Please go back and read what I posted. Best player, not best RB.
Zamir white is the best RB I have ever seen in 30+ years of watching HS football. He has a 2nd gear that is breathtaking and more wiggle than Crouch. All that said I think most scouts would say you are splitting hairs because Crouch is 6'2 225 and still growing. He is Eddie George to White's Saquan Barkely.
Crouch however is also the best defensive player on the field as well. His numbers against a good Providence team when I saw him were 23 carries for 350 yards and 4 TD's, 2 sacks, 3 TFL's and double digit tackles. He played DE, OLB, MLB and SS at various times in that game.
I believe Scotland without White is a 8-9 win team. HArding without Crouch wins 4 maybe 5 games and is one and done in the playoffs. Beyond that Scotland was and will remain a good to great football program once White is gone. Crouch has taken a program that has had exactly 2 winning seasons since 1990 and made them a legitimate state title contender.
Crouch is the best football player in the state and maybe in the country. Its really not that close.