Iran using dirty bomb

UrHuckleberry

Heisman
Jun 2, 2024
10,910
23,554
113
If Iran detonated a dirty bomb in Washington DC, would the US be justified in responding with a tactical nuclear strike on Iran? I think so.
I have no doubt that would happen. Would think you'd need (or should) confirm it was actually them of course.

Not sure it really makes sense that they would do it with the Dems coming to power. Think the expectation is that the war would start winding down, have more oversight, etc. So doing something like that that would unite these United States doesn't make any sense other than a false flag type deal (not making an accusation).
 
  • Like
Reactions: coldbud1994

coldbud1994

All-American
Jan 18, 2005
4,007
6,493
112
I would think we would drop one right in Tehran. It would be terrible for the civilians, but its their government. I just think whatever the response is it would have to be so horrible no one would consider such an act against the U.S. again.
 
  • Love
Reactions: fatpiggy

Rifler

All-American
Jan 26, 2011
6,716
7,576
113
No,... Take out any remaining IRGC targets, governmental positions, and infrastructure,... Then continue with the economic strangulation.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,986
113
No,... Take out any remaining IRGC targets, governmental positions, and infrastructure,... Then continue with the economic strangulation.
I agree, if Trump doesn't have the stomach for militarily winning the war - doesn't want collateral deaths - I can't see him being strong enough to use a nuclear weapon
 

fskillet

All-Conference
Mar 26, 2026
1,055
2,714
113
I’d say we prob would in that scenario, but I don’t ever think the use of a nuclear weapon is justified considering there’s not really any military target large enough to justify it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: yoshi121374

coldbud1994

All-American
Jan 18, 2005
4,007
6,493
112
Yes, but you still have to worry about nuclear fallout that is carried to possible civilian areas. It's not just the blast to be concerned with - it's the radiation/fallout that the wind can carry miles away.
If a dirty bomb went off among civilians in Washington DC, I don't think anyone is worried about fallout and/or Iranian civilians.

I'm sure all the Iranian higher ups would be in deep underground bunkers, so you have to destroy everything else, so if they survive, there is nothing left for them to rule. Send them back to the stone ages. Its unfortunate because many Iranian civilians do not like their government, but they have had plenty of time to overthrow them, I guess they go down with the ship.
 

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,132
5,819
113
I agree, if Trump doesn't have the stomach for militarily winning the war - doesn't want collateral deaths - I can't see him being strong enough to use a nuclear weapon

There's a clear difference between not "having the stomach" to follow through on an illegal war that was horribly/not thought out ... and "having the stomach" to retaliate to getting nuked, not only in your own territory, but in the heart of our government.

Sad I have to explain that to a supposed former military man, but it is what it is.

If Iran was successful in deploying a dirty bomb on US soil, we'd be justified in retaliating in like kind ... and then some. And I'm sure, whatever our response would be, it'd be more than the current trajectory.

The "smarter" move would be to just own Iran. Full might, walk in, eliminate any resistance fully and without hesitation, and it's ours. Not nation-building-helping-the-natives type of deal ... but, sorry Iranians, you no longer can be entrusted to have a country, so anyone remaining alive works for us now. No nukes, because we don't want to ruin our new territory, nor any of the resources we can exploit within. Dirty bomb us? We colonize you.

Bonus result would be we have somewhere to ship Trump and his MAGAts to toil the rest of their lives in labor camps.
 

baltimorened

All-American
May 29, 2001
9,674
6,986
113
I don’t disagree in the slightest. Just pointing out why I don’t think a nuke is ever “justified.” Just a personal stance about it.
the "interesting" part of this debate, and JMO, we should never have gotten to this point. Our kinetic effort was making extraordinary progress. We should NEVER have agreed to the ceasefire...

I have no idea what Trump is doing in Iran...he has allowed them to seize the momentum and it would be destabilizing for the region to restart bombing now. I can't for the life of me think that the military commanders/advisors chose this strategy (if you want to call it that).
This quagmire is all on trump.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,490
39,383
113
the "interesting" part of this debate, and JMO, we should never have gotten to this point. Our kinetic effort was making extraordinary progress. We should NEVER have agreed to the ceasefire...

I have no idea what Trump is doing in Iran...he has allowed them to seize the momentum and it would be destabilizing for the region to restart bombing now. I can't for the life of me think that the military commanders/advisors chose this strategy (if you want to call it that).
This quagmire is all on trump.
The strategy is to cause the regime to implode internally from cutting off all sources of funds. The alternative would be much costlier and more impactful to the innocent civilians suffering under the regime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coldbud1994

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,269
13,218
113
the "interesting" part of this debate, and JMO, we should never have gotten to this point. Our kinetic effort was making extraordinary progress. We should NEVER have agreed to the ceasefire...

I have no idea what Trump is doing in Iran...he has allowed them to seize the momentum and it would be destabilizing for the region to restart bombing now. I can't for the life of me think that the military commanders/advisors chose this strategy (if you want to call it that).
This quagmire is all on trump.

I totally agree that when winning you keep the pressure on even if the 2 and 3 teams are in

don’t let players think it’s ok to put out less than the best

Should have keep bombing until Iran said UNCLE
 

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,269
13,218
113
If Iran detonated a dirty bomb in Washington DC, would the US be justified in responding with a tactical nuclear strike on Iran? I think so.

I don’t feel that ANYONE ON THIS BOARD UNDERSTANDS HOW VULNERABLE THE WORLD IS TO HAVING THE FIRST DIRTY NUKE OR BIOLOGICAL DETONATED IN A MAJOR CITY

WAIT WAS IT COVID. BY CHINA

I THINK A PREMATURE AND IT SPREAD
 

Moogy

All-American
Jul 28, 2017
8,132
5,819
113
Maybe Iran was closer than people think
And Trump had to do the war to save a part of the country

Most folks on here are one eyed

Except we'd already bombed them once and cleared everything out, remember? At least, that's what we were told ... until we "had" to go in and conduct an illegal war in order to do even more complete destruction of what we already completely destroyed before.

You have to stop living in a world where the actions and consequences are obvious, but you deny them, or try to twist them or the responsibility for them, in order to retrofit a narrative that protects your Fuhrer.

It's tragic to watch you folks emasculate yourselves in order to pledge fealty to such a dumb and evil figure, who tells you to your face that he doesn't respect you if you follow him, and you say "yes, my lord ... how may we be of service?"
 
  • Like
Reactions: dpic73

hopefultiger13

Heisman
Aug 20, 2008
11,436
18,416
113
Maybe Iran was closer than people think
And Trump had to do the war to save a part of the country

Most folks on here are one eyed
This is the whole problem. I don't know what to think anymore. When Iran says something, as far as I'm concerned, it has the relevance of a fart in a whirlwind. You can't believe them. The PROBLEM here is that in the past when the POTUS said things about foreign policy, I felt like I could believe them. That was true of Biden, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Bush. When they were speaking officially to the country about our actions around the world, I generally believed it.

I don't believe Trump. He told us that Iran was close to having a bomb. Then he (and Israel) bombed the **** out of them. Then he told us that Iran's nuclear program had been Obliterated. Not damaged, not delayed, obliterated... And 6 months later we are in a war to keep Iran from getting a nuclear weapon AGAIN? Both of those things can't be true.

So maybe you are right... Maybe Trump is telling the truth here and it had to be done. Just because Trump is a lying sack of shiit doesn't mean he doesn't tell the truth some (or even most of the time). But it means that when important things are going on, that Trump WILL lie if it suits him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coldbud1994

PalmettoTiger1

Heisman
Jan 24, 2009
13,269
13,218
113
No,... Take out any remaining IRGC targets, governmental positions, and infrastructure,... Then continue with the economic strangulation.

This is the whole problem. I don't know what to think anymore. When Iran says something, as far as I'm concerned, it has the relevance of a fart in a whirlwind. You can't believe them. The PROBLEM here is that in the past when the POTUS said things about foreign policy, I felt like I could believe them. That was true of Biden, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Bush. When they were speaking officially to the country about our actions around the world, I generally believed it.

I don't believe Trump. He told us that Iran was close to having a bomb. Then he (and Israel) bombed the **** out of them. Then he told us that Iran's nuclear program had been Obliterated. Not damaged, not delayed, obliterated... And 6 months later we are in a war to keep Iran from getting a nuclear weapon AGAIN? Both of those things can't be true.

So maybe you are right... Maybe Trump is telling the truth here and it had to be done. Just because Trump is a lying sack of shiit doesn't mean he doesn't tell the truth some (or even most of the time). But it means that when important things are going on, that Trump WILL lie if it suits him.

I will disagree with you on one point

EVERY POLITICAL WILL LIE AND SWEAR ON THE BIBLE ITS THE TRUTH IF IT MOVES THE NEEDLE

YOU MAY MASSIVELY DISAGREE WITH ME BU I HAD TO BET MY LIFE ON THE LIES TRUMP HAS TOLD THEY ARE VERY LOW IN NUMBER WHEN COMPARED TO EVERY PRESIDENT

IT’s PERCEPTION BABY AND THE SCREAMING RANTING HOLLARING ABOUT TRUMP TO ME HAS LITTLE TO DO WITH POLICY

THE DUDE COMES OFF AS ARROGRANT

I REALLY AM TURNED OFF BY HIS PERSONNALITY BUT LIKE HIS PERFORMANCE AND STYLE OF GOVERNANCE

Really all the folks name calling him are just overlooking the faults of those they call Saints

So just like the policy not the guy
 

PAWrocka

Heisman
Nov 3, 2008
21,362
28,922
103
Asking the wrong question … we’d absolutely respond and Iran would cease to exist. There is no debate about that.

the question SHOULD be, if Iran detonates a dirty bomb on DC (our capital), does the world die?

we would destroy Iran, but would China, Russia, or maybe even Pakistan respond …THAT is the question … if so, the world/civilization dies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TigerGrowls

TigerAnkabut

Senior
Sep 5, 2026
204
479
63
This is the whole problem. I don't know what to think anymore. When Iran says something, as far as I'm concerned, it has the relevance of a fart in a whirlwind. You can't believe them. The PROBLEM here is that in the past when the POTUS said things about foreign policy, I felt like I could believe them. That was true of Biden, Obama, Bush, Clinton, and Bush. When they were speaking officially to the country about our actions around the world, I generally believed it.

I don't believe Trump. He told us that Iran was close to having a bomb. Then he (and Israel) bombed the **** out of them. Then he told us that Iran's nuclear program had been Obliterated. Not damaged, not delayed, obliterated... And 6 months later we are in a war to keep Iran from getting a nuclear weapon AGAIN? Both of those things can't be true.

So maybe you are right... Maybe Trump is telling the truth here and it had to be done. Just because Trump is a lying sack of shiit doesn't mean he doesn't tell the truth some (or even most of the time). But it means that when important things are going on, that Trump WILL lie if it suits him.
Exactly. How can you trust somebody that repeatedly contradicts himself? We obliterated their nuclear program until we didn't. We wanted the regime gone until we decided to negotiate with them.

What can we reasonably conclude to be true? Iran had a lot of centrifuges, and it had considerably more enriched uranium than what it needed for civilian purposes. The purpose of that uranium was to allow for the development of nuclear weapons IF that decision was made by their leadership.

That's one hell of an 'if,' but you do have to draw a distinction between that possibility and one where Iran decided to develop nuclear weapons regardless of the circumstances. I have not seen any evidence for the latter.

The war is a case of Israel trying to knock Iran out before it becomes too large of a regional power for them to deal with. They've managed to convince Trump that their interests align with ours. Do I agree? No. Let's get out of the sandbox.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: fsu1jreed

TigerAnkabut

Senior
Sep 5, 2026
204
479
63
The strategy is to cause the regime to implode internally from cutting off all sources of funds. The alternative would be much costlier and more impactful to the innocent civilians suffering under the regime.
Sanctions are going to hurt the average Iranian, whom we claim to care about, far more and for far longer than the average member of the IRGC.

We sanctioned the hell out of Iraq, and Saddam lasted until we physically invaded the place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fsu1jreed

TigerGrowls

Heisman
Dec 21, 2001
50,490
39,383
113
Sanctions are going to hurt the average Iranian, whom we claim to care about, far more and for far longer than the average member of the IRGC.

We sanctioned the hell out of Iraq, and Saddam lasted until we physically invaded the place.
You are right that it will affect everyone but it would be worse if we took out the critical infrastructure. What they are currently doing to Iran wasn't done to Iraq.
 

TigerAnkabut

Senior
Sep 5, 2026
204
479
63
You are right that it will affect everyone but it would be worse if we took out the critical infrastructure. What they are currently doing to Iran wasn't done to Iraq.
Not quite sure I follow. With Iran, you mean the idea that we should bomb critical civilian infrastructure? We did make a great effort to prevent Iraq from selling oil.
 
Tiger Illustrated

Latest

  1. 01 Tiger Illustrated Football Thursday Clemson Football Insider
  2. 02 Tiger Illustrated Football Graham Neff: 'What drives winning is different now'
  3. 03 Tiger Illustrated Basketball Thursday Dillon Hunter Update
  4. 04 On3 Football House working on small revisions of Protect College Sports Act before vote
  5. 05 Tiger Illustrated Football Wednesday Evening Clemson Football Insider