Toggle sidebar

Band halftime show tonight

ScarletDave

ScarletDave

Heisman
Oct 7, 2010
34,382
14,987
85
Guys, make sure to check out the Marching Scarlet Knights halftime show tonight! It's going to be really awesome/fun. Stay in your seats for that extra few minutes before you run and get a hotdog. If you like the stuff Ohio State does, you'll love this show! Here's a sneak peak from the Facebook page:

 
R

RC1991

All-Conference
Jul 31, 2003
3,760
1,706
81
I guess it will depend on whether or not Tim Smith and company were able to pilfer the drill and arrangements from OSU.....of course we know he won't be able to teach it. This will be.....intersting to say the least.
 
K

kupuna133

All-American
Jul 13, 2015
5,981
6,602
113
Can't come on the board and advertise an exciting halftime show if that is the product. Teen age kid in my section yelled out that Ridge High School did that exact show 3 years ago in her sisters senior year. Spelling out Halo and making a Z is not going to keep people in their seats at halftime.
 
L

LadyRU09

Junior
Jul 3, 2007
5,197
302
0
I enjoyed it! (geek here)

Loved the start screen and GAME OVER. But was that a Triforce during their Zelda segment? I couldn't see it clearly from my vantage point.
 
R

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
Pretty weak, imo.

Lots of "march to a spot, then stop for 16 bars, then march to another spot, then stop for 16 bars..." If the drill designer is going for somewhat recognizable forms (i.e. triforce, Tetris pieces) and is making the audience stare at them for long periods, then the drill instructor has to do a better job making sure the band can hit those forms (especially straight lines).
 
DJ Spanky

DJ Spanky

Heisman
Jul 25, 2001
46,245
56,119
113
kupuna133 said:
Can't come on the board and advertise an exciting halftime show if that is the product. Teen age kid in my section yelled out that Ridge High School did that exact show 3 years ago in her sisters senior year. Spelling out Halo and making a Z is not going to keep people in their seats at halftime.
Click to expand...
So where do you think he gets his ideas?
 
S

Scarlet16e2

All-Conference
Nov 22, 2005
8,980
4,046
113
One note:

The video board director needs to stick to the wide-angle from above, showing the whole field to help with this.
I couldn't tell what the formation was from my angle, and the scoreboard is showing close-ups of individual musicians.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruready07
O

OTBOTOR

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2014
2,339
2,158
0
Tough crowd.

I enjoyed the show. It would be great if we could either (a) increase the size of the band to 450, or (b) have a wall of microphones on the field to pipe the band over the speakers like when they play in the stands. You really cannot hear much when the band is playing on the field and that's a shame.
 
O

OTBOTOR

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2014
2,339
2,158
0
LadyRU09 said:
I enjoyed it! (geek here)

Loved the start screen and GAME OVER. But was that a Triforce during their Zelda segment? I couldn't see it clearly from my vantage point.
Click to expand...

I'd call it more of a try-force. The lines were not straight, but Triforce was what they were going for.
 
R

RC1991

All-Conference
Jul 31, 2003
3,760
1,706
81
The fact that he took the show from a HS band is not surprising.....though spelling out of "HALO" was probably from OSU. Just for reference here is the OSU video game halftime from 2012:

 
R

RUChoppin

Heisman
Dec 1, 2006
19,270
13,695
0
The band director's prior musical experience prior to Rutgers was managing a Coconuts.
OTBOTOR said:
Tough crowd.

I enjoyed the show. It would be great if we could either (a) increase the size of the band to 450, or (b) have a wall of microphones on the field to pipe the band over the speakers like when they play in the stands. You really cannot hear much when the band is playing on the field and that's a shame.
Click to expand...

Or if we could field a band of size with instrumentation you can hear in a stadium. Ohio State has 196 brass instruments and 28 drumline. From rough estimates the first game, we had about 150-160 marching members (including drumline, excluding color guard)... and of those, at least a third to a half were woodwinds that you can't hear in a packed stadium without microphones.

I played saxophone in marching band... but I know that there's no way that instrument can be heard across a loud stadium without a microphone. In a quiet stadium for marching band competition or exhibition, woodwinds are perfectly fine - in a college football environment, you need brass and lots of it.
 
O

Ole Cabbagehead

All-American
Apr 21, 2011
8,075
6,323
0
When it comes to creative stuff, you can't rip off someone else's idea with a worse version. Its like re-making a song and doing it worse. Not only was the idea copied from OSU, but many of the formations were copied, and they were mostly executed worse.
 
J

JerseyShoreKnight

All-Conference
Jan 2, 2014
3,081
2,954
0
Yeah, the video board needed to stick to the above field view. Couldn't tell what they were doing from my seats. And the band still only plays to one side of the field. Could only hear the drums. Got some of the trumpets part of the time, but could make out any songs. Doesn't the band have section leaders? Why doesn't the band spread out? They could have the section leaders up high with the director and conduct in sync with one another. I've seen this at other schools' halftime shows. All the leaders do is keep their eyes on the director and mimic him. It would be nice if the entire stadium could hear the music and see the show.
 
G

gigantor1024

All-Conference
Apr 6, 2006
6,166
3,384
0
music was okay but the choreographer needs to be fired asap. What was the weird blob after the star durng mario music? and the tri force was the worst tri force i've ever seen, ever.
and why was the H in Halo so fat and crooked.

music sounded good when they were facing the camera.
 
O

OTBOTOR

All-Conference
Aug 28, 2014
2,339
2,158
0
RUChoppin said:
In a quiet stadium for marching band competition or exhibition, woodwinds are perfectly fine - in a college football environment, you need brass and lots of it.
Click to expand...

JMU would disagree with you. But they have something like 500 musicians.
 
bac2therac

bac2therac

Hall of Famer
Jul 30, 2001
238,094
167,826
113
I couldn't hear a thing plus I couldn't hear the alma mater

how does Tim Smith still have a job
 
  • Like
Reactions: ruready07
S

Scarlet Jerry

All-Conference
Jul 30, 2001
4,208
2,456
0
Everyone in our section loved the halftime show, but you should feel free to come over to the band parents tailgate at the next game and tell us how badly our kids suck. Our kids spend a week in the summer at band camp where they practice from dawn through the night. During the season, they rehearse every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday after going to class all day, and spend their entire Saturday rehearsing then entertaining the crowd during the game. They sure sound loud enough in the YouTube video that is taped from the top of the stadium's upper deck.

Would you like to compare the band to a well-established B1G marching band? Check out the Penn State Blue Band's halftime show from this year's Rutgers game (below). If our band did their show, people would be talking about how "boring" the formations are and how the music stinks.

-Scarlet Jerry
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir ScarletKnight
D

DHajekRC84

Heisman
Aug 9, 2001
30,709
19,816
0
Scarlet Jerry said:
Everyone in our section loved the halftime show, but you should feel free to come over to the band parents tailgate at the next game and tell us how badly our kids suck.
-Scarlet Jerry
Click to expand...


I haven't EVER read a post here about the Band where ANYBODY has said the kids suck or it is their fault. We all know WHO the problem is and what the problem is. NOT enough members, Not enough Brass, lack of creativity and terrible uninspired leadership.

Phil Collins boring? PSU marches with spats and is tight. RU Drum and Bugle "plant your heels and walk" in black shoes is yuk. Not a Marching Band thing. Sorry. Again, the kids can only do what they are told to do.

Edit: having watched it again and will say that the movement was quite better than I have seen in a while. 50% more horns and percussion would add A LOT. THAT is the biggest issue. Just too small and not loud enough.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: billhobo
K

knight90

Sophomore
Jun 22, 2009
444
136
0
I couldn't hear them from my seat. They need either more members or some microphones.
 
R

RUJohnny99

All-American
Nov 7, 2003
64,667
5,961
113
144 instruments
18 flag twirlers

Imagine how impressive it would be if they gave all those flag twirlers bass drums instead.
And give them to the flutes too.
 
C

ClassOf02v.2

Heisman
Sep 30, 2010
13,556
14,784
103
Scarlet Jerry said:
Everyone in our section loved the halftime show, but you should feel free to come over to the band parents tailgate at the next game and tell us how badly our kids suck. Our kids spend a week in the summer at band camp where they practice from dawn through the night. During the season, they rehearse every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday after going to class all day, and spend their entire Saturday rehearsing then entertaining the crowd during the game. They sure sound loud enough in the YouTube video that is taped from the top of the stadium's upper deck.

Would you like to compare the band to a well-established B1G marching band? Check out the Penn State Blue Band's halftime show from this year's Rutgers game (below). If our band did their show, people would be talking about how "boring" the formations are and how the music stinks.

-Scarlet Jerry
Click to expand...


When a football coach is fired (at Rutgers or anywhere else) for underperforming with the available talent, it is NEVER about the players. It's always about the coach's abilities (or lack thereof). Same thing with the band. NO ONE is questioning the talents or dedication of the band members at all. It's entirely about the leadership they have. The kids are awesome and they deserve better.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom