As the NCAA faces numerous court cases that could shake up the landscape of the sport in the coming months and years, one argument the NCAA used to make no longer seems to be working. Amateurism has long been a shield for the organization, wanting to protect it to preserve the integrity of the game.



But, legally speaking, the footing on which to stand on that front is rapidly eroding.



Typically the NCAA has pointed to a 1984 case concerning TV rights as its standing on the amateurism claims, but in one of the latest developments, a judge has ruled that that case does not pertain to amateurism arguments.



“It’s exactly what you just said, he said that’s irrelevant here,” explained Michael McCann, a legal expert for Sportico, on the Andy Staples On3 show. “That case is about TV contracts. It has no bearing on college athletes. And the NCAA would repeatedly use that language. As you said, in a case that they lost, ironically, it was their best case. And here the court said, really just dismissed it quickly to say, ‘That’s irrelevant.'”



As the court system grapples over how to handle NIL and potential anti-trust issues governing the topic, getting a precise handle on all the legalese can be challenging.



But this came down in no uncertain terms.



“This isn’t about TV contracts between schools, conferences and the NCAA and TV networks, this is about compensation for college athletes,” McCann said. “In the Alston case in the form of reimbursement for education-related expenses. So for the court to so quickly and swiftly dismiss it, that had to be jarring for the NCAA.”



Time will tell which direction the NCAA goes from here, but preliminary indications are that <a href="https://www.on3.com/college/tennessee-volunteers/news/why-the-ncaa-win-over-tennessee-virginia-attorneys-general-in-court-is-small-likely-short-lived-victory/">the organization is fighting a losing battle</a>.



At some point, the NCAA might just have to find some collective bargaining type of model that works for everyone or risk the entire system going bust.



This much is clear: The NCAA could use a win.



“The last decade has been so rough for their legal team and I don’t know where the window is for them,” McCann said. “I think to Charlie Baker‘s credit he’s at least proposed something that tries to resolve, tries to separate certain schools from others. I think that’s smart. I don’t know if it’s going to have any traction. As the NCAA says, it’s a membership organization. We’ll see what kind of persuasion he has.”

how-many-legal-threats-is-ncaa-facing-lets-count-them

On3 Football

Explaining why the NCAA cannot use 'amateurism' as defense in court

team image

The Main Board

Football

Basketball

Women's Basketball

Softball

Baseball

Teams

Fan Sites

Forums

Shows

team-link

College Football News

College Football Player Rankings

College Football Rankings

College Football Playoff

College Basketball News

Women's Sports

College

NIL News

NIL Valuation

NIL Deals

NIL Deal Tracker

Sports Business

Transfer Portal News

NCAA Transfer Portal News

NCAA Transfer Portal

Transfer Portal Rankings

Transfer Portal Team Rankings

Transfer Portal

NCAA Transfer Portal Home

Football Recruiting

Basketball Recruiting

Database

Team Rankings

Player Rankings

Industry Comparison

Commitments

Recruiting Prediction Machine

Recruiting

High School News

Schools

High School Search

Rankings

High School Rankings

Scores

High School Scores

High School

NFL Draft

NFL Draft News

Draft By Stars

College Draft History

College Draft Totals

NBA Draft

NBA Draft News

Draft

NASCAR

Culture

Sports Betting

About

On3 App

Advertise

Press

Contact

Alabama

Arizona State

Arizona

Arkansas

Auburn

Baylor

Boston College

California

Removed

Clemson

Colorado

Duke

Florida

Florida State

Georgia

Georgia Tech

Illinois

Indiana

Iowa

Iowa State

Kansas

Kansas State

Kentucky

Lettermen Row

Lettermen Lounge

Louisville

Maryland

Miami

Michigan State

Michigan

Minnesota

Mississippi State

Missouri

NC State

Nebraska

North Carolina

Northwestern

Notre Dame

Ohio State

Oklahoma

Oklahoma State

Ole Miss

Oregon

Oregon State

Penn State

Pittsburgh

Purdue

Rutgers

South Carolina

Stanford

Syracuse

Tennessee

Texas A&M

Texas

Texas Tech

UCLA

Utah

Vanderbilt

Virginia

Virginia Tech

Wake Forest

Washington

Washington State

West Virginia

Wisconsin

BamaOnLine

BOL Round Table

Inside Texas

IT Members Only

DawgsHQ

Dawg Walk

Scoop Duck

Recruiting & Sports

AuburnSports

The Corner

WeAreSC

GarryP's Trojan Huddle

The Wolverine

The Fort

The Lions Den

The Wolfpacker

The Wolves’ Den

GatorsOnline

Swamp Talk

Alabama A&M

Alabama State

Albany

Alcorn State

Abilene Christian

Appalachian State

Akron

Army

Austin Peay

Arkansas-Pine Bluff

Arkansas-Little Rock

Arkansas State

Air Force

Ball State

American

Wofford

Winthrop

Wisconsin-Milwaukee

Wisconsin-Green Bay

Wichita State

Western Carolina

Volleyball

Gymnastics

Men's Lacrosse

Women's Lacrosse

Men's Soccer

Women's Soccer

Women's Track

Men's Golf

Women's Golf

Men's Hockey

Women's Hockey

Men's Swimming

Women's Swimming

Wrestling

Men's Tennis

Women's Tennis

Annual $1

Annual Premium

Annual $1 

Monthly

Annual

Unlimited Access to This and All Articles.

Article (On3 Plus Rivals)

Forum (On3 Plus Rivals)

Intro

Join

College scoop, experts, and community - all in one.

Explaining why the NCAA cannot use 'amateurism' as defense in court

2026 All-America Team

5-Star Countdown

Duke, Darian Mensah

NCAA files motion

Bill Belichick