Toggle sidebar

NCPreps Elite 8 1A Rankings Week 9

D

Deana_King_rivals106402

All-American
May 31, 2001
258,633
8,516
0
Here are the latest rankings in the NCPreps.com Elite 8 for Week 9 of the NC high school football season.

These rankings are sponsored by XPloderBar.


NCPREPS.COM ELITE 8 1A RANKINGS
1. Tarboro (7-0)
2. East Surry (7-0)
3. Holmes (6-0)
4. Murphy (6-1)
5. Mitchell (7-0)
6. Robbinsville (7-0)
7. Princeton (6-0)
8. Swain County (7-0)
 
  • Like
Reactions: wncbowhunter and mbdfan_rivals121259
Old Mountaineer

Old Mountaineer

All-American
Nov 4, 2018
3,964
5,662
113
NCPREPS/Maxprep/Simmons/Adjusted

1 Tarboro/Tarboro/Tarboro/Tarboro
2 East Surry/ES/ES/Robbinsville
3 Holmes/Robbinsville/Holmes/East Surry
4 Murphy/Holmes/Mitchell/Murphy
5 Mitchell/Swain/Robbinsville/Princeton
6 Robbinsville/Mitchell/Murphy/Swain
7 Princeton /Polk /Princeton/ Holmes
8 Swain / Murphy/ Polk/ Polk
9 ......../ Princeton/ TJ/ Mitchell
10 ....../ Mt Airy/ Swain / Mt Airy
Simmons has Mt Airy @ #11
Maxprep & NCHSAA adjusted has Thomas Jefferson @ # 12
 
  • Like
Reactions: mbdfan_rivals121259, Mitchell county mountie and wncbowhunter
M

mbdfan_rivals121259

All-Conference
Mar 17, 2007
25,690
4,313
0
Mitchell county mountie said:
I agree. Flip Princeton and Swain and it would look good. Brian is right up there with one other fan in NC with the amount of work he puts into his football knowledge.
Click to expand...
NCHSAA should take Maxpreps, NCPreps, Simmons and CarolinaPreps, average them and use that for their rankings.
 
Last edited:
B

btango

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2003
120,102
4,779
0
mbdfan said:
NCHSAA should take Maxpreps, NCPreps, Simmons and Carolina Preps, average them and use that for their rankings.
Click to expand...

Every team has to be ranked to use fir playoff seeding. NC Preps only does the top 8.
 
N

NWWatchdog

Senior
Feb 21, 2003
1,214
421
40
Mitchell county mountie said:
The adjusted rankings is a joke. Not just because they have Mitchell low either...
Click to expand...
I think the frustrating thing is that they are quite different than the regular Maxpreps rankings and there’s no justification as to why. What criteria determines changes from regular Maxpreps? Why the lack of transparency? I understand Maxpreps has a “trademarked” formula that they won’t release, but why won’t the NCHSAA release their justifications behind their differences?
 
  • Like
Reactions: CPC4LIFE3
Old Mountaineer

Old Mountaineer

All-American
Nov 4, 2018
3,964
5,662
113
mbdfan said:
Simmons looks the most accurate overall to me, although I think Swain is too low.
Click to expand...

Of course in the end only one will count Nchsaa adjusted. But at least 1A rankings are closer together the they are in 2A right now for example Midway is #32 & #40 in Maxprep & Simmons but #8 in Adjusted and Anson is #6 & #7 in the other two but #25 in adjusted.
 
B

btango

All-Conference
Nov 5, 2003
120,102
4,779
0
NWWatchdog said:
I think the frustrating thing is that they are quite different than the regular Maxpreps rankings and there’s no justification as to why. What criteria determines changes from regular Maxpreps? Why the lack of transparency? I understand Maxpreps has a “trademarked” formula that they won’t release, but why won’t the NCHSAA release their justifications behind their differences?
Click to expand...

NCHSAA has the winning margin aka score differential removed. I thought they should have used 20 to 22 points. Thought this was the only item they had changed which happened after the initial season started if I am not mistaken.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Old Mountaineer
T

The Fact Jack

Redshirt
Dec 10, 2008
121
39
0
The winning margin should not count. Forfeits and running clocks hurt some teams. A forfeit counts as a Two to Zero win.
 
V

vikandpiratepride

Sophomore
Sep 14, 2012
671
197
0
Tarboro’s out of conference schedule is really helping them.
Rocky mount-5-2
Washington 6-1
Northern Nash 5-2
North Edgecombe 5-3
Southwest Edgecombe 6-1
 
  • Like
Reactions: RudeBoyyyz
T

The Fact Jack

Redshirt
Dec 10, 2008
121
39
0
Yes Washington (2aa) SWE (2aa) and North Edgecombe (1a) are all in first place in there conference. Probably will win them. Rocky Mount (3a) will finish 1st or second behind only Southern Nash in there’s.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RudeBoyyyz
E

ESODcards

Junior
Nov 13, 2016
615
288
0
Does anyone know how the adjusted ratings are even done? Or does the state just do it with everyone in the dark!
 
Old Mountaineer

Old Mountaineer

All-American
Nov 4, 2018
3,964
5,662
113
ESODcards said:
Does anyone know how the adjusted ratings are even done? Or does the state just do it with everyone in the dark!
Click to expand...
Don't know thier exact mathematical formula but they take the Maxprep computer rankings and send them to a San Francisco-based company that stores schedules, rosters and stats online then they provide an adjusted number to the NCHSAA each week. One thing they do take out is margin of victory.
 
T

Thunder_struck8712

All-American
Oct 5, 2016
4,954
6,174
0
They won't say. Coaches have asked time and time again. They even have put Que on the spot at the coaches clinic before and they won't say. Its a bit like the BCS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gdawg74
S

SlickRich28120

All-Conference
Nov 4, 2006
1,279
1,608
113
Looks about right to me, my team is where they should be , 11th or 12th. I know we have heard it all year but the cards are for real and a real threat to the vikes. Coming to the swain Murphy game to get a look at these two up close. Also lot of interest in the heritage and Mitchell game. If Mitchell goes and Murphy go big this year the west is a dog fight. If east Surry gets pushed east it’s a travesty.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom