Yea, that doesn't make a lot of sense with revenue sharing. If they're going to be paid, they should be able to enter into multiyear agreements. Could still leave the option to transfer with pentalties; maybe the acquiring school has to pay NIL back or something. Let G5 take penalty free, so if it's really a toxic situation, players can drop to G5.Transfer Liberty still a thing just sux.
That’s the thing. On the surface this doesn’t change anything. We will still have NIL Collectives. Now maybe schools are less likely to encourage donations to the collective bc they need to make up the shortfall. All this does is try to stem lawsuits.Ole Miss will figure a way around it
Bingo! Just keeps getting worse and worse, it’s amazing that so many are trying so hard to ruin this whole deal. Well, we know why, because they are profiting.All this does is try to stem lawsuits
#4 is the most inportant bc unlimited transfers drive up the NIL cost. But more importantly we have had our success signing the overlooked guys Now we sign them and show everyone they are good and they can leave.Putting aside my distaste for this subject in general, I guess the best case for State would be:
1. The same cap value for all P5.
2. No outside NIL
3. Some formula that allows variation between sports (i.e., we're not required to give a track and field athlete equal money to a football player)
4. Some sort of limitation on transfers
The worst case would be:
1. No cap (or a percentage-of-budget-based cap)
2. No limits on outside NIL
3. Mandatory equal payments to all athletes
4. No limits on transfers
My two sats:Putting aside my distaste for this subject in general, I guess the best case for State would be:
1. The same cap value for all P5.
2. No outside NIL
3. Some formula that allows variation between sports (i.e., we're not required to give a track and field athlete equal money to a football player)
4. Some sort of limitation on transfers
The worst case would be:
1. No cap (or a percentage-of-budget-based cap)
2. No limits on outside NIL
3. Mandatory equal payments to all athletes
4. No limits on transfers
Once the players create a union, that can be negotiated. Until then, it's illegalYea, that doesn't make a lot of sense with revenue sharing. If they're going to be paid, they should be able to enter into multiyear agreements. Could still leave the option to transfer with pentalties; maybe the acquiring school has to pay NIL back or something. Let G5 take penalty free, so if it's really a toxic situation, players can drop to G5.
This. The players can’t get TV money without giving something back. Portal, contracts, something has to be in exchange for TV money.All that does is pay players more, it doesn't help schools at all.
I bet they can. It's a 17ed up system, but the players have all the leverage. The courts are going to force the schools to open up the TV revenue for the players. Just like they forced full free agency. The schools have nothing to bargain with to get the players to give anything up.This. The players can’t get TV money without giving something back. Portal, contracts, something has to be in exchange for TV money.
Actually the schools do have some leverage, but i don't think they can actually cooperate enough to use it. Colleges basically entered into a gentleman's agreement with the NFL to function as the farm system without it costing the NFL a dime, because it gives colleges their pick of the most talented players for 3 years for the "cost" of tuition. Only people not getting a (legal) cut in that deal is the players.I bet they can. It's a 17ed up system, but the players have all the leverage. The courts are going to force the schools to open up the TV revenue for the players. Just like they forced full free agency. The schools have nothing to bargain with to get the players to give anything up.
Yep, and I say that even as MSU has probably had an overall net benefit from the portal, but I don't think that will last forever.#4 is the most inportant bc unlimited transfers drive up the NIL cost. But more importantly we have had our success signing the overlooked guys Now we sign them and show everyone they are good and they can leave.
I don’t ever see a time with no outside NIL. The NFL doesn’t even have that.