Let's talk about Lebby's preseason quote...

RiverCityDawg

Well-known member
Dec 30, 2009
2,218
2,648
113
If you look at our talent, I think we're actually only one game behind where we should be. ASU and Arkansas are much better than all of us thought. We absolutely should not have lost to Toledo and we should have been more competitive against Florida and Arkansas for sure. I'm not sure how we could have expected much more against all the top 25 teams we played, we just aren't there as a program with all that happened the last 2 years.

I'm in the "I don't know camp" with Lebby, but need to see a lot in the next 60 days when it comes to fixing the DC mistake and upgrading talent in the portal. Next year is going to be tough again with the schedule, but we have to take steps in the right direction with at least 4 or 5 wins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maroon13

Dawgbite

Well-known member
Nov 1, 2011
6,440
5,085
113
This year is the culmination of a series of mistakes and unfortunate events that culminated into the current mess we have. The first domino was hiring Leach, this wasn’t a mistake but Leach gutted the roster of the type of players that 99% of other coaches need to be successful. This was fine as long as Leach was here and coaching. Leach’s death was very unfortunate in that he had completely changed the the roster and the timing of his death was doubly unfortunate. At the time of his death we had no AD, we really had no choice but to name Arnett head coach. What we should have done was name him interim for a year and kept all of Leach’s staff that we could and performed a real coaching search this past year. Allowing Arnett to completely replace the staff and change the team’s philosophy was a major mistake. Swapping Arnett for Lebby initially has not been an improvement, it may turn out to be the correct move but only time will tell. We needed stability and that comes from an experienced head coach not an assistant. We couldnt afford to experiment with an assistant coach and fail which exactly what year one has been. We have two options, keep Lebby and give him time to learn how to be a head coach and become successful or start over again with an experienced head coach. Neither option has a high probability of success in the short term with inferior talent which we currently have. We’re in an era of buying players when we’re are the poorest school in the poorest state. The deck is stacked against us. There isn’t a perfect solution.
 

85Bears

Well-known member
Jan 12, 2020
1,970
1,795
108
This year is the culmination of a series of mistakes and unfortunate events that culminated into the current mess we have. The first domino was hiring Leach, this wasn’t a mistake but Leach gutted the roster of the type of players that 99% of other coaches need to be successful. This was fine as long as Leach was here and coaching. Leach’s death was very unfortunate in that he had completely changed the the roster and the timing of his death was doubly unfortunate. At the time of his death we had no AD, we really had no choice but to name Arnett head coach. What we should have done was name him interim for a year and kept all of Leach’s staff that we could and performed a real coaching search this past year. Allowing Arnett to completely replace the staff and change the team’s philosophy was a major mistake. Swapping Arnett for Lebby initially has not been an improvement, it may turn out to be the correct move but only time will tell. We needed stability and that comes from an experienced head coach not an assistant. We couldnt afford to experiment with an assistant coach and fail which exactly what year one has been. We have two options, keep Lebby and give him time to learn how to be a head coach and become successful or start over again with an experienced head coach. Neither option has a high probability of success in the short term with inferior talent which we currently have. We’re in an era of buying players when we’re are the poorest school in the poorest state. The deck is stacked against us. There isn’t a perfect solution.
What players did Leach “gut” ?

I remember a major culture problem stemming from Sloppy Joe and Leach had to purge some bad apples who were too good to go to practice.

The mistakes were obvious and they started when Arnett was named permanent, the staff was fired and replaced with bums and
retreads, the offense was round peg-square holed to some primitive monstrosity, and a veteran 9-4 roster was wasted.
 

OG Goat Holder

Well-known member
Sep 30, 2022
8,502
8,046
113
What players did Leach “gut” ?

I remember a major culture problem stemming from Sloppy Joe and Leach had to purge some bad apples who were too good to go to practice.

The mistakes were obvious and they started when Arnett was named permanent, the staff was fired and replaced with bums and
retreads, the offense was round peg-square holed to some primitive monstrosity, and a veteran 9-4 roster was wasted.
They did this with Croom too. The sheep just went on and on about the dumpster fire talent, building a foundation, etc. they won’t ever acknowledge that even if the talent is low, it’s not as low as the record. And they also don’t seem to want to acknowledge that there is thing now known as the immediate eligibility transfer portal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 85Bears

85Bears

Well-known member
Jan 12, 2020
1,970
1,795
108
They did this with Croom too. The sheep just went on and on about the dumpster fire talent, building a foundation, etc. they won’t ever acknowledge that even if the talent is low, it’s not as low as the record. And they also don’t seem to want to acknowledge that there is thing now known as the immediate eligibility transfer portal.
Seriously, would Sloppy Joe have a better record than 2-10 ? I think he would He beat Toledo with Akrons roster
 

Barkman Turner Overdrive

Well-known member
May 28, 2006
3,714
1,504
113
Seriously, would Sloppy Joe have a better record than 2-10 ? I think he would He beat Toledo with Akrons roster
He would have gone 0-10 in the all SEC schedule of 2020. Recall how slow and out of shape the defense was in 2019. Could you imagine having no disciple SLOMO at the helm during COVID with no organized practices or workouts?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 85Bears

85Bears

Well-known member
Jan 12, 2020
1,970
1,795
108
He would have gone 0-10 in the all SEC schedule of 2020. Recall how slow and out of shape the defense was in 2019. Could you imagine having no disciple SLOMO at the helm during COVID with no organized practices or workouts?
For sure, that was culture rot. Joe had lost control
 

paindonthurt17

Active member
Jul 11, 2024
507
386
63
Super Troopers Yes GIF by Searchlight Pictures

100% true statement, we have 8 sacks this season the closest team to us is Alabama with 22, there are something like 6 players in the SEC who individually have more sacks than us. Coaches coach up players, I've seen none of that from Putzler and if he is then we are so deep in trouble from a personnel standpoint there is no hope!
It’s both
Hutzler isn’t good and we are awful talent wise on defense. AWFUL
 

LandingDog

New member
Jul 30, 2023
25
14
3
It’s funny how many people are saying give a 2-10 1st year coach 2 more years who were so quick to fire a 5-7 1st year coach. I don’t think Arnett was the long term answer by any means. But it’s not like last year was anywhere near the disaster this year is. And we’d be in much better position to make the move now & start with hopefully a good coach instead of being locked in with a clueless staff.
Two totally different situations. Arnett was a disaster. He had to go. Had he not totally dismantled the offense with a senior laden roster and QB room and coaching staff built for it, he might still be our coach.
 

Maroon13

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2022
2,009
2,046
113
This year is the culmination of a series of mistakes and unfortunate events that culminated into the current mess we have. The first domino was hiring Leach, this wasn’t a mistake but Leach gutted the roster of the type of players that 99% of other coaches need to be successful. This was fine as long as Leach was here and coaching. Leach’s death was very unfortunate in that he had completely changed the the roster and the timing of his death was doubly unfortunate. At the time of his death we had no AD, we really had no choice but to name Arnett head coach. What we should have done was name him interim for a year and kept all of Leach’s staff that we could and performed a real coaching search this past year. Allowing Arnett to completely replace the staff and change the team’s philosophy was a major mistake. Swapping Arnett for Lebby initially has not been an improvement, it may turn out to be the correct move but only time will tell. We needed stability and that comes from an experienced head coach not an assistant. We couldnt afford to experiment with an assistant coach and fail which exactly what year one has been. We have two options, keep Lebby and give him time to learn how to be a head coach and become successful or start over again with an experienced head coach. Neither option has a high probability of success in the short term with inferior talent which we currently have. We’re in an era of buying players when we’re are the poorest school in the poorest state. The deck is stacked against us. There isn’t a perfect solution.
Spot on.

All the coaching turnover is over and done. Here we are with a green coach. However even with that in mind, my biggest concern is the latter.

We had a $8million donation and $3million donation recently. Hints of more to come. Now let's see what Lebby can do in the portal. This off season will tell us a lot about our ability to rebuild.
 

patdog

Well-known member
May 28, 2007
49,485
13,845
113
Two totally different situations. Arnett was a disaster. He had to go. Had he not totally dismantled the offense with a senior laden roster and QB room and coaching staff built for it, he might still be our coach.
And yet still had a much better season than Lebby. I just think if you hire a guy, you just about have to give him 2 years unless it’s a total disaster. I’ve sat through a lot of seasons comparable to or worse than 2023. Never anything worse than 2024.
 

She Mate Me

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
9,945
6,500
113
I don't see it. As civildawg said, a good coach doesn't go 2-10 in their first season. 5-7, maybe. 6-6, perhaps. But not 2-10.

Frank Beamer went 2-9 and 3-8 in his first two years at Va Tech. Then he got them to 20 something straight bowl games including quite a few of the Sugar and Orange varieties.

Has no bearing on Lebby, but sweeping generalizations are generally wrong.
 

Turfdoc992

New member
Oct 3, 2022
45
24
8
The only sensible answer is that no, we don’t have the right guy. We’re 2-10 and haven’t been close to winning an SEC game.

The defense is laughable, and we look undisciplined. Mullen had us looking well-coached within a few games.

This may be unpopular and I don’t care, but the most reliable way to get this ship righted is to try to bring Mullen back soon. He’s done it before. Every other hiring option caries more risk.

“Rabble rabble, he can’t recruit in this era”

whatever recruiting he could get done would be a dam n sight better than what is occurring now.

Dude is a good coach, has name recognition, and would get good coaches and players to come here. Of course with leaders like Selmon and Keenum I doubt they view this as an option.
But you are bringing back a Dan Mullen who is 15 years older. Perhaps he is one that has more energy at 52 than at 35 but given what I see of him currently I don't think so. He had some juice then, I don't think he does now. But perhaps he is wiser now? Is he even relevant with current players? Would good assistants jump at the chance to come work for him - maybe - he will be far more reliant on them to bring the juice than 15 years ago.

If Lebby does not fired, or reassign Hutzler (he has experience with special teams and we are paying him) in the next week then he has lost credibility with me. Is Hutlzer Lebby's McCorvey?
 

civildawg88

Active member
Aug 22, 2012
2,361
485
72
Frank Beamer went 2-9 and 3-8 in his first two years at Va Tech. Then he got them to 20 something straight bowl games including quite a few of the Sugar and Orange varieties.

Has no bearing on Lebby, but sweeping generalizations are generally wrong.
Do you understand how long ago that was and how much the roster game has changed since then? It's not even comparable
 

She Mate Me

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
9,945
6,500
113
Do you understand how long ago that was and how much the roster game has changed since then? It's not even comparable

Since I've lived it, yeah I understand how long ago it was. I have little doubt Beamer would figure out how to be a good coach today.
 
Get unlimited access today.

Pick the right plan for you.

Already a member? Login