Stay at the Atlantis.
Play golf at the Ocean Club. Michael Jordan hosts his celebrity tournament there every year. I also played at Cable Beach golf club... which was very much like the cheaper Municipal courses in the US. It wasn't a terrible course... but it's not nearly as nice as the Ocean Club.
Gambling is good at the Atlantis as well. Plenty of craps tables and table games. If you're an oldlady, there's also plenty of slots. If you're a poker player, there isn't a poker room in the Bahamas (or atleast there wasn't when I went) so don't waste time looking for one.
I went withmy fiance and her family... so I didn't get to do a 3 or 4 hour snorkeling trip like I wanted. I did, however, get on a booze cruise that let you snorkel for about 30 minutes. Watch out for barracuda's... I had one swim up to within 10 feet of me. Thank God he was scared of me... I think I walked on water back to the boat.
There's a very unique market in downtown as well... if you like bargaining for prices, go there for some momentos.
Also, be sure to have some Conch. I cant remember the name of the place, but all of the cab drivers know where to take you. There's this spot that they'll know when you ask "Where's the best place to get some Conch?".
</p>