Nate Oats?

Johnnie Africa

All-Conference
Feb 27, 2003
462
1,275
93
Do you want me to quote your posts in this very thread and have you decide if they are “condescending “ and “self righteous”? I just don’t see the need for the arguing and creating discord just because some fellow fans like Pope. That’s ridiculous — at least try to understand why they like Pope instead of assuming it’s only because he played here.

The only reason anyone would want to give Pope another year is because theyre mouth breathing mongoloids that hate Kentucky and kittens and puppies. It is an objective fact that the entire state will be in ruins the likes of which we’ve never seen if Mitch Barnhart isn’t allowed to hire his replacement IMMEDIATELY
 
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
Well no one has said any other reason on why they like pope. I don’t care how many posts you quote. And what discord? Am I not allowed to give my opinion? I just have to be happy we have pope until he’s gone so as not to cause discord on the rafters message board
Not at all.

- Person who wants Pope gone
- Person who wants Pope to stay

^ Those two views can co-exist without having to agree. It’s simple.. you try to understand the rationale behind the other.

I could probably give you a detailed reason right now why each of those “teams” believe what they believe. I could have a full-on debate between both positions because I took time to talk to people I disagree with. It isn’t hard to do….at all. If anything, by doing that, you can make your own arguments even better if you know the other side. It’s easy to strawman someone but if you really know the opposing arguments that’s a good thing.
 
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
The only reason anyone would want to give Pope another year is because theyre mouth breathing mongoloids that hate Kentucky and kittens and puppies. It is an objective fact that the entire state will be in ruins the likes of which we’ve never seen if Mitch Barnhart isn’t allowed to hire his replacement IMMEDIATELY
That’s pretty much the view a lot of folks have here. Definitely not condescending in any way lol
 

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
Not at all.

- Person who wants Pope gone
- Person who wants Pope to stay

^ Those two views can co-exist without having to agree. It’s simple.. you try to understand the rationale behind the other.

I could probably give you a detailed reason right now why each of those “teams” believe what they believe. I could have a full-on debate between both positions because I took time to talk to people I disagree with. It isn’t hard to do….at all. If anything, by doing that, you can make your own arguments even better if you know the other side. It’s easy to strawman someone but if you really know the opposing arguments that’s a good thing.
When I’m on here talking I’m not seeing myself as being in a debate with people, I’m just interacting with others man. Not arguing, it’s just conversation.
 

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
Dude. He had a good year last year. The guy can coach. Maybe he goes back to what worked last year. Maybe he makes staff changes. Coaches have bad years and fix things all the time. It's not unheard of.
I don’t consider last year that good, and we have the same problems we did last year defensively. That tells me it’s a pope problem and something that’s probably not gonna be fixed
 
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
When I’m on here talking I’m not seeing myself as being in a debate with people, I’m just interacting with others man. Not arguing
If you believe that the people who aren’t ready to fire Pope right this second “want Kentucky to suck” then I’d say you aren’t just interacting with people. That lack of understanding of their rationale tells me you clearly haven’t interacted with them other than dunking.
 

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
If you believe that the people who aren’t ready to fire Pope right this second “want Kentucky to suck” then I’d say you aren’t just interacting with people. That lack of understanding of their rationale tells me you clearly haven’t interacted with them other than dunking.
I already responded to that and said I was joking when I said that. My goodness
 

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
I may have missed that.

But I’m sure you understand that’s a common refrain around here.
I’ve seen it said, you gotta understand people are just extremely frustrated with the hire though, along with just not being relevant for like 7 years now. Most people didn’t want him in the first place, and it’s looking like for good reason unfortunately.
 
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
I’ve seen it said, you gotta understand people are just extremely frustrated with the hire though, along with just not being relevant for like 7 years now. Most people didn’t want him in the first place, and it’s looking like for good reason unfortunately.
And that’s fair. Just be mindful that the “Popeists” are just as frustrated as you. It’s one fanbase of people with all kinds of differences. I’ll bet you there isn’t a single person on this site that is happy with how things have been — not if they are true blue. I don’t think anyone saw this season coming.

You think 99% of the people who supported Pope won’t be supportive of another coach if he fails and gets replaced? Of course they would support the next coach. I think it’s best if it doesn’t come to that point, but if it does it does.
 

Phil_The_Music2

Heisman
Nov 29, 2010
3,044
12,418
113
I’ve seen it said, you gotta understand people are just extremely frustrated with the hire though, along with just not being relevant for like 7 years now. Most people didn’t want him in the first place, and it’s looking like for good reason unfortunately.
We are all frustrated. I get it. I actually understand where you aee coming from. What aggravates me is that most people in your camp call me a bad fan, or say I want to be Indiana, or that I want UK to suck simply because I think a coach should at least get 2 years.
 
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
We are all frustrated. I get it. I actually understand where you aee coming from. What aggravates me is that most people in your camp call me a bad fan, or say I want to be Indiana, or that I want UK to suck simply because I think a coach should at least get 2 years.
Bro, you don’t know how many times I’ve been called “the problem” with Kentucky basketball by people who have been very vocal about how wrong is to blame our fanbase for being toxic. Literally, like three comments above me, they’re responding to someone who say our fans are a net negative and they’re going off about it, saying we are the best fanbase and all this. Then, I say something they assume is supportive of Pope and say I’m everything that’s causing Kentucky basketball to fail. And they never even see the irony of that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phil_The_Music2

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
We are all frustrated. I get it. I actually understand where you aee coming from. What aggravates me is that most people in your camp call me a bad fan, or say I want to be Indiana, or that I want UK to suck simply because I think a coach should at least get 2 years.
I never said anyone was a bad fan. Are you saying that you’re in agreement that if things continue to go south this year there’s no point in a third?
 

Argonaut

Senior
Jan 3, 2026
291
599
93
I do wonder what some will say if Pope ends up doing well this season. Will it be

"Oops, my bad, he gets another year to prove himself"?
Not if he can’t prove himself in the transfer portal. Because he sure as heck isn’t getting any high school guys.

And to be honest, even if Pope manages to turn it around, but probably not enough to make the tournament, the NIL is likely to be cut drastically and at that point his next season is possibly doomed to fail before it even begins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Anon1739778738
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
I don’t see a problem with that. The criticism has been justified
Yes it has. I’ll answer the earlier question even though it wasn’t directed to me and say that for me, the answer can be different depending on what we mean:

- If I had a button I could press right now and change coaches of my choosing, I would absolutely press it and bring in Bruce Pearl.

- If I had a button I could press right now and change coaches but I don’t get to choose it, I would lean towards pressing it but I’m not certain.

- Am I dead set on firing Pope? No.

- Am I dead set on keeping Pope? No.

- Do I think he will be fired or let go after the season if things continue at about the same level as they have been up to this point this year? No.

- Do I think he will be fired or let go after the season if things get progressively worse throughout the season? Possibly.

- Am I going to support Pope and wish him the best? Absolutely.
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
28,426
3,625
113
I do wonder what some will say if Pope ends up doing well this season. Will it be

"Oops, my bad, he gets another year to prove himself"?
If history is any guide, if Pope were to turn it around at any point, some of the strongest critics will be posting how they always supported him and knew this would happen. A few will say, "I was wrong!" Of course, if Pope doesn't turn it around, some of the ones who supported him will claim that they didn't. Such is life on a chat board.
 

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
Yes it has. I’ll answer the earlier question even though it wasn’t directed to me and say that for me, the answer can be different depending on what we mean:

- If I had a button I could press right now and change coaches of my choosing, I would absolutely press it and bring in Bruce Pearl.

- If I had a button I could press right now and change coaches but I don’t get to choose it, I would lean towards pressing it but I’m not certain.

- Am I dead set on firing Pope? No.

- Am I dead set on keeping Pope? No.

- Do I think he will be fired or let go after the season if things continue at about the same level as they have been up to this point this year? No.

- Do I think he will be fired or let go after the season if things get progressively worse throughout the season? Possibly.

- Am I going to support Pope and wish him the best? Absolutely.
If things get worse I just don’t see how he wouldn’t get fired, but you’re probably right. I’d take Pearl, but I think I’d rather we go after oltzenberger or Lloyd. May not be realistic but they would be must calls to me
 
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
If things get worse I just don’t see how he wouldn’t get fired, but you’re probably right. I’d take Pearl, but I think I’d rather we go after oltzenberger or Lloyd. May not be realistic but they would be must calls to me
I love Otzelberger and Lloyd.

But did you see how different my answer was depending on all those different factors? I think you’d find that a lot of the “Popeists” would also have a lot of different answers depending on different situations. That’s why it’s good to understand. No one who loves the school wants it to fail. I certainly don’t post on here 1,000 times a day and drive my wife nuts talking hoops all day for no reason lol. I love UK basketball.

Best case scenario is that Pope rights the ship and then I don’t have any desire to press the button and maybe if he does enough you won’t want to press it either.

Make sense?
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
28,426
3,625
113
If things get worse I just don’t see how he wouldn’t get fired, but you’re probably right. I’d take Pearl, but I think I’d rather we go after oltzenberger or Lloyd. May not be realistic but they would be must calls to me
After Matt Dohtery went 8 and 20 in his second year, UNC gave him a third before they fired him. I know it is a different school, different AD, etc but I think it does illustrate that most coaches are going to be given at least 3 years before a change is made as long as it doesn't become a Billy G type situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NociHTTP

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
I love Otzelberger and Lloyd.

But did you see how different my answer was depending on all those different factors? I think you’d find that a lot of the “Popeists” would also have a lot of different answers depending on different situations. That’s why it’s good to understand. No one who loves the school wants it to fail. I certainly don’t post on here 1,000 times a day and drive my wife nuts talking hoops all day for no reason lol. I love UK basketball.

Best case scenario is that Pope rights the ship and then I don’t have any desire to press the button and maybe if he does enough you won’t want to press it either.

Make sense?
Yeah, I got you
 

TotheMoon88

Sophomore
Apr 12, 2024
216
149
43
After Matt Dohtery went 8 and 20 in his second year, UNC gave him a third before they fired him. I know it is a different school, different AD, etc but I think it does illustrate that most coaches are going to be given at least 3 years before a change is made as long as it doesn't become a Billy G type situation.
But should he have gotten a third year? No, and it was a waste to give it to him. We should learn from history
 
  • Like
Reactions: Argonaut

Argonaut

Senior
Jan 3, 2026
291
599
93
After Matt Dohtery went 8 and 20 in his second year, UNC gave him a third before they fired him. I know it is a different school, different AD, etc but I think it does illustrate that most coaches are going to be given at least 3 years before a change is made as long as it doesn't become a Billy G type situation.
That happened over 20 years ago when teams weren’t spending millions of dollars and didn’t have the transfer portal to make immediate impacts on the team. I see Pope’s 3rd season hangs on boosters’ willingness to support him another year. If he doesn’t get the necessary funds, he’s basically going into next year destined to fail because boosters were unwilling to provide.
 

Anon1759768907

All-Conference
Oct 6, 2025
1,151
1,724
113
That happened over 20 years ago when teams weren’t spending millions of dollars and didn’t have the transfer portal to make immediate impacts on the team. I see Pope’s possibility of getting a 3rd season relies on if boosters are willing to support him another year. If he doesn’t get the necessary funds, he’s basically going into next year destined to fail because boosters were unwilling to provide.
yeah well pope buying new teams every year isnt going to work so
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
28,426
3,625
113
But should he have gotten a third year? No, and it was a waste to give it to him. We should learn from history
On the other side, Dan Hurley was 35 wins and 29 losses at UConn in his first two years. His next 2 years he lost in the Round of 64 and then won 2 straight titles in his 5th and 6th years. Outside of his 2 title years he never even made a Sweet 16!

Of course we can play this game all day long but it just illustrates that coaches are going to get a LOT of grace in their first 2 or 3 years. Realistically, I don't see Pope getting fired unless things get even worse than they are now.
 
Jul 30, 2024
3,983
6,987
113
That happened over 20 years ago when teams weren’t spending millions of dollars and didn’t have the transfer portal to make immediate impacts on the team. I see Pope’s possibility of getting a 3rd season relies on if boosters are willing to support him another year. If he doesn’t get the necessary funds, he’s basically going into next year destined to fail because boosters were unwilling to provide.
Exactly. It will be decided by boosters/athletic department not the posters on here. No one really cares if I want year 3 or not. If Kelly Craft says “No year 3 from me” people will listen.
 

preacherfan

All-Conference
Oct 11, 2003
28,426
3,625
113
That happened over 20 years ago when teams weren’t spending millions of dollars and didn’t have the transfer portal to make immediate impacts on the team. I see Pope’s 3rd season hangs on boosters’ willingness to support him another year. If he doesn’t get the necessary funds, he’s basically going into next year destined to fail because boosters were unwilling to provide.
Serious question: Are we overvaluing the transfer portal to help traditional powers? Indiana is playing for the national title in FOOTBALL! Nebraska is undefeated in basketball. Vandy is undefeated in basketball and had a terrific year in football. UNC and Kansas are ranked 17th and 22 respectfully.

20 years ago we know that UNC was cheating probably along with other national powers and automatically got the top recruits in the country with the promise of free degrees. All this makes me wonder how the landscape of college sports might be changing?
 
Jan 10, 2015
18,319
30,307
62
So Pope was better, he got a Sweet 16 in his first year.
To be honest if we continue to take some loses which is for sure to happen... Pope would be regressing by not making the tournament in his 2nd year... These aren't good signs of a good coach if you're dealt 22 million dollars and you can't even make the tournament.
 

preston-lemasterpiece

All-Conference
Apr 15, 2025
804
1,567
91
If you believe that the people who aren’t ready to fire Pope right this second “want Kentucky to suck” then I’d say you aren’t just interacting with people. That lack of understanding of their rationale tells me you clearly haven’t interacted with them other than dunking.
They may not want UK to suck
But maybe they’re ok with UK sucking. They aren’t that bothered by UK sucking if they want Mark Pope back. IMO
we keep comparing him to legitimately good coaches who just had a rough year 2. Pope isn’t like that and we all know it. A 12+ loss season isn’t a blip or an outlier for him. It’s the norm. It’s who he is as a coach