Garner, I think, might've been a really solid win (we'll know for sure later on in the season).
But here's what Simmons thinks of the rest of your schedule:
Wakefield - #73
Rocky Mount - #40
Panther Creek - #169
Athens Drive - #205
Cary - #186
Holly Springs - #78
Fuquay-Varina - #73
Apex Friendship - #303
Green Hope - #203
Apex - #305
Now, I don't know what you've been told (and it's already been established that I don't know anything about football), but I still feel fairly confident in assuring you that Middle Creek is NOT playing the "best teams in the area." Besides Garner (ranked #7), the only other team on your schedule ranked in the top 70 is a 3-single-A school with literally a third of Middle Creek's enrollment.
Again, if Middle Creek's goal is to win a bunch of games against overmatched opponents, then they are doing just fine. However, if they truly want to be taken seriously on a state level and be legitimately ranked in real state polls and be talked about with genuine respect on this or any other 4A message board, then there is a serious credibility problem with Middle Creek's schedule. And this credibility problem is amplified by getting smoked in the playoffs last year as a #1 seed, which just screams of being undeserving of the seed bestowed upon them.
The good news is, it's all fixable. Play somebody...beat somebody. Everything else will work itself out. The bad news is, Garner might be the only time they see a decent 4A team all season until they hit the playoffs. When you schedule like that, it doesn't give much opportunity to prove yourself. And if Garner loses some games....