Kirby Smart TO?

ronpolk

All-Conference
May 6, 2009
9,147
4,746
113
Where are you on this? If you watch the replay, it does look like Kirby is yelling “clapping” but he’s definitely motioning time out. I don’t think many coaches would have gotten this time out back.

 

Bhamdawg1725

Junior
Dec 15, 2023
144
272
63

The all-22 shows the truth. Kirby calls timeout and in running down sees AUs safety clapping. Which he can’t do. It should have been a delay of game on AU as the claps happened before Kirby called TO.
Kirby confirmed this in the post game. But the announcers, McElroy in particular were so convinced Kirby was just lying that it drove the narrative.

Now there’s an argument that the TO should have stood bc the clapping wasn’t noticed by officials. But the call ended up being correct-ish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog

Bhamdawg1725

Junior
Dec 15, 2023
144
272
63

The all-22 shows the truth. Kirby calls timeout and in running down sees AUs safety clapping. Which he can’t do. It should have been a delay of game on AU as the claps happened before Kirby called TO.
Kirby confirmed this in the post game. But the announcers, McElroy in particular were so convinced Kirby was just lying that it drove the narrative.

Now there’s an argument that the TO should have stood bc the clapping wasn’t noticed by officials. But the call ended up being correct-ish.

Additionally, there’s even audio on twitter during the video of Kirby saying “they’re 17n clapping. They can’t 17n clap”.
Not “I was clapping”.

Joking here… but it’s crazy how the broadcast can make a narrative just like news media.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,705
26,047
113

The all-22 shows the truth. Kirby calls timeout and in running down sees AUs safety clapping. Which he can’t do. It should have been a delay of game on AU as the claps happened before Kirby called TO.
Kirby confirmed this in the post game. But the announcers, McElroy in particular were so convinced Kirby was just lying that it drove the narrative.

Now there’s an argument that the TO should have stood bc the clapping wasn’t noticed by officials. But the call ended up being correct-ish.

So media hype making a big controversy over nothing. Strange, that's never happened before. I do agree the time out should have stood though. If the officials didn't call the penalty when it happened, it can't be reviewed or changed later and the time out should have stood.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MagnoliaHunter

Dawg1976

All-Conference
Aug 22, 2012
8,127
2,636
113
I hope we can upset there ***. Long shot I know. Not a fan of his constant whining.
 

Bobby Ricigliano

All-Conference
Jul 27, 2011
2,473
1,404
113
So media hype making a big controversy over nothing. Strange, that's never happened before. I do agree the time out should have stood though. If the officials didn't call the penalty when it happened, it can't be reviewed or changed later and the time out should have stood.
Not sure how I feel about the deal, but UGA did finish the game with an unused TO. So, the non-enforced TO wound up being inconsequential.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,705
26,047
113
I think it’s great. Freeze and all of Auburn feels like they got screwed last night, Smart looks like a giant douche. That’s about the best outcome you could hope for
Only downsides are Kirby Smart had to win and I had family members who are big Aubie fans who were at the game so I do feel sad for them. But that said, 17 Freeze, 17 Cohen, and 17 Auburn.
 

Dawgzilla2

All-Conference
Oct 9, 2022
2,039
2,371
113
If I were the ref, I would have given Kirby a choice of a timeout or a delay of game penalty. Certainly not just reset the clock.

But I didnt realize he was complaining about the Auburn players. So, maybe I would put a couple seconds on the play clock.
 

patdog

Heisman
May 28, 2007
56,705
26,047
113
If I were the ref, I would have given Kirby a choice of a timeout or a delay of game penalty. Certainly not just reset the clock.

But I didnt realize he was complaining about the Auburn players. So, maybe I would put a couple seconds on the play clock.
I would have given him a choice of a time out or a time out & and unsportsmanlike conduct penalty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dawgzilla2

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
3,795
2,750
113
Where are you on this? If you watch the replay, it does look like Kirby is yelling “clapping” but he’s definitely motioning time out. I don’t think many coaches would have gotten this time out back.


Auburn non TD not a big deal.

This is terrible.
 

paindonthurt

All-Conference
Apr 7, 2025
3,795
2,750
113

The all-22 shows the truth. Kirby calls timeout and in running down sees AUs safety clapping. Which he can’t do. It should have been a delay of game on AU as the claps happened before Kirby called TO.
Kirby confirmed this in the post game. But the announcers, McElroy in particular were so convinced Kirby was just lying that it drove the narrative.

Now there’s an argument that the TO should have stood bc the clapping wasn’t noticed by officials. But the call ended up being correct-ish.

Hold the 17 up. Kirbi called a timeout out.
FACT.

Why can’t the safety clap?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Crazy Cotton

Bhamdawg1725

Junior
Dec 15, 2023
144
272
63
Hold the 17 up. Kirbi called a timeout out.
FACT.

Why can’t the safety clap?
Specifically, if the offense uses a clap snap count (as UGA and most everyone does) it’s simulating a snap count and a delay of game on the defense. No warnings. Any clap. Delay of game: defense. That’s why Kirby lost his mind.

I believe our defense received one of these penalties this year, as well.
 

topbulldawg

Freshman
Jan 27, 2008
524
83
28
Kirby clearly was calling a TO. He may also have been talking about the clapping, but there is no denying he made the TO signal
 

IBleedMaroonDawg

All-American
Nov 12, 2007
25,536
9,744
113
Everyone knows he was obviously calling a timeout.

Unfortunately, he got away with it.

I don't like him either. But he wins, most of the time.
 

FreeDawg

Senior
Oct 6, 2010
3,861
642
98

The all-22 shows the truth. Kirby calls timeout and in running down sees AUs safety clapping. Which he can’t do. It should have been a delay of game on AU as the claps happened before Kirby called TO.
Kirby confirmed this in the post game. But the announcers, McElroy in particular were so convinced Kirby was just lying that it drove the narrative.

Now there’s an argument that the TO should have stood bc the clapping wasn’t noticed by officials. But the call ended up being correct-ish.

Since when can coaches call TO to argue a penalty and then get a free TO essentially? Did a safety 20 yards away from the play clap? Yes. Is that against the rules? Yes. Was he trying to simulate snap? No. Is that still illegal? Yes. All that said, Kirby 100% called TO and got bailed out in an absolutely BS way no other program in the SEC would have. It was either a penalty on Auburn or a Kirby TO. And Kirby saying he didn’t call TO makes him a hog head lying bastard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: patdog