No. 12 Wrestling Hosted No. 20 Oklahoma, Drexel in Weekend Action

Kiddagger311

Sophomore
Sep 17, 2025
203
110
43
Last year I didn't post my annual reminder (I was being kind) and I know some here hate it. I've forgotten what year I started it. Here it is, can you relate?

Rutgers wrestling and this forum repeat the same stages every year. There's the manic stage where the enthusiasm is high and the expectations great. "This is our best line up ever". The rankings look good. There is some early success mixed with unexpected disappointment. The season gets rolling and there's great disappointment, rankings drop. The forum goes into a WTF discussion and questions what's going on and some coaching criticism. That is followed by reconciliation and support for the coaching. Then the manic stage starts again with the battle cry of "just wait until next year". Repeat from beginning.
I also noticed this too and pointed this out the start of the season when some people were predicting 3+ AA best team ever talks. Every season we are met with many more lows and WTF moments then the highs. We peaked when Ash and Suriano won titles n it’s been a steady complacent/decline for too long.
 

wngarbarini

Heisman
May 4, 2006
10,686
10,689
113
SCW got totally screwed against Okie as that was clearly a TD which would have won him the bout and us the match. If Joey O had wrestled against Okie we win the match. The Rider kid at 141 beat Wells via injury default for 6 points. We were really not aggressive offensively against Okie which cost us the match. Against Drexel we finally got offensively aggressive. Shawver had a WTF match. Upper weights wrestled well. Don’t forget Peterson beat some top ranked guys while at RU so I can’t see why you say he did not improve here. Did he regress at Iowa cause he got pinned and only beat another unranked guy barely in SV? We tried to make Brian Soldano a total wrestler her and not just rely on his funk. I had a long talk with Roger Kish the Okie coach who told me he is trying to do the same thing we tried to do during his career here.
 

NJwrestling26

Sophomore
Oct 16, 2025
109
180
43
SCW got totally screwed against Okie as that was clearly a TD which would have won him the bout and us the match. If Joey O had wrestled against Okie we win the match. The Rider kid at 141 beat Wells via injury default for 6 points. We were really not aggressive offensively against Okie which cost us the match. Against Drexel we finally got offensively aggressive. Shawver had a WTF match. Upper weights wrestled well. Don’t forget Peterson beat some top ranked guys while at RU so I can’t see why you say he did not improve here. Did he regress at Iowa cause he got pinned and only beat another unranked guy barely in SV? We tried to make Brian Soldano a total wrestler her and not just rely on his funk. I had a long talk with Roger Kish the Okie coach who told me he is trying to do the same thing we tried to do during his career here.
A lot of could’ve ,should’ve ,would’ve right here.

i know you are forever a Rutgers wrestling optimist but let’s be real here

Soldano time here has to been seen as a total failure, he was the 12th ranked recruit in the country and regressed after his freshman year then the coaching staff pushed him aside for SCW a guy brought in to be a room body. Peterson another failure , top 17 recruit #1 at his weight and never came close to being the top of his weight class , never developed any more offense.

Shawver is a big ten champ and an AA, those guys don’t have wtf matches against 6th year seniors who have never qualified for nationals. Quite possibly the worst lose for any big ten champ from the past 20 years. He also got wrecked by Mougalian whose never been a starter in college.

Rutgers is in the middle of the 2nd best talent producing wrestling state in the country, in the big ten with a very good fanbase and has finished top 10 at ncaas before , you don’t get to pat yourself on the back for wrestling aggressively against drexel.

the team looks pretty bad so far. The 2 AAs pinto and Shawver have looked nothing like AAs or even R12 guys right now. The best wrestler Oliveri a senior was just sat down for 2 duals, including a national televised one and it cost Rutgers the dual. Transfers at 197 285 have been average so far.. 149 Clark has regressed, 125 Rutgers lost peterson a top recruit and R12/AA type guy and swapped him out with a NQ R32 type guy. SCW looks good but just lost to the guy hes replacing. Parkins and Harer are solid redshirts but most likely have the same ceiling as the current guys in the lineup which is R12/ low AA

big picture not much to be optimistic about at the moment everything seems pretty stale at moment
 

Kiddagger311

Sophomore
Sep 17, 2025
203
110
43
A lot of could’ve ,should’ve ,would’ve right here.

i know you are forever a Rutgers wrestling optimist but let’s be real here

Soldano time here has to been seen as a total failure, he was the 12th ranked recruit in the country and regressed after his freshman year then the coaching staff pushed him aside for SCW a guy brought in to be a room body. Peterson another failure , top 17 recruit #1 at his weight and never came close to being the top of his weight class , never developed any more offense.

Shawver is a big ten champ and an AA, those guys don’t have wtf matches against 6th year seniors who have never qualified for nationals. Quite possibly the worst lose for any big ten champ from the past 20 years. He also got wrecked by Mougalian whose never been a starter in college.

Rutgers is in the middle of the 2nd best talent producing wrestling state in the country, in the big ten with a very good fanbase and has finished top 10 at ncaas before , you don’t get to pat yourself on the back for wrestling aggressively against drexel.

the team looks pretty bad so far. The 2 AAs pinto and Shawver have looked nothing like AAs or even R12 guys right now. The best wrestler Oliveri a senior was just sat down for 2 duals, including a national televised one and it cost Rutgers the dual. Transfers at 197 285 have been average so far.. 149 Clark has regressed, 125 Rutgers lost peterson a top recruit and R12/AA type guy and swapped him out with a NQ R32 type guy. SCW looks good but just lost to the guy hes replacing. Parkins and Harer are solid redshirts but most likely have the same ceiling as the current guys in the lineup which is R12/ low AA

big picture not much to be optimistic about at the moment everything seems pretty stale at moment
^^this
Another problem is we graduate Joey O, Shawver, Pinto, Katka, and Clark… that’s half starting lineup and whos going to replace the potential AA??

I think only SCW has a decent to shot to AA after this year.. not enough evidence from the other recruits to think they got a reasonable shot to AA. If younger Harer isn’t a stud we are going to be cooked unless we hit the portal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Freddy Stubbs

Rutfan79

Redshirt
Jun 23, 2025
38
34
18
^^this
Another problem is we graduate Joey O, Shawver, Pinto, Katka, and Clark… that’s half starting lineup and whos going to replace the potential AA??

I think only SCW has a decent to shot to AA after this year.. not enough evidence from the other recruits to think they got a reasonable shot to AA. If younger Harer isn’t a stud we are going to be cooked unless we hit the portal.
Let me see here:
125-Smith
133-Townsen/Huerta
141-Tahir/Harer
149-Nini/Harer/Magro
157-C. Harer/Magro
165-Barbosa/Ford
174-Ford/Champman
184-SCW/Chapman
197-Cotton/PJ
Hwt-portal
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kiddagger311

Harleyr1

Senior
Dec 6, 2017
823
667
61
It's speculation, you mental midget. He is guilty, until proven innocent and we are certainly allowed to have our unbiased opinions until otherwise stated.I have no beef with the VanBrills.In fact, I was a big fan.But let's be clear hear, all the talk they did about AA this and National champ that, come NCAAs they choked...big time.You can't tell me otherwise.Regarding the Janzer/Aragona posse and their idol threats. I was over 2000 miles away, but in no way shape or form am I afraid of guys like them, even though I am half their size.None of them have even remotely wrestled or competed against the likes of a John Guira, Lee Kemp, or Barry Davis.Taking down and throttling old, out of shape, fat men with big mouths and subpar RU wrestlers is and was a small task for me...even at my age now.You live vicariously on this board...I lived it. Being a nobody, nothing is something you are content with, them so be it.But I certainly not going to have some fleabag, zero like yourself, tarnish my accolades or wrestling knowledge.You couldn't go toe to toe with female JV wrestler from Bayonne hs school, let alone even compete against men. Little angry boy, hates to hear the truth, but reality is, you really are kinda of low rent loser, with zero athletic accolades.
What about all your talk about inside info you supposedly had regarding PSU and Iowa transfer ...lol..it was a lock you said ...bet on it you said...called guys names when they doubted you ...lol...they're coming you said then you disappeared into your brown bag ..none of it was true ..never was and now you make up some **** about Joey O ..you are nobody trying to live on some 40 year old bs...there's a reason RU wants nothing to do with you ...you would think that supposedly being a former AA that you would carry yourself like one ...your lies and defaming kids is classless but coming out of your brown bag why should we expect anything different ...no I'm not a former AA and neither are hundreds of kids who represented RU but I'll take them over your classless *** any day
 

Harleyr1

Senior
Dec 6, 2017
823
667
61
I'll put money on it, It is some sort of mob relations with raimo.That East Hanover crowd is always trouble, and they all seem to be somewhat remotely related to each other...with wrestling and shady dealings.
Why in the world would you make up this crap about Joey O ...there is nothing shady about him or his family ..your a real piece of **** ..no wonder you've been banned from here 3 different time
 
  • Like
Reactions: RUBOWLMAN78

RUAldo

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2008
4,491
3,165
113
Mytych is probably the only reason the PA pipeline is flowing. Goodale has done a lot for the program over the years but it’s time for him to move on. This does not look like a B10 program. I don’t believe that Blair, Delbarton, SJR, SPP, etc. have all closed their doors to RU. Goodale isn’t working hard enough to build those relationships. VT is all over NJ and now snagged Konopka out of GFA up in CT. Eleazer DeLuca has built RFH into a public school powerhouse and runs the Dragons which attracts kids to train in NJ from all over. Where are the pipelines Goodale built during his time?
 
  • Like
Reactions: njsportsphan

biochemist001

Senior
Dec 23, 2023
603
651
93
Mytych is probably the only reason the PA pipeline is flowing. Goodale has done a lot for the program over the years but it’s time for him to move on. This does not look like a B10 program. I don’t believe that Blair, Delbarton, SJR, SPP, etc. have all closed their doors to RU. Goodale isn’t working hard enough to build those relationships. VT is all over NJ and now snagged Konopka out of GFA up in CT. Eleazer DeLuca has built RFH into a public school powerhouse and runs the Dragons which attracts kids to train in NJ from all over. Where are the pipelines Goodale built during his time?
I think it's unfair to say that Rutgers does not look like a B1G program. They consistently finish in the Top 15 in overall rankings and are consistently within the middle tier of the B1G. They consistently beat Northwestern, Indiana, MSU, Purdue, Maryland, Wisconsin, and Illinois. The problem is that they never beat PSU, Iowa, Michigan, OSU, Minnesota, and Nebraska.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rutfan79

NJwrestling26

Sophomore
Oct 16, 2025
109
180
43
I think it's unfair to say that Rutgers does not look like a B1G program. They consistently finish in the Top 15 in overall rankings and are consistently within the middle tier of the B1G. They consistently beat Northwestern, Indiana, MSU, Purdue, Maryland, Wisconsin, and Illinois. The problem is that they never beat PSU, Iowa, Michigan, OSU, Minnesota, and Nebraska.
Well they are staring down back to back years with no AA and The projected lineup above for next season will lose to atleast half those teams if they don’t hit the transfer portal hard
 

njsportsphan

Senior
Jan 26, 2021
985
976
93
I don't think the future roster is as bad as everyone thinks. Yes, they're super young and no proven AA guys yet (which I admit is alarming), but I think there's potential. That is of course, if they develop. Which apparently is hard to come by. I still think we're getting better recruits than in the past. As long as they wrestle to score, I'd rather watch a young squad with a higher ceiling for development than a bunch of grad students losing to unranked competition or barely scoring in their wins any day.

I just hope that if there is a coaching change that they at least look hard at the things that are going right and try to at least keep some of the current coaches.
 

biochemist001

Senior
Dec 23, 2023
603
651
93
Well they are staring down back to back years with no AA and The projected lineup above for next season will lose to atleast half those teams if they don’t hit the transfer portal hard
So, that's a different issue. I would argue that Goodale has historically put so much importance on winning duals that his roster builds have been to have guys at each weight that can help win team duals. These have been guys like Gravina, the Van Brills, Billy Smith, Clark, White, Janzer, Pagano, etc. The national tournament has not ever been his focus. Ashnault and Suriano were unicorns, maybe also Rivera.
 

biochemist001

Senior
Dec 23, 2023
603
651
93
I don't think the future roster is as bad as everyone thinks. Yes, they're super young and no proven AA guys yet (which I admit is alarming), but I think there's potential. That is of course, if they develop. Which apparently is hard to come by. I still think we're getting better recruits than in the past. As long as they wrestle to score, I'd rather watch a young squad with a higher ceiling for development than a bunch of grad students losing to unranked competition or barely scoring in their wins any day.

I just hope that if there is a coaching change that they at least look hard at the things that are going right and try to at least keep some of the current coaches.
I think the problem is the inability to recruit top guys because you don't have coaches with top credentials. Right now that is only Labriola. Losing Pritzlaff/Rivera/Buxton to Columbia has likely really hurt there as well as losing Ashnault to Princeton.
 

njsportsphan

Senior
Jan 26, 2021
985
976
93
I think the problem is the inability to recruit top guys because you don't have coaches with top credentials. Right now that is only Labriola. Losing Pritzlaff/Rivera/Buxton to Columbia has likely really hurt there as well as losing Ashnault to Princeton.
Oh 100%. There's no arguing that. We really need help there.
 

RUAldo

All-Conference
Sep 11, 2008
4,491
3,165
113
I think the problem is the inability to recruit top guys because you don't have coaches with top credentials. Right now that is only Labriola. Losing Pritzlaff/Rivera/Buxton to Columbia has likely really hurt there as well as losing Ashnault to Princeton.
Totally agree. I think Goodale comes across as more of a manager instead of a coach which is OK under certain circumstances. But DT is a coach that still breaks a sweat in practice. He will make every wrestler better. Brands Bros are scrapping with wrestlers every day. If RU grabs JB the program immediately elevates recruiting profile as kids want to grind with greatness. I’m sure Goodale is a likable guy but does a recruit believe he will make them an AA?
 

Rutfan79

Redshirt
Jun 23, 2025
38
34
18
I think the problem is the inability to recruit top guys because you don't have coaches with top credentials. Right now that is only Labriola. Losing Pritzlaff/Rivera/Buxton to Columbia has likely really hurt there as well as losing Ashnault to Princeton.
Explain then why the last three and class of 27’ are all top 10 recruiting classes and none of those coaches were here for the 24-27 classes?
 

Crackersisback

Redshirt
Jul 2, 2025
102
39
28
Totally agree. I think Goodale comes across as more of a manager instead of a coach which is OK under certain circumstances. But DT is a coach that still breaks a sweat in practice. He will make every wrestler better. Brands Bros are scrapping with wrestlers every day. If RU grabs JB the program immediately elevates recruiting profile as kids want to grind with greatness. I’m sure Goodale is a likable guy but does a recruit believe he will make them an AA?
Unfortunately , there is no tradition at our school. Second, If we were to start a tradition, nobody's going to feel comfortable being trained by a former high school coach. There's no higher standard with him as head coach. I think what he has done with his abilities is commendable.But with the amount of talent in new jersey , we really need to set a standard with a coach.
 

Crackersisback

Redshirt
Jul 2, 2025
102
39
28
Why in the world would you make up this crap about Joey O ...there is nothing shady about him or his family ..your a real piece of **** ..no wonder you've been banned from here 3 different time
It's "you're" not '"your. I' m a POS. Bwaahhh, dude I would throttle you if you were in front of me....with one hand behind my back.All day, everday...period, end of sentence