2025 Phillies Thread

WestSideLion

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
3,655
4,067
113
I agree, for being a top 5 highest payroll there way too many holes in the everyday lineup and that's not even getting into the bullpen
I don’t think they’re a top-5 team in MLB. They don’t score runs consistently enough and their bullpen has regressed to the mean.

It’s a long season and Dombrowski can still make a move or three, but I’m thinking they’ll be hard pressed to make a run at the third wild card spot.
 

Grant Green

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,895
3,973
113
I don’t think they’re a top-5 team in MLB. They don’t score runs consistently enough and their bullpen has regressed to the mean.

It’s a long season and Dombrowski can still make a move or three, but I’m thinking they’ll be hard pressed to make a run at the third wild card spot.
Care to wager? $100 that the Phillies make the playoffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PSUAVLNC

Grant Green

Well-known member
Oct 12, 2021
2,895
3,973
113
LOL. Have you folks ever watched an entire baseball season?

The amazing 2008 Phillies were 15-4 in the end of May and early June.
The followed that by going 5-13 with a 1-8 streak. Reeeeeeelax!

Addendum: 2009 Phillies - arguably even better than 2008
end May-early June: 15-4
early to late June: 5-14 (includes a 1-9 streak)
 
Last edited:

rudedude

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
7,096
13,966
113
A stat of infamy, not good




 

RyanSnyder

Well-known member
Staff member
Sep 20, 2021
27,424
137,637
113
I don’t think they’re a top-5 team in MLB. They don’t score runs consistently enough and their bullpen has regressed to the mean.

It’s a long season and Dombrowski can still make a move or three, but I’m thinking they’ll be hard pressed to make a run at the third wild card spot.

They’ll be fine. Luzardo has to be tipping pitches or something.
 

LB99

Well-known member
Oct 27, 2021
7,148
9,613
113
I don’t think they’re a top-5 team in MLB. They don’t score runs consistently enough and their bullpen has regressed to the mean.

It’s a long season and Dombrowski can still make a move or three, but I’m thinking they’ll be hard pressed to make a run at the third wild card spot.
The bullpen didn’t just regress. It wasn’t seriously addressed in the offseason. They didn’t get a surefire bullpen guy with any history of success. Alvarado, even before the suspension, was all or nothing. He is either lights out or all over the place. Getting another backend bullpen guy like Tanner Scott would have been a smart move. At this point, this may sound crazy, but can Nola close? He’s usually good for an inning or two then it’s anybody’s guess. They needed another OF bat also. They loosely addressed it with the new left fielder, but the jury is still out. They still don’t have anyone in the lineup that is a consistent hitter. Lots of power, but when the bats go cold, they go really cold. Just my view from the cheap seats.
 

rudedude

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
7,096
13,966
113
They’ll be fine. Luzardo has to be tipping pitches or something.
I think his arm is shot, some injury not apparent yet. I predict Tommy John surgery. I know some may think I’m nuts but pitch tipping ain’t it.
 
Last edited:

nittanyfan333

Well-known member
Oct 6, 2021
2,978
5,885
113
Two of the three outfield positions contribute next to nothing offensively, and the defense is nothing to brag about there either. And ffs, throw in the towel with Romano. He's not the closer.

Yeah I’m with you. Kepler and Marsh are…. Less than ideal offensively. Marsh is like Casty. He puts a few good games together in the playoffs and everyone forgets. And spot on about Romano. They need a legit closer.

Feels like after this one, it’s time to dip into the pigs…. Bring up some of the boys for a stretch and see what’s what.
 

kgilbert78

Well-known member
Oct 25, 2021
778
1,253
93
The trick with this team is that they are streaky--both good and bad--and have been that way for a few years now,