Mount Rushmore of RU Athletics

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
7,742
4,252
66
Paul Robeson and Carli Lloyd no debate.
Then Grentz and Ashnault. Wicks and Cherry first two out.
 
Last edited:

e5fdny

Heisman
Nov 11, 2002
113,646
52,261
102
Paul Robeson and Carli Lloyd no debate.
Then Grentz and Ashnault. Wicks and Cherry first two out.
Sure there is.

Unless we’re including post grad work? I’m not in these threads.

It’s On the Banks only for me.
 

RUTGERS95

Heisman
Sep 28, 2005
25,937
34,792
113
Any list without Wicks is just wrong
absolutely, she may be the greatest RU athlete ever to be honest (accolades etc)

I did it based on excellence in their sport and as compared to others when they played
I added the after college and professional impact they had on our name

my 4, I don't think, can be beat as each was AA, set records, elevated the school and were well known after their playing days at RU and in some cases, are known globally.

Carli Lloyd
Lalas
Sellers
Wicks
 

G- RUnit

All-American
Sep 13, 2004
14,212
7,753
113
Objective
Paul Robeson
Carli Lloyd
Phil Sellers
Greg Schiano

Subjective
Brian Leonard
Anthony Ashnault
Greg Schiano
Todd Frazier

HM
Alexi Lalas
Sue Wicks
Ray Rice
Bob Lloyd
Jim Valvano
McCourty Brothers
Eddie Jordan
Roy Hinson certainly worthy of HM.
John Battle as well.
 

Shelby65

All-Conference
Apr 1, 2008
7,742
4,252
66
Objective
Paul Robeson
Carli Lloyd
Phil Sellers
Greg Schiano

Subjective
Brian Leonard
Anthony Ashnault
Greg Schiano
Todd Frazier

HM
Alexi Lalas
Sue Wicks
Ray Rice
Bob Lloyd
Jim Valvano
McCourty Brothers
Eddie Jordan
compare Schiano's accomplishments to Theresa Grentz's....
 

RUInsanityToo

All-American
May 5, 2006
9,398
9,625
113
Baseball - Jeff Torborg (Honorable mention - Eric Young, Fred Hill Sr.) - shout out to Todd Frazier
Football - Paul Robeson (Honorable Mention - Rice, Leonard, Burns, Schiano)
Basketball - Wicks / Sellers (Honorable Mention - Tom Young, Bailey) - very much hoping Pike in the future
Soccer - Lalas / Lloyd
 
  • Like
Reactions: rutger80

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,016
18,368
113
Players only

Lloyd
Wicks
Robeson
Rice

2nd team
Sellers
Leonard
Lalas
Knobloch - Lax HM AA in 2023, 1st team AA 2024
 

RUTGERS95

Heisman
Sep 28, 2005
25,937
34,792
113
Robeson, Wicks, Schiano, Sellers
c'mon (saying that smiling and joking like we're having a beer), any list that doesn't include Wicks (arguably the greatest and most accomplished collegiate athlete in RU history) is nuts but any list that omits Lalas and Lloyd is even worse! those two are global names in the biggest sport on the planet. You've got one slot to go...........

RU has no one in football, baseball, any olympic sport that warrants consideration for a rushmore type thing.

so who gets the last slot, who was more accomplished, did more for the university and carried the banner best?

If it's not Sellers then who?


For the Schiano crowd, why not Valvano, Burns, Hill Sr (rest in peace), Gentz, Vitale (who put together our best team ever)

Robeson? don't even need to touch that one
Rice? see above
Ray Lucas? lol
Cherry? (more deserving than any RU football alum imho with 6 pro bowls but no)


by the way, love these discussion as it's easy to pick 10-20 but 4 get's tight