OT: Electric vehicles

Dec 4, 2010
5,866
5,256
0
Nah. Will take the word of two renowned automobile experts over some guy on a football message board who is wrong more than he is right.
"In this video I show you the build quality of a Ford F150 Lightening (EV) compared to the Tesla Model X Plaid. Sadly the build quality issues are still a thing with Tesla while costing twice as much as the Ford!"


Munro Team Praises the Ford F-150 Lightning Chassis, It's Built Tough but Simple​


Munro and Associates were highly critical of the build quality of the 2017 model 3. However, during recent teardowns of the 3 and Y, the Munro team stated the build quality has improved. You're going to find panel gaps in every make and model, even in high end luxury vehicles. Does the average consumer care or even notice millimeter differences?

My decision to buy a Tesla wasn't based on potential panel gaps. It wasn't even on my radar. I was more impressed with the power to weight ratio of their electric motors, the highly efficient HVAC system which leads to added range, less weight compared to other EVs, the software, software updates, UI, and safety. For me, the engineering is the true "build quality".
 
  • Like
Reactions: Letitrip

MulletCork

All-Conference
Sep 1, 2012
2,636
3,157
113
Alamo gave me some Kia hybrid at the rental counter down in Florida recently. I didn't care what I got - I just rent a compact car typically, whatever is cheapest.
Thing got like 50 miles per gallon practically. Never drove a hybrid in my life. Seems like a far better option than this disastrous EV Kia. Yikes, who has the time for that nonsense?
 
  • Like
Reactions: fsg2_rivals

RU4Real

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
50,955
30,733
0
You're going to find panel gaps in every make and model, even in high end luxury vehicles.

Tell me you've never bought a high-end luxury vehicle without telling me you've never bought a high-end luxury vehicle...

Hell, it doesn't even have to be "high end". Each of the 5 Audis I've owned has been impeccably built. There are no panel gaps. Tell your story in Ingolstadt and it's likely they'll cut a *****.

The build quality on my Volvo is as near perfect as it gets.
 

AZBlues

All-Conference
Sep 29, 2013
1,185
1,389
0
Agree that the US is not quite ready for everyone to have only EV vehicles... But it also doesn't seem very bright to take a 1500 mile trip in an EV without planning in advance where to recharge and without being experienced in the real life range limitations for the vehicle.. And probably not too many people would acquire an EV now with the intent of taking many long cross country trips in it, unless they knew they had the time to stop and recharge when necessary.

Regardless, I'm still grateful for the benefits to the environment... Rome wasn't built in a day, and you have to start somewhere, even if it includes primarily shorter trips for now. Eventually they'll invent batteries that charge faster and last longer, or maybe a quick and safe battery swap system for an additional charged battery, etc..
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,272
0
Munro and Associates were highly critical of the build quality of the 2017 model 3. However, during recent teardowns of the 3 and Y, the Munro team stated the build quality has improved. You're going to find panel gaps in every make and model, even in high end luxury vehicles. Does the average consumer care or even notice millimeter differences?

My decision to buy a Tesla wasn't based on potential panel gaps. It wasn't even on my radar. I was more impressed with the power to weight ratio of their electric motors, the highly efficient HVAC system which leads to added range, less weight compared to other EVs, the software, software updates, UI, and safety. For me, the engineering is the true "build quality".
How do YOU spell "rationalization"? 😉

But I agree with your point about how Teslas are built for the average consumer. Like Toyotas. Nothing wrong with being average. Most people are.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,272
0
toyotas are a better quality build.
That's true.

I probably shouldn't make fun of Tesla build quality. My P car's in the shop to fix the analog gas gauge, which has been suffering bouts of schizophrenia lately. Sometimes it shows I have a tank and a half of gas when I actually am near empty. Sometimes it shows empty when I actually just filled the tank. Sometimes it's spot on.

I endured some justifiable mockery over this by one of my friends during my Superbowl party, when I mentioned I was dropping the car off at the shop the next day. "You paid such and such for a car and the gas gauge doesn't even work?" was the just the start of her mini-rant. 😀

Now that I think about it, I was in the midst of serving her some 18 year old scotch while she was mocking me and/or my car, introducing even more comic irony into the situation. 🤣

But then she brought brie-bread to the party which is the way to my heart (which gets that much closer to stopping after consuming it). So I'm not complaining. I love brie bread. Mmmmmm.
 

RU4Real

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
50,955
30,733
0
That's true.

I probably shouldn't make fun of Tesla build quality. My P car's in the shop to fix the analog gas gauge, which has been suffering bouts of schizophrenia lately. Sometimes it shows I have a tank and a half of gas when I actually am near empty. Sometimes it shows empty when I actually just filled the tank. Sometimes it's spot on.

I endured some justifiable mockery over this by one of my friends during my Superbowl party, when I mentioned I was dropping the car off at the shop the next day. "You paid such and such for a car and the gas gauge doesn't even work?" was the just the start of her mini-rant. 😀

Now that I think about it, I was in the midst of serving her some 18 year old scotch while she was mocking me and/or my car, introducing even more comic irony into the situation. 🤣

But then she brought brie-bread to the party which is the way to my heart (which gets that much closer to stopping after consuming it). So I'm not complaining. I love brie bread. Mmmmmm.

My brother-in-law solved this problem brilliantly.

He paid upwards of a quarter mil for his DB11, what with all of the wild (and generally accurate) tales of Brit build quality and reliability. God only knows what could possibly go wrong with this thing. The solution? He doesn't drive it. Sort of the Schrödinger's Theory of Vehicle Reliability.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,272
0
My brother-in-law solved this problem brilliantly.

He paid upwards of a quarter mil for his DB11, what with all of the wild (and generally accurate) tales of Brit build quality and reliability. God only knows what could possibly go wrong with this thing. The solution? He doesn't drive it. Sort of the Schrödinger's Theory of Vehicle Reliability.
I suppose that's one way to ensure reliability.

I'm just under 40K miles now, and a few days past 4 years. Other than this recent gas gauge thing, I only had one other thing, where there felt like a slight wobble that turned out to be due to wheel weights that fell off (how that can happen, I have no idea).

Considering how hard it's been driven, I feel like it's been very reliable. Knock on wood. I've been changing the oil and filter, or having them changed, at about half the recommended interval. Probably a waste, but it can't hurt.
 

Knight Shift

Heisman
May 19, 2011
87,563
85,231
113
Munro and Associates were highly critical of the build quality of the 2017 model 3. However, during recent teardowns of the 3 and Y, the Munro team stated the build quality has improved. You're going to find panel gaps in every make and model, even in high end luxury vehicles. Does the average consumer care or even notice millimeter differences?

My decision to buy a Tesla wasn't based on potential panel gaps. It wasn't even on my radar. I was more impressed with the power to weight ratio of their electric motors, the highly efficient HVAC system which leads to added range, less weight compared to other EVs, the software, software updates, UI, and safety. For me, the engineering is the true "build quality".
For me, I wanted a truck that looked like a truck and was made by a company with a long history of building quality trucks. I also wanted one that was going to be available asap. That ruled Tesla CT out. The comparison Munro with the Rivian was revealing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MADHAT1

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
  • An Axios reporter took a Kia EV6 on a 1,500 mile road trip.
  • She said it showed the US is not quite ready for an electric-car revolution.
  • She and her husband stopped to charge the car 12 times over the course of the trip from Michigan to Florida.
Taking an electric car on a road trip can be a stressful experience — at least according to a couple who took their Kia EV6 on a cross-country trip from Michigan to Florida.

Axios reporter Joann Muller said her husband took the electric car on a 1,500 mile road trip — she joined him part-way through — to see if the US is truly ready for mass EV adoption. While electric cars are becoming more prevalent, charging infrastructure isn't quite what it should be, Muller wrote.

"We were constantly thinking about where to charge next," Muller wrote of her experience during the trip. "It occupied our minds more than where to eat or spend the night."

They stopped 12 times to recharge the car, which has an estimated battery range of 274 miles, over the course of the 1,500 mile, four-day journey, and that charging times were between 20 to 55 minutes.


https://www.msn.com/en-us/autos/new...pc=U531&cvid=c7a0cad8c67d4ac89c9558b56a447cc8
This is actually a fair criticism of EVs and why I believe a plug-in hybrid household is the best solution right now. Zero emissions local driving, unfettered long range capability in all weather and conditions.
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
For me, I wanted a truck that looked like a truck and was made by a company with a long history of building quality trucks. I also wanted one that was going to be available asap. That ruled Tesla CT out. The comparison Munro with the Rivian was revealing.
I couldn't bring myself to touch a "Stellantis" beyond a test drive, but the Ram 1500 Rev looks good along those lines too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Knight Shift

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,272
0
The study in the article seems to support what some of us have been saying. We think EVs are a fine technology that can help some with the environment. But they aren't perfect and there are likely to be a number of adoption-delaying issues.

I do not believe many, if any, of the various state-declared deadlines for adoption will be met. Nonetheless, it still makes sense, to me, to create lofty adoption goals in order to push the process along at an accelerated rate.
 

RUevolution36

All-American
Sep 18, 2006
8,165
5,647
113
The study in the article seems to support what some of us have been saying. We think EVs are a fine technology that can help some with the environment. But they aren't perfect and there are likely to be a number of adoption-delaying issues.

I do not believe many, if any, of the various state-declared deadlines for adoption will be met. Nonetheless, it still makes sense, to me, to create lofty adoption goals in order to push the process along at an accelerated rate.
i just wanted to share, as certain folks in this thread think that the rest of us are fist-waving-at-the-sky luddites and our concerns are unfounded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mildone_rivals

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,272
0
i just wanted to share, as certain folks in this thread think that the rest of us are fist-waving-at-the-sky luddites and our concerns are unfounded.
It Is certainly true that we have some EV extremists in the thread who seem unable to tolerate the variety of viewpoints different than their own.

I wonder, sometimes, if the "it MUST be EVs" folks realize how similar they are to the "it MUST NOT be EVs" folks.
 

MADHAT1

Heisman
Apr 1, 2003
31,028
15,916
113
It Is certainly true that we have some EV extremists in the thread who seem unable to tolerate the variety of viewpoints different than their own.

I wonder, sometimes, if the "it MUST be EVs" folks realize how similar they are to the "it MUST NOT be EVs" folks.
EVs are a work in progress, they must not be considered the only means of transportation at this time .
But the EV industry needs to be given every help needed to become the type of transportation everyone wants to buy and feel safe driving cross country in an EV.

The claims against using fossil fuel might have some merit, but until the EV battery technology improves , ranting against gas./diesel fuel vehicles is just blowing smoke
trying to turn attention away from a major EV problem
 
Dec 4, 2010
5,866
5,256
0
Tell me you've never bought a high-end luxury vehicle without telling me you've never bought a high-end luxury vehicle...

Hell, it doesn't even have to be "high end". Each of the 5 Audis I've owned has been impeccably built. There are no panel gaps. Tell your story in Ingolstadt and it's likely they'll cut a *****.

The build quality on my Volvo is as near perfect as it gets.
A quick Google search for any luxury brand and build quality might help you. No car is going to be perfect.
And again, to each their own. For me, features & function > near perfect build.
 
Dec 4, 2010
5,866
5,256
0
For me, I wanted a truck that looked like a truck and was made by a company with a long history of building quality trucks. I also wanted one that was going to be available asap. That ruled Tesla CT out. The comparison Munro with the Rivian was revealing.
Just be careful. Long history of building quality trucks isn't the same as building quality EVs. Every OEM is stumbling through electrification. For your sake, I hope the Ford production halt isn't too serious
 
Dec 4, 2010
5,866
5,256
0
This is actually a fair criticism of EVs and why I believe a plug-in hybrid household is the best solution right now. Zero emissions local driving, unfettered long range capability in all weather and conditions.
Detroit to Orlando in a Kia EV6.
8 charging stops. None longer than 23 minutes at any charger.

https://abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=d1daa6a7-e97b-4143-9c1e-4fda00fb8395

Beware of these "EV charging nightmare" stories. They're ********. And if this couple stayed at a hotel with destination charging, the trip could be 1 or 2 less stops. The New York Times ran a similar EV hit piece where the author of the article intentionally drove out of her way to avoid DC fast chargers.
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
Detroit to Orlando in a Kia EV6.
8 charging stops. None longer than 23 minutes at any charger.

https://abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=d1daa6a7-e97b-4143-9c1e-4fda00fb8395

Beware of these "EV charging nightmare" stories. They're ********. And if this couple stayed at a hotel with destination charging, the trip could be 1 or 2 less stops. The New York Times ran a similar EV hit piece where the author of the article intentionally drove out of her way to avoid DC fast chargers.
Didn't read the story, but it's non-debatable that an ICE-equipped vehicle is superior for a road trip.
 

mildone_rivals

Heisman
Dec 19, 2011
55,607
51,272
0
Detroit to Orlando in a Kia EV6.
8 charging stops. None longer than 23 minutes at any charger.

https://abetterrouteplanner.com/?plan_uuid=d1daa6a7-e97b-4143-9c1e-4fda00fb8395

Beware of these "EV charging nightmare" stories. They're ********. And if this couple stayed at a hotel with destination charging, the trip could be 1 or 2 less stops. The New York Times ran a similar EV hit piece where the author of the article intentionally drove out of her way to avoid DC fast chargers.
What happens when the hotel doesn’t have enough chargers for all their guests with EVs on a given night? Or are they just running extension cords out to cars with batteries?
 
Dec 4, 2010
5,866
5,256
0
Didn't read the story, but it's non-debatable that an ICE-equipped vehicle is superior for a road trip.
The story is disingenuous. That's the point.

Don't generalize that ICE vehicles are superior for road trips. I could say it's "non-debatable" that EVs are superior for road trips when it comes to cost. Some people might not want to redline it across the country. Did the route and charging stops I linked seem like a "nightmare scenario"?

This is individual preference so not worth debating. My point is the original story is complete ******** and unfortunately, it's one of many similar EV hit pieces.
 
Oct 19, 2010
207,472
28,752
0
  • An Axios reporter took a Kia EV6 on a 1,500 mile road trip.
  • She said it showed the US is not quite ready for an electric-car revolution.
  • She and her husband stopped to charge the car 12 times over the course of the trip from Michigan to Florida.
Taking an electric car on a road trip can be a stressful experience — at least according to a couple who took their Kia EV6 on a cross-country trip from Michigan to Florida.

Axios reporter Joann Muller said her husband took the electric car on a 1,500 mile road trip — she joined him part-way through — to see if the US is truly ready for mass EV adoption. While electric cars are becoming more prevalent, charging infrastructure isn't quite what it should be, Muller wrote.

"We were constantly thinking about where to charge next," Muller wrote of her experience during the trip. "It occupied our minds more than where to eat or spend the night."

They stopped 12 times to recharge the car, which has an estimated battery range of 274 miles, over the course of the 1,500 mile, four-day journey, and that charging times were between 20 to 55 minutes.


https://www.msn.com/en-us/autos/new...pc=U531&cvid=c7a0cad8c67d4ac89c9558b56a447cc8

We had this Kia as a loaner while having repairs on Tesla (someone backed into to the car and caught one of the front cameras with their tow hitch). I can report the Kia is a total POS compared to the Tesla Model Y. I had anxiety driving this three miles - forget about 1,500 miles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FRA10Thunderbolt

Jtung230

Heisman
Jun 30, 2005
19,055
12,223
82
We had this Kia as a loaner while having repairs on Tesla (someone backed into to the car and caught one of the front cameras with their tow hitch). I can report the Kia is a total POS compared to the Tesla Model Y. I had anxiety driving this three miles - forget about 1,500 miles.
Which Kia model?
 

newell138

Heisman
Aug 1, 2001
36,317
46,381
112
What happens when the hotel doesn’t have enough chargers for all their guests with EVs on a given night? Or are they just running extension cords out to cars with batteries?
That’s how it is in some CA neighborhoods. Extension cords all over the sidewalks
 

fsg2_rivals

Heisman
Apr 3, 2018
10,881
13,184
0
The story is disingenuous. That's the point.

Don't generalize that ICE vehicles are superior for road trips. I could say it's "non-debatable" that EVs are superior for road trips when it comes to cost. Some people might not want to redline it across the country. Did the route and charging stops I linked seem like a "nightmare scenario"?

This is individual preference so not worth debating. My point is the original story is complete ******** and unfortunately, it's one of many similar EV hit pieces.
You responded to me, home bro. I was never talking about the original story. I have zero interest in that kind of social media-derived "look at me" editorializing to begin with.

The disadvantage EVs have for road tripping is a valid concern, with or without those type of stories.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mildone_rivals

RU4Real

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
50,955
30,733
0
Doesn't everyone want to sit in the parking lot of a target or panera for 30 mins every few hours?

My wife's niece has 2 kids under 2. Her husband told me that the best thing about his Model 3 is that he can sneak off to the mall for an hour every couple of days to charge his car.