New coach

Zone-Blitz

Junior
Oct 27, 2013
107
207
43
I like this list, though I would flip Diaz with Lea. I also am not enamored of Hartline.
Diaz should be near the top, i don’t understand the fascination with Elko at all. Manny has proven to be a winning head coach, great defensive coordinator and fits the Penn State culture perfectly. I don’t know how Elko brings anything more to the table than Manny? Hartline can bring skill position talent but we don’t know how he’ll handle anything else. Lea, Key, Campbell are all guys who I’m sure will win the press conference but not sure they move the needle on anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NewEra 2026

Rudy4526

Senior
Oct 13, 2010
600
657
93
Diaz should be near the top, i don’t understand the fascination with Elko at all. Manny has proven to be a winning head coach, great defensive coordinator and fits the Penn State culture perfectly. I don’t know how Elko brings anything more to the table than Manny? Hartline can bring skill position talent but we don’t know how he’ll handle anything else. Lea, Key, Campbell are all guys who I’m sure will win the press conference but not sure they move the needle on anything.
I agree. Also out of all the candidates he seems most attainable other than coordinators.
 

Itraindogs

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2024
798
1,504
93
I agree. Also out of all the candidates he seems most attainable other than coordinators.
Penn State could do a lot worse than Manny, though I prefer a coach that comes from the offensive side of the ball and can attract and develop QBs (Brohm, who I do not think comes).
 

WaffleShopper

Senior
Sep 20, 2023
267
463
63
His team is ranked 2nd ... I guess that's a big step to a title? One thing is for sure, he took over the losingest P4 program in America ... and if 2 years ago someone said , "He'll have them in the playoffs in year one", I would've responded with "that's a big step".
Yup it’s a big step going from great to winning a title as Penn State fans know too well. Indiana was in the top 5 last year then got humbled by both OSU and Notre Dame. We were also #2 this year and look what happened. I’ll be cheering for them but until they do it at the end of the season and in the playoffs then being ranked high doesn’t mean all that much.
 

DaytonRickster

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
1,645
1,812
113
and, like I tried to say but maybe I didn't shout it loud enough, Vandy has pumped in a ton more money than when Franklin was around.
Yes they are working major facilities upgrades and a stadium renovation. I think the stadium reno might be completed or close to being completed.
 

Connorpozlee

All-American
Aug 29, 2013
2,747
5,266
113
Like a reverse spelling bee.
”What do you think of NIL?”
”N I L, nil. I’ll use it in a sentence. The chances of me not cheating on my wife with a coed are nil. Where do I sign!?!?!?”
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

Catch1lion

All-Conference
Oct 12, 2021
2,804
4,253
113
Raven's OC seems like an interesting possibility for one of the better jobs if he is interested in CFB. Saw him on the possible Auburn list on the Athletic.
Baltimore Ravens offensive coordinator Todd Monken: With the Ravens struggling this season, perhaps the 59-year-old Monken could become an option for colleges again. He won two national championships as Georgia’s offensive coordinator from 2020 to ’22. In his only college head coaching stint, he took over a winless Southern Miss team in 2013 and won nine games two years later, before leaving for an NFL assistant job. He has also coached at Oklahoma State and LSU, among other places.
 

WSTLion87

All-Conference
Oct 10, 2021
794
1,712
93
Too cold for his hair?

😞
Could be and again... I like Manny very much. When he was DC we were 21-4 over that stretch. You can make the argument that he WAS the Head Coach, then. The thing is I just get the feeling he's not being magnified at Duke and the ACC overall pretty much stinks but that isn't his fault. I would consider him if he was interested but perhaps as a fourth or fifth choice. Definitely not a first or second!
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobPSU92

84lion

Senior
Oct 7, 2021
611
993
93
I've seen this same story at multiple sites through I somewhat view it with a high level of doubt because it feels like click fodder (even for Yahoo! who notes the bulk of that story is from Audacy and Awful Announcing--I wouldn't consider either as a gold standard of journalism). My rule of thumb is if breaking or insider news like this is shared and it's from someone you've never heard of--take it with a grain of salt.

The other reason I am not putting a lot of stock in these discussions with Meyer is because the whole issue on why it broke down is the exact reason many of us on message boards and pseudo-journalists/columnists have noted as a negative for Meyer (dealing with NIL).

Now setting all those doubts aside, let's say these two meetings did happen. What could Meyer have said about NIL that would have turned PSU away from him? Clearly, he's observed the blowback with Dabo and his unwillingness to embrace transfers (and I'm guessing NIL too?). Meyer may be a lot of things but I don't think he's dumb enough to not recognize NIL has to be major factor when building and maintaining a team. I suspect he is still close to OSU who have been big players in NIL since it was legal so it would be odd for him not throw out an answer that would have turned off PSU. The only thing I can think of is:
  1. Meyer wanted to bring in his own GM to handle NIL management
  2. Meyer wanted to handle NIL himself without a GM
  3. Kraft indicated he would manage NIL himself
  4. Kraft indicated he would appoint the GM not Meyer
Given the reporting puts in on PSU not liking Meyer's answers, it would lead me to believe it was #1 or #2. But who the heck knows!
The more I see of this “story” the more it sounds like fiction designed as “cover” for the real story. The story makes no sense. Meyer wants to make a comeback at Penn State, interviews with PSU, and they rebuff him over…of all things…an answer to how he’d handle NIL. That, to me, is ridiculous, given that Meyer coached at Florida (you know he handled “recruit” money there, and almost certainly at tOSU as well), and in any case would have (as FHCJF did) a GM to manage NIL money.

My thought is that Meyer would like the position but is in no hurry. There will be a LOT of coaching changes this go-round. I think Meyer wants to wait until the first deals are done to see what numbers come out. I don’t think he wants to work for cheap (I don’t blame him). Both sides needed a cover, and the concerns about Meyer’s coaching experience being pre-NIL were made to order.

In addition to the points you made, I wonder if someone supposedly whispering in Kraft’s ear is a vehement anti-Meyer voice. Just need some strong cocktails at the next meeting to turn them around.

Someone once said, “it ain’t over ‘till the fat lady sings.” Penn State would look like a bunch of idiots if Meyer came offering his services and they rejected him.

And Yahoo! Is about as far from being a “gold standard of journalism” as you can get.
 

PSUForever

Senior
Feb 17, 2007
688
619
93
Diaz should be near the top, i don’t understand the fascination with Elko at all. Manny has proven to be a winning head coach, great defensive coordinator and fits the Penn State culture perfectly. I don’t know how Elko brings anything more to the table than Manny? Hartline can bring skill position talent but we don’t know how he’ll handle anything else. Lea, Key, Campbell are all guys who I’m sure will win the press conference but not sure they move the needle on anything.
We need a guy who can develop and coach up QBs.