But it means that when important things are going on, that Trump WILL lie if it suits him.
Sanctions are going to hurt the average Iranian, whom we claim to care about, far more and for far longer than the average member of the IRGC.The strategy is to cause the regime to implode internally from cutting off all sources of funds. The alternative would be much costlier and more impactful to the innocent civilians suffering under the regime.
You are right that it will affect everyone but it would be worse if we took out the critical infrastructure. What they are currently doing to Iran wasn't done to Iraq.Sanctions are going to hurt the average Iranian, whom we claim to care about, far more and for far longer than the average member of the IRGC.
We sanctioned the hell out of Iraq, and Saddam lasted until we physically invaded the place.
Not quite sure I follow. With Iran, you mean the idea that we should bomb critical civilian infrastructure? We did make a great effort to prevent Iraq from selling oil.You are right that it will affect everyone but it would be worse if we took out the critical infrastructure. What they are currently doing to Iran wasn't done to Iraq.
Tiger Illustrated Football
Thursday Clemson Football Insider
Tiger Illustrated Football
Graham Neff: 'What drives winning is different now'
Tiger Illustrated Basketball
Thursday Dillon Hunter Update
On3 Football
House working on small revisions of Protect College Sports Act before vote
Tiger Illustrated Football
Wednesday Evening Clemson Football Insider