Year 1 was probably always gonna be a pass for me from the beginning. Late hire, nothing in the cupboard but Travis Perry, Portal already open, and high school recruiting mostly all but done. He had to build a plane while flying it. Some staff choices were questionable buddy hires, but both Hart and AB3 seemed, at the time, like great recruiting hires. That team did have some head scratching losses, but strung together a ton of improbable wins as well. It was exciting to watch and made us hopeful with a little time to settle into the job and more time to recruit, Pope could be successful here. Especially without injuries.
Year 2 they missed on a lot of recruits, missed on a lot of top level portal guys, and tried to shoe horn a ton of 6th men into starting roles and overpaid to try and improve in athleticism. The staff, the players, and a lot of the fans got drunk on the hype and potential. He also took a flier on JQ, a calculated risk, that if it hit, would make the team a contender in his mind. And if it missed, he thought he had the athleticism to compete without him. But there were noticeable cracks even before the season tipped off. He lost Lewis, he didn't get a backup PG, he built his lineup around Lowe and then you lose the PG before the season even starts. He missed on his high percentage shooters. He brought in a bruiser PF and sacrificed shooting there. BG did not improve at all and our projected 3rd string Center won the starting spot. The team lacked focus, effort, discipline and direction and Pope looked defeated. I think this is when most fans realized he wasn't built for this job. He didn't get angry, he didn't get in their behinds, he didn't vent his frustration to the media and put his players on blast. He just used political word salad and dodged questions. The media made it worse by lobbing him softball questions and never going for his throat or forcing him to answer things. Recruits saw it, opposing coaches saw it, fans saw it. He projected weakness in a time in college basketball that you cannot look weak. And we suffer for it.
Year 3 was always a forgone conclussion in my mind. You can't make the change while Mitch is still AD, a post June/July coaching hire is crazy talk and would basically forfeit the season if the new AD hires someone as soon as they take over. I think Pope is in lose lose territory. He has gotten played like a fiddle by Wright, Freeman, Collins, and Stokes this cycle, Wilkerson, Dent, Wilson and Ament last year, and it just crushes his image publicly and makes KY a joke. The man will almost certainly have to win the SEC and go to the Elite 8 to even be considered for year 4 at this point (unless the university is dead set on killing men's basketball amidst their hatred of NIL) as opposed to Rev Share.
I like Mark the man, the former player. But as many have said, he gives off that overly enthusiastic Youth Pastor vibe and it is not working here. I want him to succeed, but this experiment needs to end if he can't accomplish the assignment...