OT: How To Maximize Fixed Income as a Retiree

KK1827

All-American
Nov 4, 2023
2,893
8,190
48
My mother is approaching retirement and has been asking me how to create a cashflow stream from her savings. She’ll have about $800K along with her full SS benefits.

While I can consult her on a variety of real estate related investments, I’d like to learn more about other fixed income avenues for impending retirees like her and what are the typical returns.

Any help and contributions to the thread are appreciated.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,014
18,364
113
You'll need someone more familiar with annuities than me to analyze that possibility but right you might consider setting up a ladder of short term (2 years and less) treasuries with a part of her funds. You can get a totally safe return of around 5%. That could change as interest rates change. You'll also have to review her cash flow needs and tolerance for risk.
 

fg7321

All-American
Nov 29, 2009
4,258
5,132
48
Check with Fidelity they have annuities that are totally free of any fees. We got one back in Nov. with a 6.4% payout ratio for our lifetime and if we die before the money we put in gets paid back to us that balance goes to our kids.

We also put some cash into a 3 year annuity that pays out 5.1 % that we can take out 10% of the investment each year. Again no fees.
 

RU Golfer

All-Conference
Dec 4, 2009
1,973
1,171
0
Check with Fidelity they have annuities that are totally free of any fees. We got one back in Nov. with a 6.4% payout ratio for our lifetime and if we die before the money we put in gets paid back to us that balance goes to our kids.

We also put some cash into a 3 year annuity that pays out 5.1 % that we can take out 10% of the investment each year. Again no fees.
I set up an annuity with Fidelity as well. If anything is left over out of the initial investment it will go to my beneficiaries.
 

T2Kplus20

Heisman
May 1, 2007
30,233
18,208
113
Check with Fidelity they have annuities that are totally free of any fees. We got one back in Nov. with a 6.4% payout ratio for our lifetime and if we die before the money we put in gets paid back to us that balance goes to our kids.

We also put some cash into a 3 year annuity that pays out 5.1 % that we can take out 10% of the investment each year. Again no fees.
Seriously, no fees? The one issue with annuities is the fees and crazy costs you need to deal with. I've been a Fidelity customer for years, but never looked into this topic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Morrischiano

KK1827

All-American
Nov 4, 2023
2,893
8,190
48
Seriously, no fees? The one issue with annuities is the fees and crazy costs you need to deal with. I've been a Fidelity customer for years, but never looked into this topic.
Just did an annuity estimate with them. Female starting at age 67 and $800K input pays 8.2% annually for life. Sounds attactive but i gotta see if theres a catch. Around $5600/month.
 

T2Kplus20

Heisman
May 1, 2007
30,233
18,208
113
Just did an annuity estimate with them. Female starting at age 67 and $800K input pays 8.2% annually for life. Sounds attactive but i gotta see if theres a catch. Around $5600/month.
That's a healthy monthly payout. Does this include the option for unused money going to her kids/beneficiaries?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Morrischiano

Morrischiano2

All-American
Dec 3, 2019
5,956
7,718
0
My mother is approaching retirement and has been asking me how to create a cashflow stream from her savings. She’ll have about $800K along with her full SS benefits.

While I can consult her on a variety of real estate related investments, I’d like to learn more about other fixed income avenues for impending retirees like her and what are the typical returns.

Any help and contributions to the thread are appreciated.
Paying into an annuity for someone in their early 60’s won’t get you a return much better than building a bond ladder. It’s fairly easy to do on fidelity or Charles Schwab sites. Depending on her age you can do a 2-5-10 yr structure and hold to maturity and get a 5~5.5 percent return. You just need to figure out her cash flow needs over that timeframe and figure out how much to invest at each tranche.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jtung230

Morrischiano2

All-American
Dec 3, 2019
5,956
7,718
0
Just did an annuity estimate with them. Female starting at age 67 and $800K input pays 8.2% annually for life. Sounds attactive but i gotta see if theres a catch. Around $5600/month.
Ok I’m surprised it’s that high. There probably isn’t an estate component with that payout. Meaning if she dies at age 70 the estate gets zero. There are annuities that guarantee a minimum payment for 10, 20, 30 years. So if she dies 1 yr into retirement then the estate gets 9 yr of payments (in the first example)
 

Vlife

Senior
Nov 20, 2001
450
581
46
You'll need someone more familiar with annuities than me to analyze that possibility but right you might consider setting up a ladder of short term (2 years and less) treasuries with a part of her funds. You can get a totally safe return of around 5%. That could change as interest rates change. You'll also have to review her cash flow needs and tolerance for risk.
An additional nice feature of Treasury securities is the income is exempt from state & local taxes
 
Last edited:

hoquat63

All-Conference
Mar 17, 2005
9,129
4,421
0
You can also open a treasury direct account and buy bills, notes and bonds directly from the treasury.
Also for tax purposes Vanguard has a NJ bond fund which is tax free. Probably available from other sources too
 

KK1827

All-American
Nov 4, 2023
2,893
8,190
48
Ok I’m surprised it’s that high. There probably isn’t an estate component with that payout. Meaning if she dies at age 70 the estate gets zero. There are annuities that guarantee a minimum payment for 10, 20, 30 years. So if she dies 1 yr into retirement then the estate gets 9 yr of payments (in the first example)
So I looked into it. If a 67 year old woman puts $800K into an annuity the pay out is like $6200/month which is pretty damn good. And if hypothetically that person dies 3 years later, the heirs would get $800K minus 3 years worth of payments which comes to around $575K. Fidelity has their annuity calculator on their site which I linked above.
 

KK1827

All-American
Nov 4, 2023
2,893
8,190
48
You can also open a treasury direct account and buy bills, notes and bonds directly from the treasury.
Also for tax purposes Vanguard has a NJ bond fund which is tax free. Probably available from other sources too
Speaking of taxes. If $800K sits in a traditional 401K for the 67 year old and they want to stuff that money into for example a fidelity annuity product, what are the tax implications on that $800K?
 

RUschool

Heisman
Jan 23, 2004
49,910
13,999
78
So I looked into it. If a 67 year old woman puts $800K into an annuity the pay out is like $6200/month which is pretty damn good. And if hypothetically that person dies 3 years later, the heirs would get $800K minus 3 years worth of payments which comes to around $575K. Fidelity has their annuity calculator on their site which I linked above.
You lose the interest that accrued for the three years?
 
  • Like
Reactions: T2Kplus20

Vlife

Senior
Nov 20, 2001
450
581
46
You can also open a treasury direct account and buy bills, notes and bonds directly from the treasury.
Also for tax purposes Vanguard has a NJ bond fund which is tax free. Probably available from other sources too
I use my broker to submit noncompetitive auction bids. Treasury Direct is good but a disadvantage is if you ever want to sell before maturity the security has to first be transferred to a brokerage account.
 

RUschool

Heisman
Jan 23, 2004
49,910
13,999
78
I use my broker to submit noncompetitive auction bids. Treasury Direct is good but a disadvantage is if you ever want to sell before maturity the security has to first be transferred to a brokerage account.
I found this out later and wish I-never brought long term bonds. Most of my other bonds were. the shorter term bonds, under 2 years matured. Not going to buy more bonds and sticking with short term CD or bonds from brokerage.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,014
18,364
113
Speaking of taxes. If $800K sits in a traditional 401K for the 67 year old and they want to stuff that money into for example a fidelity annuity product, what are the tax implications on that $800K?

You DON'T distribute the money to buy an annuity outside of a retirement plan. You can distribute it into a Rollover IRA tax free. The distributions from the rollover account are taxable. As your mother is not a high income taxpayer, NJ is friendly towards distributions from rollover IRAs. Setting up a bond ladder within a rollover account is incredibly easy with Schwab.
 

KK1827

All-American
Nov 4, 2023
2,893
8,190
48
You DON'T distribute the money to buy an annuity outside of a retirement plan. You can distribute it into a Rollover IRA tax free. The distributions from the rollover account are taxable. As your mother is not a high income taxpayer, NJ is friendly towards distributions from rollover IRAs. Setting up a bond ladder within a rollover account is incredibly easy with Schwab.
Gotcha. So basically you roll the 401K into an IRA and then use the $800K to buy an annuity through there and the lets say $6200/month distributed via the annuity is then taxed. Am I following correctly?
 

RUTGERS95

Heisman
Sep 28, 2005
25,934
34,778
113
You can also open a treasury direct account and buy bills, notes and bonds directly from the treasury.
Also for tax purposes Vanguard has a NJ bond fund which is tax free. Probably available from other sources too
sgov is another one yielding 5.15 with no state income tax. it's short term if anyone just wants and easy etf
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,014
18,364
113
Gotcha. So basically you roll the 401K into an IRA and then use the $800K to buy an annuity through there and the lets say $6200/month distributed via the annuity is then taxed. Am I following correctly?

Check with the vendor of the annuity. Someone made a good point above about "Term certain". That's important.
 

Extra Point_rivals157299

All-Conference
Aug 9, 2001
13,169
4,691
0
Thinking about the annuity, dividing 800K by the annual payout of 67,200 would last almost 12 years. If the average woman's life span is 80, 80 minus 67 is 13 years, only a year longer than if she spent the 800K getting 0 interest on it. I guess an annuity makes sense for people who have good genes and will live a long life, to 90 or 100 years old and for people who want to leave their offspring a chunk of money.
 

mdk02

Heisman
Aug 18, 2011
26,014
18,364
113
Thinking about the annuity, dividing 800K by the annual payout of 67,200 would last almost 12 years. If the average woman's life span is 80, 80 minus 67 is 13 years, only a year longer than if she spent the 800K getting 0 interest on it. I guess an annuity makes sense for people who have good genes and will live a long life, to 90 or 100 years old and for people who want to leave their offspring a chunk of money.

A fair point, but I believe the average life expectancy for a 67 year old woman is more like 85.
 

RUschool

Heisman
Jan 23, 2004
49,910
13,999
78
Does she have a decent social security payment? Does she need more than $5,000 month which is $60,000 annually especially if the mortgage is paid off and probably translate to $80,000 salary before taxes and deductions?
 

T2Kplus20

Heisman
May 1, 2007
30,233
18,208
113
Does she have a decent social security payment? Does she need more than $5,000 month which is $60,000 annually especially if the mortgage is paid off and probably translate to $80,000 salary before taxes and deductions?
It really seems like a competent financial planner/manager can do a lot better job than an annuity. Generate the required cash flow with better preservation of principle.

Perhaps KK should call Fidelity or another big shop and speak with a wealth manager?
 

phs73rc77gsm83

All-Conference
Aug 11, 2011
3,040
3,831
83
It really seems like a competent financial planner/manager can do a lot better job than an annuity. Generate the required cash flow with better preservation of principle.

Perhaps KK should call Fidelity or another big shop and speak with a wealth manager?
I don’t use an advisor but Vanguard’s Personal Advisor program charges 30 basis points annually for that asset amount. I think Schwab and Fidelity would be comparable. That’s on top of any fees for funds and/or annuities that may be purchased, but lower than Fisher or other groups of that ilk. Anyone (an advisor or otherwise) would want to know SS, equity in home, other income streams, goals (leave KK or siblings an inheritance), expenses, discretionary wishes beyond necessary expenses, etc.). Also, i am guessing KK could be a “backstop” in a worst case scenario so that could increase flexibility.
 
  • Like
Reactions: T2Kplus20

KK1827

All-American
Nov 4, 2023
2,893
8,190
48
Does she have a decent social security payment? Does she need more than $5,000 month which is $60,000 annually especially if the mortgage is paid off and probably translate to $80,000 salary before taxes and deductions?
She will get about $3400/month SS and an additional $1200/month from a prudential an old annuity and then she will have this $800K to decide what to do with. These annuities actually seem like a pretty solid option if the only concern is cashflow
 

KK1827

All-American
Nov 4, 2023
2,893
8,190
48
I don’t use an advisor but Vanguard’s Personal Advisor program charges 30 basis points annually for that asset amount. I think Schwab and Fidelity would be comparable. That’s on top of any fees for funds and/or annuities that may be purchased, but lower than Fisher or other groups of that ilk. Anyone (an advisor or otherwise) would want to know SS, equity in home, other income streams, goals (leave KK or siblings an inheritance), expenses, discretionary wishes beyond necessary expenses, etc.). Also, i am guessing KK could be a “backstop” in a worst case scenario so that could increase flexibility.
Yeah me and my sister do well for ourselves so were not banking on inheriting anything from my mother so my main thing is maximizing her retirement cashflow. She plans on retiring after her 67th bday which will October 2028 so we have some time to plan
 
  • Like
Reactions: phs73rc77gsm83