New coach

Ludd

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
3,310
3,756
113
During this search I've taken some time to look at boards from the schools that some of these coaching candidates are currently - for the most part, the A&Ms Bamas NDs have shown no worry at all. BYU fans were freaking out, but seemed ready to rally the troops.

Iowa State fans don't seem to care - and not that they want him gone, they want him to stay. But it's a sense of "oh, good for him" and "that would be a great fit" "we got our money's worth!". Which seems so bizarre to me? Maybe that's why he's been there so long? No pressure. These people are just happy to be playing. Great if we win 8-10 games. There's no real drive for winning.
In other words, they’re being sane, realistic fans…wow, that’s a change of pace.
 
  • Like
Reactions: doctornick

TheWizardofCamelot

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2015
956
1,229
93
You are aware of the who the two teams playing in the ACC championship game this weekend are, no? James doesn't need to win the Big Ten with VTs roster.

UVA's last 4 recruiting classes were 46, 70, 65 and 64. Their 2026 class is in the 90s. That is what is carrying UVA to the playoff out of the ACC this season.
Right. The ACC is dogshit. They might not even get a team in. They have no respect nationally.

Sure, James might win the worst conference in America by default. But that doesnt guarantee him a playoff spot anymore. And besides, how fun will it be to see him play OSU in the first round. Hello darkness my old friend.
 

fairgambit

All-American
Aug 20, 2010
2,287
6,814
113
I wouldn't like to fire-bomb Joe Paterno's widow's house. No.

What I would like? I would like some "409ers" to acknowledge that after 14 years, they have been 100% unsuccessful in meaningfully changing anybody's opinion as regards Joe Paterno's culpability as regards Sandusky.

Give up already "409ers." You lost. And you don't get to hold the football program or University hostage either.
I disagree as to Joe and Sandusky. As a lawyer, I regularly deal with people from all across the country, many of whom are college football fans. I have seen a significant change in perception toward Joe's "culpability", so much so that I am amazed by it. From Tuscaloosa to Eugene, views are far more positive than years ago. Now, admittedly I am generally dealing with people who are objective and have no agendas, but still, I find their views interesting.
 
Last edited:

SoCalLion

Sophomore
Jun 23, 2022
104
150
43
I disagree as to Joe and Sandusky. As a lawyer, I regularly deal with people from all across the country, many of whom are college football fans. I have seen a significant change in perception toward Joe's "culpability", so much so that I am amazed by it. Now, admittedly I am generally dealing with people who are objective and generally have no agendas, but still, I find their views inte resting.

Your anecdotal experiences are 100% different than mine then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUSignore

Fred8811

Sophomore
Aug 27, 2006
212
123
43
He has been there since the 2016 season and has had a few opportunities to leave. I am not sure how good those opportunities have been in terms of a top ten job like ours. I am encouraged that he is from Ohio and he seems to bring an element of toughness and grit that I think we have lacked under Franklin.

It could take a lot to pry him out of Ames. He and his family are settled there and the school likes him as evidenced by the recent contract extension. He has security in Ames.

I agree that he would be a good hire. My concern and admittedly I have not researched this aspect but how successful has he been developing QBs and a good or innovative offense? That is a kind of difficult to assess because he has lacked the talent that we have had. Also wondering how strong of a recruiter he is although that facet has changed with the NIL era. However, as a new coach in a new area of the country you will need to sell yourself, your vision, the university, the program, etc.
More $ likely.
 

fastlax16

Senior
Jan 1, 2014
404
488
63
Yep, I'm making Matt Campbell top 5-10 paid coaches in America. Make it so it's an absolute no brainer.

Yup. Everything that's happening is a problem, but its a problem that can mostly/somewhat be solved by money. Which is the best kind of problem to have, if you have money, which we do.

Right. The ACC is dogshit. They might not even get a team in. They have respect.

Sure, James might win the worst conference in America by default. But that doesnt guarantee him a playoff spot anymore. And besides, how fun will it be to seem him play OSU in the first round. Hello darkness my old friend.

SMU got in as the ACCCG loser last year. Franklin is making the playoff if he gets VT to 2 losses or wins the ACC with 3. The media will eat it up. They open up with 2 cream puffs and then they play maryland, who I expect him to blast into the stone age. Then they're off to the races.
 

Nitanee1234

Freshman
Dec 1, 2025
56
99
18
I wouldn't like to fire-bomb Joe Paterno's widow's house. No.

What I would like? I would like some "409ers" to acknowledge that after 14 years, they have been 100% unsuccessful in meaningfully changing anybody's opinion as regards Joe Paterno's culpability as regards Sandusky.

Give up already "409ers." You lost. And you don't get to hold the football program or University hostage either.

Well if a person is unwilling to stand up for their principles and unwilling to defend a great coach (and even better human) just because they want to “move on”, then I wouldn’t want to be associated with such a person.

And how are 409ers holding the program hostage?
 

Alphalion75

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
14,668
3,674
113
Nobody ---- not me, not Pat Kraft, not the BoT ---- thinks that Terry Smith should be automatically DQed because he "is tied to" Joe Paterno. Nobody cares that Terry Smith is a former JoePa player.

What DO we care about? That he resurfaced the issue as regards JoePa's culpability as regards Sandusky, unannounced, by wearing that 409 pin on National TV vs. Nebraska.

I was fine with talking about JoePa and Sandusky in 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015. But that's all over a DECADE ago. Nothing good comes in resurfacing that issue 14 years after the fact now.
Actually I believe Terry's was simply acknowledging Joe for his 409 wins. Many fans wear those buttons on game day. Fans in Bama wear houndstooth hats and accessories to pay respects to Bear Bryant. I see nothing wrong with what Terry did.
 

fastlax16

Senior
Jan 1, 2014
404
488
63
Actually I believe Terry's was simply acknowledging Joe for his 409 wins. Many fans wear those buttons on game day. Fans in Bama wear houndstooth hats and accessories to pay respects to Bear Bryant. I see nothing wrong with what Terry did.

BS. Terry knew what he was doing with the pin. If he wasn't, and he didn't understand what the optics were, then he isn't media savvy enough for the position. It might actually end up working out for him because of how Kraft is bungling this, but it was absolutely done to drum up support.
 

MacNit

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,148
2,045
113
I wouldn't like to fire-bomb Joe Paterno's widow's house. No.

What I would like? I would like some "409ers" to acknowledge that after 14 years, they have been 100% unsuccessful in meaningfully changing anybody's opinion as regards Joe Paterno's culpability as regards Sandusky.

Give up already "409ers." You lost. And you don't get to hold the football program or University hostage either.
Request denied, Skippy!
 

Alphalion75

All-Conference
Oct 24, 2001
14,668
3,674
113
BS. Terry knew what he was doing with the pin. If he wasn't, and he didn't understand what the optics were, then he isn't media savvy enough for the position. It might actually end up working out for him because of how Kraft is bungling this, but it was absolutely done to drum up support.
Frankly I have more respect for Terry for not caring what the media thinks. The man probably has more integrity in his pinky than all of the combined media.
 

fairgambit

All-American
Aug 20, 2010
2,287
6,814
113
Your anecdotal experiences are 100% different than mine then.
Apparently, but when you use a phrase like "100% unsuccessful in meaningfully changing anybody's opinion" you leave yourself open to charges of agenda bias. No matter, I have a 3PM call to an attorney in Tallahassee. I will seek his opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OUIrPSU

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
384
478
63
I wouldn't like to fire-bomb Joe Paterno's widow's house. No.

What I would like? I would like some "409ers" to acknowledge that after 14 years, they have been 100% unsuccessful in meaningfully changing anybody's opinion as regards Joe Paterno's culpability as regards Sandusky.

Give up already "409ers." You lost. And you don't get to hold the football program or University hostage either.
Hostage, looks like the only option, and they are choosing no one. Rather kill the program than backtrack on 1 % on a 15 year old narrative
 

Player2BNamedL8r

All-Conference
Jan 3, 2012
1,037
2,106
113
  • Like
Reactions: Midnighter

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
384
478
63
Nobody ---- not me, not Pat Kraft, not the BoT ---- thinks that Terry Smith should be automatically DQed because he "is tied to" Joe Paterno. Nobody cares that Terry Smith is a former JoePa player.

What DO we care about? That he resurfaced the issue as regards JoePa's culpability as regards Sandusky, unannounced, by wearing that 409 pin on National TV vs. Nebraska.

I was fine with talking about JoePa and Sandusky in 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015. But that's all over a DECADE ago. Nothing good comes in resurfacing that issue 14 years after the fact now.
So your thinking is we need to ignore the PSU history and players from 1950-2011 to insure Sandusky doesn’t come up?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MacNit

Grant Green

All-Conference
Jan 21, 2004
3,380
4,642
113

SIAP - the CDT (grain of salt) is reporting that they “have expressed interest or had conversations with three notable names who are currently the focus of the search — Cleveland Browns offensive coordinator Tommy Rees, Ohio State defensive coordinator Matt Patricia and Iowa State head coach Matt Campbell.” Also reporting that Smith is “on the outside looking in.”
Please no Rees or Patricia. I think I'd rather have Daboll. Definitely prefer Campbell to those.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Player2BNamedL8r

SoCalLion

Sophomore
Jun 23, 2022
104
150
43
Hostage, looks like the only option, and they are choosing no one. Rather kill the program than backtrack on 1 % on a 15 year old narrative

1% my butt.

The "409ers" want the whole enchilada. Statue back up, stadium named after Paterno, announcers fawning about JoePa every game, him appearing in videos a dozen times a game, et cetera.

You can't give the "409ers" 1% because they'll literally NEVER shut up in wanting more, more, more, more, more, more, more.
 

PSUSignore

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
1,448
2,294
113
Franklin happened to Chesney and every other person known to be interested in the Job. Word is Franklin had direct conversations with most of them lamenting Kraft and the entire hierarchy at PS. Lamenting in it's context here is a polite term to how those conversations went.
There's got to be more to the story between Kraft and Franklin then. I can't see Franklin being this upset just over not getting a new contact last year and getting fired, he knows that's part of the business. Some other factors must have happened behind the scenes to break the so-called alignment Franklin had been touting.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
384
478
63
These kids are going to play for many coaches after they leave PSU.
The problem is not their loyalty to Franklin or Terry. That’s natural and will dissipate once the future plan is in place and shared. The problem is Kraft is acting like an idiot, and not only is giving them nothing to believe in, he’s sabotaging their chances in 2026 by not putting anything in place
 
  • Like
Reactions: doctornick

PSUForever

Senior
Feb 17, 2007
914
949
93
Dan Mullen himself has stated that he does not like recruiting. Would not hire him at PSU. Here is one of a variety of direct quotes from Dan during his time at Florida: “I hate recruiting. I absolutely hate it. … I love coaching football. I love being on the field, I love being in the meeting rooms, I love practice, I love the games. Recruiting is the worst part of the job, by far.”
This is why he cannot hold a power football job like Florida. As you know, our next coach is going to have to love recruiting and love going into the portal . Dan would be a very hard pass for me.
Hire a top flight GM. I am not sure about Mullen but I lean toward more of a "ball coach" and not a CEO who loses every big game like we had before.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Macdad10

WaffleShopper

Senior
Sep 20, 2023
416
775
93
Yup. Everything that's happening is a problem, but its a problem that can mostly/somewhat be solved by money. Which is the best kind of problem to have, if you have money, which we do.



SMU got in as the ACCCG loser last year. Franklin is making the playoff if he gets VT to 2 losses or wins the ACC with 3. The media will eat it up. They open up with 2 cream puffs and then they play maryland, who I expect him to blast into the stone age. Then they're off to the races.
Just like we were off to the races after our 3 cupcakes to start the year with all our talent?

2026: Va, @ Clemson, @ Miami, GT, Pitt
2027: @ ND, @ Va, @ Lou, @ SMU, Clemson, Miami
2028: ND, Va, @ Miami, @ Pitt, FSU, Lou, SMU

Some of those teams probably won’t be that great but pretending 2 losses every year is doable is crazy. 2027 is going to be painful.
 

Psumatt85

Senior
Jan 5, 2002
384
478
63
1% my butt.

The "409ers" want the whole enchilada. Statue back up, stadium named after Paterno, announcers fawning about JoePa every game, him appearing in videos a dozen times a game, et cetera.

You can't give the "409ers" 1% because they'll literally NEVER shut up in wanting more, more, more, more, more, more, more.
Ok , I’ll bite. So hiring Terry Smith( which I agree was a bad option until I realized we had a clueless AD), means it will be stipulated that the statue goes up, the stadium name is changed, the stadium experience videos and the agenda of the tv announcers who are not employed by Penn state all change,? Therefore, it is better to not have a 2026 class, and we might lose a large portion of players to the portal, this is all ok because it might be viewed as a small win for the fans of the winningest coach in college football history.
Just trying to ensure I’m clear.
 

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
944
1,734
92
Here we go getting crazy

Rojas scrubbed his social medias of anything PSU a week ago. Are we supposed to believe his threat? All of this is making us look like a dysfunctional bunch. I hope it doesn’t scare away Campbell. I’m OK with Terry taking the job, but I’m also OK with the university believing that Matt Campbell is the better candidate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Binder74 and LB99