The "it will hurt recruiting" ******** is the dumbest of all the arguments in this debate. Sure, we might be giving them a Super Bowl, and they may stand to benefit more financially from this than us, but I just can't see it being the end of the world with a recruit.
MSU coach: Hi there. You're quite the talented player. We'd love to have you come to Starkville and play for us.
Recruit: What do you have to offer me?
MSU coach: Well, for starters, we run a spread offense. It's perfect for someone as talented as you are.
Recruit: But I'm thinking about going to USM. I saw where they beat you last year.
MSU coach: Yes, they did. The atmosphere was electric and everybody was fired up. But that was the biggest game of the year for them. At State, every game is the biggest game of the year. We play on TV every single week. You want to make it to the pros? Your chances will increase with that kind of exposure. If we win our conference, we get a chance to play for a national championship. At USM, you get to play in the Liberty Bowl. Have a look around our campus. Isn't it beautiful? See that stadium over there? It holds 55,000 people. Your face might be on one of those banners one day. At USM, their stadium holds 30,000 people and looks like a Jim Walter manufactured home. They don't play on TV very much, and when they do, it's usually on Thursday night or something goofy. Everybody is watching The Office on Thursdays. See that pretty girl over there? There's more of those here than in Hattiesburg. Come check out our facilities - locker room, weight room, IPF - were you more impressed with ours or USM's during your visit there? Be honest. Coach Mullen would really love to have a player like you wearing maroon. We think you're the type of player that will turn our program around. Here's an offer letter. What do you think?
Recruit: I'm going to sign with Southern Miss.
MSU coach: Why? What about all that stuff I just said?
Recruit: Well, they beat you last year. Plus my auntie lives in Wiggins.