NY Yankees

Jul 31, 2025
468
613
93
I have to agree. Early in the year Williams was a mess but the second half he was pretty solid. He was a pretty key part of the 7-8-9 pen setup.
Devin Williams as a set-up man was great

Devin Williams as a closer was terrible

He still sees himself as a closer and more importantly wants to be PAID as a closer

I don't think the Yanks were ever going to do that this offseason
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2forheels
Jul 31, 2025
468
613
93
He was terrible. He cannot handle NY. I didn't like him calling his own pitches. I felt that is what got him in so much trouble. Yes, we talked about Gil as a closer. They should give it a try.
Calling his own pitches is terrible. When he would actually USE his fastball (which is pretty damn good) to set up the change, he was lights out.

When he would go all Tommy Kahnle and just throw changes....guys just spit on it pitch after pitch. And he would lose his mechanics on the fastball so he had nothing to fall back on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2forheels

hmk23

Redshirt
Jul 31, 2025
7
0
1
He was terrible. He cannot handle NY. I didn't like him calling his own pitches. I felt that is what got him in so much trouble. Yes, we talked about Gil as a closer. They should give it a try.
If he had a problem with NY, why would he sign with the Mets, and why would the Mets want him?
 

2forheels

Junior
Aug 2, 2025
302
223
43
If he had a problem with NY, why would he sign with the Mets, and why would the Mets want him?
Yankees and Mets are 2 entirely different scenarios. Yankees fans are brutal to their own players. You could clearly see that bothered Williams. Not everyone has what it takes to be a Yankee. Yankee Stadium is a very hard place to play, home or visitor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lakelawyerheel