New coach

WestSideLion

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
4,448
4,911
113
I don't think he was ever coming here. It's more likely he talked to Kraft as a consultant and expressed his disdain for how NIL is structured and gave PSU some names of candidates he would consider if he were making the decision
That's a highly plausible take, IMO. I bet Kraft made a lot of calls in this vein. It's a low-pressure way of kicking the tires on the most accomplished coaches out there. Ex: Meyer and Saban. And if the convo turns to them being interested, then you explore it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JVP_Yahweh

LMTLION

All-Conference
Mar 20, 2008
609
1,029
92
True, though Brohm does not appear to belong to this group. He does not appear to be a "next higher rung is better' kind of guy. A multimillionaire driving a 2004 Honda Accord for 20 years is telling. Of course, we are completely speculating but Brohm is from Louisville, his and his extended family are from Louisville, he played at Louisville and is making good money at Louisville. And though I grant you that he is ultra-competitive and tough as nails (you should see the clip of him almost getting decapitated during a game and him returning the following game) his very competitive "alpha male" psyche may very well translate in a a desire to will his alma mater to the pinnacle of the sport. That would truly be drive. In any case, simply spitballing over morning coffee.
And he very well could be going to the playoffs, further complicating the ability or willingness we have to completely destroy our recruiting and portal classes on the hope and prayer he says yes. Personally, I do not think he or Elko are worth that gamble.
 

Fred8811

Freshman
Aug 27, 2006
122
54
28
Diaz should be near the top, i don’t understand the fascination with Elko at all. Manny has proven to be a winning head coach, great defensive coordinator and fits the Penn State culture perfectly. I don’t know how Elko brings anything more to the table than Manny? Hartline can bring skill position talent but we don’t know how he’ll handle anything else. Lea, Key, Campbell are all guys who I’m sure will win the press conference but not sure they move the needle on anything.
Manny would be a natural.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSU4U and Rudy4526

WestSideLion

All-Conference
May 29, 2001
4,448
4,911
113
And he very well could be going to the playoffs, further complicating the ability or willingness we have to completely destroy our recruiting and portal classes on the hope and prayer he says yes. Personally, I do not think he or Elko are worth that gamble.
One recruiting class in exchange for the right head coach is a trade off you make everyday and twice on Sundays.

That’s especially true in the portal era where the right guy will be an immediate magnet for transfers who are likely more ready to contribute.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 94LionsFan

Rudy4526

Senior
Oct 13, 2010
625
700
93
One recruiting class in exchange for the right head coach is a trade off you make everyday and twice on Sundays.

That’s especially true in the portal era where the right guy will be an immediate magnet for transfers who are likely more ready to contribute.
realistically who is the guy that is the guy that is coming to PSU?
 

NOYDB

Redshirt
Jan 21, 2012
115
46
12
Yes. PSU needs someone like Brohm who was a QB, has a distinct offensive philosophy, and can recruit and develop QBs. If you bring in top end QB talent the rest follows. Unfortunately, I do not see him leaving Louisville.

I like the 2004 Honda story. It says something positive about him to me, but I can't really put it in words. Maybe that he's a no BS guy?
Brohm is a smart guy and is making 6 million dollars that could move to 13 million at PSU. He also understands that the ACC is a one bid league (most years)! The highest ranked team that was released last night from the ACC, wasn’t in the top 12.

Don’t count out the motivation to be one of the highest paid coaches AND be able to compete every year for a championship. It’s not going to happen at UL.
 

Zone-Blitz

Junior
Oct 27, 2013
108
209
43
Brohm is a smart guy and is making 6 million dollars that could move to 13 million at PSU. He also understands that the ACC is a one bid league (most years)! The highest ranked team that was released last night from the ACC, wasn’t in the top 12.

Don’t count out the motivation to be one of the highest paid coaches AND be able to compete every year for a championship. It’s not going to happen at UL.
Exactly, the most overrated, over-talked about aspect is where a coach grew up or went to college, or that he’s at his Alma mater. I don’t think any of that matters much. The Alma mater thing didn’t do Scott frost any favors. I don’t know why Brohm would be unattainable just because he’s at Louisville. Going from Purdue to Louisville is understandable, but when PSU offers, I don’t know how strong that loyalty would be to just turn an opportunity like that down ?
 

LionJim

Heisman
Oct 12, 2021
12,875
17,837
113
Exactly, the most overrated, over-talked about aspect is where a coach grew up or went to college, or that he’s at his Alma mater. I don’t think any of that matters much. The Alma mater thing didn’t do Scott frost any favors. I don’t know why Brohm would be unattainable just because he’s at Louisville. Going from Purdue to Louisville is understandable, but when PSU offers, I don’t know how strong that loyalty would be to just turn an opportunity like that down ?
Scott Frost, good take, attaboy.
 

barry j fenchak

Sophomore
May 11, 2016
217
139
43
Don’t count out the motivation to be one of the highest paid coaches AND be able to compete every year for a championship. It’s not going to happen at UL.
PS has 1 playoff appearance in the last 40 years. Not like they have been a playoff machine like some other programs. If the CFP had not made the "Penn State Expansion" last year we would not have made even that one.

You guys should get your head out of HV every now and then. It ain't the Camelot you think it is.
 

Itraindogs

All-Conference
Nov 28, 2024
810
1,523
93
And he very well could be going to the playoffs, further complicating the ability or willingness we have to completely destroy our recruiting and portal classes on the hope and prayer he says yes. Personally, I do not think he or Elko are worth that gamble

If he makes the playoffs definitely, but the last CFP rankings have Louisville at 15 which could leave Louisville out of the CFP. If that is the case, then it may be a catalyst for Brohm to consider a change.
 

Chumboshifko1

Sophomore
Oct 15, 2025
187
119
43
PS has 1 playoff appearance in the last 40 years. Not like they have been a playoff machine like some other programs. If the CFP had not made the "Penn State Expansion" last year we would not have made even that one.

You guys should get your head out of HV every now and then. It ain't the Camelot you think it is.

You take it first
 

NOYDB

Redshirt
Jan 21, 2012
115
46
12
PS has 1 playoff appearance in the last 40 years. Not like they have been a playoff machine like some other programs. If the CFP had not made the "Penn State Expansion" last year we would not have made even that one.

You guys should get your head out of HV every now and then. It ain't the Camelot you think it is.
The 12 team playoff has been going for 1 year DA, not 40 years. The BCS crap and 4 team playoff system is over if you haven’t been paying attention..

PSU is 1 for 1 on the new system.. moving to 50% in a couple months
 
  • Haha
Reactions: barry j fenchak

BCS PSU

Senior
Jun 2, 2001
248
440
63
PS has 1 playoff appearance in the last 40 years. Not like they have been a playoff machine like some other programs. If the CFP had not made the "Penn State Expansion" last year we would not have made even that one.

You guys should get your head out of HV every now and then. It ain't the Camelot you think it is.
The playoffs did not start forty years ago, which means that they would've started in 1985. In fact, they started in 2014. What's more is if they had started forty years ago and just included four teams, PSU would've qualified in 1985, 1986, 1991, 1994, 2005, and possibly 2008, which is more than one time.
 
Last edited:

barry j fenchak

Sophomore
May 11, 2016
217
139
43
The playoffs did not start forty years ago, which means that they would've started in 1985. In fact, they started in 2014. What's more is if they had started forty years ago and just included four teams, PSU would've qualified in 1985, 1986, 1991, 1994, 2005, and possibly 2008, which is more than one time.
And that means exactly jack-shiit.

You act as if PS had some great historical playoff/championship tradition like Bama, OK, OSU...... when quite the opposite is true.

Bowl Alliance era - 0 title appearances
BCS era - 0 title appearances
4 team CFP era - 0 title appearances
12 team watered down CFP era - 0 title appearances

We are the laughingstock of CFB, yet there is an idiotic notion that no one would dare even consider refusing the HC job here. No personal reason for refusing exists that money will not change.

For you fools that consider it the best job open right now - you are due for a big dose of reality.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: psu83

84lion

Senior
Oct 7, 2021
616
998
93
There was one from State College to Cobb County GA outside of Atlanta the other day.
Well, that could be a Key development... ;)

Seriously, if that flight involved Key, and that jet went into Kennesaw, it makes sense. Don't know where Key lives, but the northern Atlanta suburbs would be a good bet.
 

Arivacalion

Junior
Aug 25, 2025
291
356
63
Well, that could be a Key development... ;)

Seriously, if that flight involved Key, and that jet went into Kennesaw, it makes sense. Don't know where Key lives, but the northern Atlanta suburbs would be a good bet.
That's the only thing that will be completed by air if they hire Key 😂
 

84lion

Senior
Oct 7, 2021
616
998
93
In 2025, I would imagine initial interviews are zoom rather than in person. Perhaps second or third interviews are in person.
Or it could just have been a good excuse for someone to get in a round of golf. The weather down here has been gorgeous this week. Temps in the 60s earlier this week, low 70s today. Not a cloud in the sky. The real head scratcher for me is why Key would want to leave Georgia. Money ain't everything.
 

SRURock24

Junior
Jul 25, 2017
267
206
43
Or it could just have been a good excuse for someone to get in a round of golf. The weather down here has been gorgeous this week. Temps in the 60s earlier this week, low 70s today. Not a cloud in the sky. The real head scratcher for me is why Key would want to leave Georgia. Money ain't everything.
A friend of mine didn’t want to move to Milwaukee but he got a significant promotion, compensation and it aligned with his career goals and objectives.
 

KingLando

All-Conference
Nov 29, 2021
2,366
1,611
113
Or it could just have been a good excuse for someone to get in a round of golf. The weather down here has been gorgeous this week. Temps in the 60s earlier this week, low 70s today. Not a cloud in the sky. The real head scratcher for me is why Key would want to leave Georgia. Money ain't everything.
Maybe he doesn't like 90-100 degree days during the summer? Main reason I'd never move south. I'm taking cold over heat everyday.