OT: DEVASTATING WILDFIRE ….Santa Monica/Palisades fire being aided by 50-80mph Santa Ana winds. 100mph possible overnight

Status
Not open for further replies.

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
25,858
18,264
113
Is it not the winds?

The winds kept them grounded on Tuesday, but they flew yesterday morning and afternoon. I don't know what the winds are this morning, but if a local station is asking the question I doubt the winds are as bad as Tuesday.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leonard23 and RU05

iReC89

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2014
2,346
1,750
78
But could the tanks be filled faster with more reservoirs?

Or maybe they need more tanks?
Probably not. Need, bigger pipes to the tanks, larger pumps, beefed up generators and electrical feeds to run the pumps., etc. More tanks would help. Bigger tanks may have water quality issues if they are too stagnant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leonard23 and RU05

iReC89

All-Conference
Jul 2, 2014
2,346
1,750
78
My inlaw works with a population of multiple disabled adults who were evacuated. Rough night for them. They are also hearing reports of looting in their neighborhood, but not confirmed. They think they can go back today to check it out. Evacuation zones have grown but the place they evacuated to has not been added.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
84,370
81,756
113
Some of the considerations presented in a non-political way about the lack of prescribed burns in California. IMO, it's a pick your poison choice-make more air pollution or reduce fire damage risk.



The indigenous tribes have it right:

 

Salvi's Headband

All-American
Oct 30, 2006
5,569
9,433
0
All of the following are true:
1-Nothing much was stopping this confluence of catastrophic events.
2-The Sierra Club stopping controlled burns was overall a very bad tradeoff.
3-California has way too much red tape that slowed the construction of approved water storage projects, just like it inhibits the construction of almost everything. We really need relief from the tyranny of endless environmental impact studies and public comment periods.
 

csphi

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
16,870
18,436
102
All of the following are true:
1-Nothing much was stopping this confluence of catastrophic events.
2-The Sierra Club stopping controlled burns was overall a very bad tradeoff.
3-California has way too much red tape that slowed the construction of approved water storage projects, just like it inhibits the construction of almost everything. We really need relief from the tyranny of endless environmental impact studies and public comment periods.
Very fair analysis
 

e5fdny

Heisman
Nov 11, 2002
113,415
51,994
102
Some of the considerations presented in a non-political way about the lack of prescribed burns in California. IMO, it's a pick your poison choice-make more air pollution or reduce fire damage risk.



The indigenous tribes have it right:

There is good smoke and bad smoke. LOL

Compared to exhaust smoke and the kind from contents fires which are mostly or heavily chemically based…I’ll take the smoke from bushes, grasses and trees any day.
 

RUDead

All-Conference
Sep 20, 2017
3,655
3,827
0
All of the following are true:
1-Nothing much was stopping this confluence of catastrophic events.
2-The Sierra Club stopping controlled burns was overall a very bad tradeoff.
3-California has way too much red tape that slowed the construction of approved water storage projects, just like it inhibits the construction of almost everything. We really need relief from the tyranny of endless environmental impact studies and public comment periods.

Well said.

4. 92% of the fires are man made, primarily through eco terrorism and homelessness.
 

NickRU714

Heisman
Aug 18, 2009
13,604
12,367
0
Can I ask a probably dumb question?

Why can’t they use the Pacific Ocean for fire fighting - both local and Forrest?

Is it because of the salt and pipe corrosion?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jm0513

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
35,127
44,221
112
That would be @RUforester72

But I’m sure he’d agree with me air is the most expensive part of these operations.

I’ve talked about this before but when still active with the Eastern Area IMT I was sent to Alaska for a fire. I am in the Finance Section of the team and responsible for managing the cost. EIGHT figure ($$$$) fire. My most expensive line item was air.

So much so you would consider buying your own plane. LOL

Coolest thing about working on that fire besides the beauty of area of Alaska and the wonderful native people was the fact there were four different Rutgers Alumni on the team. We were all Cook guys and didn’t know each other until we met up in Alaska.
always love a good Cook College reference!
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
84,370
81,756
113
There is good smoke and bad smoke. LOL

Compared to exhaust smoke and the kind from contents fires which are mostly or heavily chemically based…I’ll take the smoke from bushes, grasses and trees any day.
Have taken wildfire courses and been part of controlled/prescribed burns. As you know South Monmouth is at the northern edge of the Pine Barrens. I remember in the 1980's a wildfire on Wall/Brick border on Parkway that jumped the Parkway median (which used to be a lot wider). As mentioned before, fortunately we don't have the Pine Barrens in the So Cal terrain of mountains and canyons, which makes the efforts for controlled burns and firefighting tremendously more difficult, especially considering the interface with residential homes. In Arizona where we have a home, they are pretty good about reminding residents to keep their yards free of excess "fuel", and they have schedule brush (some call is "slash") pickups to mitigate risk to homes.

Back to controlled/prescribed burns. Substitute "controlled burns" for Napalm:


 

nutfromSEC117

All-American
Nov 2, 2002
7,775
5,769
0
Desalinated water is usually more expensive than freshwater:

  • Cost
    A thousand gallons of desalinated water costs between $2.50 and $5, while freshwater costs around $2.

  • Energy use
    Desalination is energy intensive, with energy costs accounting for about 55% of a plant's total operating and maintenance costs.

However, some say that desalination costs are expected to decrease in the future. Some experts predict that desalination costs could be reduced by 50% by 2030. This is due to improvements in technology and the increased use of renewable hybrid configurations.
 

e5fdny

Heisman
Nov 11, 2002
113,415
51,994
102
The salt will also destroy the current & future vegetation & soil. "Salting the earth of your enemies lands"

good point, didn't think of that. I can't tell you how many plants, shrubs and trees i've lost due to flooding from the bay
House down the street had a beautiful and huge row of privacy arborvitae’s. Sandy came and Lake Como was conduit for the Atlantic. Ruined the trees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

e5fdny

Heisman
Nov 11, 2002
113,415
51,994
102
Have taken wildfire courses and been part of controlled/prescribed burns. As you know South Monmouth is at the northern edge of the Pine Barrens. I remember in the 1980's a wildfire on Wall/Brick border on Parkway that jumped the Parkway median (which used to be a lot wider). As mentioned before, fortunately we don't have the Pine Barrens in the So Cal terrain of mountains and canyons, which makes the efforts for controlled burns and firefighting tremendously more difficult, especially considering the interface with residential homes.
Before everyone got bunker boots (looks like something you’d wear on a motorcycle), the SOP for a brush fire in NYC was you could wear your regular issued steel toed work shoes because of all the walking and moving around. Less blisters and better for your feet overall.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
84,370
81,756
113
The salt will also destroy the current & future vegetation & soil. "Salting the earth of your enemies lands"

good point, didn't think of that. I can't tell you how many plants, shrubs and trees i've lost due to flooding from the bay

House down the street had a beautiful and huge row of privacy arborvitae’s. Sandy came and Lake Como was conduit for the Atlantic. Ruined the trees.

It's human nature, we just want to help. And when brainstorming in a crisis, all ideas need to be voiced.
Can't find the link, but a very effective weed killer is epsom salt diluted in water and mixed with a little bit of Dawn dish detergent (a surfactant that spreads the liquid onto the plants for optimum coverage).
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,685
0
No state has more restrictions on CO2, water usage and energy in general than California - doesn't seem to be working to me. I like common sense projects we know will help. You know boring practical stuff like reservoirs, better irrigation. improved water distribution, fire breaks and brush removal.
Germany and Austria are more than half forest and they don't have the constant CA infernos because they know how to prevent these things pretty much. Adam Corolla posted about the jungle of regs people who want to rebuild will face. The LA inferno will be a funeral pyre for certain "elites."
 
  • Like
Reactions: newell138

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
14,346
9,007
113
Germany and Austria are more than half forest and they don't have the constant CA infernos because they know how to prevent these things pretty much. Adam Corolla posted about the jungle of regs people who want to rebuild will face. The LA inferno will be a funeral pyre for certain "elites."
Germany and Austria have significantly different climates.
 

e5fdny

Heisman
Nov 11, 2002
113,415
51,994
102
Germany and Austria have significantly different climates.
ALL of California does too.

But your point is correct. Sometimes local laws should maybe not supersede but really reflect as what can happen in one place might not happen in another. Or as frequently.
 

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
35,127
44,221
112
House down the street had a beautiful and huge row of privacy arborvitae’s. Sandy came and Lake Como was conduit for the Atlantic. Ruined the trees.
here too on the arborvitaes, had a row in the front yard along my neighbors driveway.... Sandy... all dead
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
14,346
9,007
113
ALL of California does too.

But your point is correct. Sometimes local laws should maybe not supersede but really reflect as what can happen in one place might not happen in another. Or as frequently.
Are you saying all of Cali has a different climate then Germany and Austria?

Or that Cali being so big, has many different climates within it's borders?

Or something else?

But surely California as a whole has a climate more prone to wild fires then Germany or Austria. Especially when its rain fall is well below normal and winds well above.
 

Caliknight

Hall of Famer
Sep 21, 2001
194,844
145,872
113
Are you saying all of Cali has a different climate then Germany and Austria?

Or that Cali being so big, has many different climates within it's borders?

Or something else?

But surely California as a whole has a climate more prone to wild fires then Germany or Austria. Especially when its rain fall is well below normal and winds well above.
It has many different climates. SoCal is much different than NorCal. If Ca. was on the easy coast it would be like 10 different states. North Carolina is much different than Vermont.

Southern California is a desert. Austria and Germany don't get hot dry winds every year out of Death Valley. This was entirely predictable. These winds come every single year. Fires happen every single year.

Yet the state and city leadership did less than nothing to prepare. It's a shocking level of incompetence that is on display for the world to see.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
14,346
9,007
113
Of course it’s a desert. Much of the vegetation is man planting.

Then of course we have incredible leadership like our great governor who’s strategy is to have locals figure it out.


"extraordinarily large fires"

"complete overwhelm of a system"
 

ashokan

Heisman
May 3, 2011
25,325
19,685
0
Germany and Austria have significantly different climates.

Yeah CA's is nicer and a big reason so many people live there.

Poor water management, poor forestry, slashed critical budgets, crews fired over mandates, millions in equipment sent to Ukraine, suicidal enviro and hiring regs - a toxic brew of incompetence from every angle. The upside of the fire is that the science averse people pushing the crazy took the hardest punch.
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
14,346
9,007
113
It has many different climates. SoCal is much different than NorCal. If Ca. was on the easy coast it would be like 10 different states. North Carolina is much different than Vermont.

Southern California is a desert. Austria and Germany don't get hot dry winds every year out of Death Valley. This was entirely predictable. These winds come every single year. Fires happen every single year.

Yet the state and city leadership did less than nothing to prepare. It's a shocking level of incompetence that is on display for the world to see.
LA has an $800mil fire budget. Annual. Cali as a state budgets $4.2bil. Should it be significantly more?

Did previous administrations do more in terms of fire preparedness?
 

RU05

All-American
Jun 25, 2015
14,346
9,007
113
Yeah CA's is nicer and a big reason so many people live there.

Poor water management, poor forestry, slashed critical budgets, crews fired over mandates, millions in equipment sent to Ukraine, suicidal enviro and hiring regs - a toxic brew of incompetence from every angle. The upside of the fire is that the science averse people pushing the crazy took the hardest punch.
Hotter and drier. Much more prone to fires. Comparing it to Germany or Austria is apples and oranges.
 

e5fdny

Heisman
Nov 11, 2002
113,415
51,994
102
Hotter and drier. Much more prone to fires. Comparing it to Germany or Austria is apples and oranges.
I see what you did there.😉

But Washington has a fire season too as does Minnesota.

It normally goes clockwise. But this seems earlier?
 

e5fdny

Heisman
Nov 11, 2002
113,415
51,994
102
Are you saying all of Cali has a different climate then Germany and Austria?

* Or that Cali being so big, has many different climates within it's borders?

Or something else?

But surely California as a whole has a climate more prone to wild fires then Germany or Austria. Especially when its rain fall is well below normal and winds well above.
Parts of it, sure.

*And I was saying that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RU05
Status
Not open for further replies.