Basketball BREAKING -- Rutgers senior guard Paul Mulcahy plans to enter the transfer portal, he announced:

aplus29

Senior
Apr 29, 2003
372
434
63
Pikiell is living in the stone age. His koom-bah-yah approach to locker room chemistry has screwed us time and time again. Myles, JY, Mathis defecting probably moved us from a Sweet 16 team to a first four. Holding on to Rieber, Miller, and Palm for an extra year cost us a bid. We have been sleepwalking through this offseason and now have 4 open scholarships and a starter returning from ACL surgery. We are essentially 8 deep at this very minute and that consists of a frosh PG, and an unproven redshirt
 

MiloTalon13

All-American
Jun 3, 2022
3,979
5,608
0
Believe me or not. My insight is solid.

It is about the perceived attention going to the future recruits vs the current roster.
I believe you, at least that it's a major factor among several.
These guys have big egos that have been fed their whole lives by almost everyone around them.

Had to be a cumulative effect for Paul too. Cam last year, GG this year, Ace and maybe Dylan next year.
Plus his spring after season had to be humbling.
Maybe even conversations with PIke about not playing much point, maybe even not starting.
All of that and if someone said "I'll give you 30+ mins at point guard"
 
Dec 5, 2022
1,346
1,664
0
Pikiell is living in the stone age. His koom-bah-yah approach to locker room chemistry has screwed us time and time again. Myles, JY, Mathis defecting probably moved us from a Sweet 16 team to a first four. Holding on to Rieber, Miller, and Palm for an extra year cost us a bid. We have been sleepwalking through this offseason and now have 4 open scholarships and a starter returning from ACL surgery. We are essentially 8 deep at this very minute and that consists of a frosh PG, and an unproven redshirt
Pikes the man. This is a very silly post.
 
Nov 15, 2001
15,044
15,615
0
Pikiell is living in the stone age. His koom-bah-yah approach to locker room chemistry has screwed us time and time again. Myles, JY, Mathis defecting probably moved us from a Sweet 16 team to a first four. Holding on to Rieber, Miller, and Palm for an extra year cost us a bid. We have been sleepwalking through this offseason and now have 4 open scholarships and a starter returning from ACL surgery. We are essentially 8 deep at this very minute and that consists of a frosh PG, and an unproven redshirt
But we might have Dylan, Ace, Griffiths, and two walkons for a year…so there’s that.
 

csphi

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
17,059
18,782
102
Pikiell is living in the stone age. His koom-bah-yah approach to locker room chemistry has screwed us time and time again. Myles, JY, Mathis defecting probably moved us from a Sweet 16 team to a first four. Holding on to Rieber, Miller, and Palm for an extra year cost us a bid. We have been sleepwalking through this offseason and now have 4 open scholarships and a starter returning from ACL surgery. We are essentially 8 deep at this very minute and that consists of a frosh PG, and an unproven redshirt
Ummm

Myles left for education reasons

Guess you missed that one
 

RobotHunter

All-Conference
May 8, 2015
2,702
4,189
81
Pikiell is living in the stone age. His koom-bah-yah approach to locker room chemistry has screwed us time and time again. Myles, JY, Mathis defecting probably moved us from a Sweet 16 team to a first four. Holding on to Rieber, Miller, and Palm for an extra year cost us a bid. We have been sleepwalking through this offseason and now have 4 open scholarships and a starter returning from ACL surgery. We are essentially 8 deep at this very minute and that consists of a frosh PG, and an unproven redshirt
He also knows that the entire roster has been tampered with and schools are trying to poach his players. I wonder if he is doing the same? He may be but something tells me he's not. If not he is putting Rutgers at a disadvantage.
 

csphi

Heisman
Jul 26, 2001
17,059
18,782
102
In a post game basketball interview, athletes are asked basketball questions, and are expected to discuss basketball, not proselytize their faith. He did it more than once. It was cringy. He's the one that put it our there.
So….that is what he believes and finds meaning in it….then more power to him

Again….who are you to judge ?

Seems like you are one of those who preach tolerance and acceptance until one disagrees with you
 

Plum Street

Heisman
Jun 21, 2009
27,306
23,009
0
This is what he said in March


“Pike's the best coach in the country; he's an incredible person.” Mulcahy said in March, after Rutgers’ season-ending loss to Hofstra in the NIT. “You play a year for him or however long, he's got you for life. He believed in me when a lot of others didn’t. He’s taken a lot of heat because of me. He does it for everybody. He believes in all of us. He deserves all the things he worked for. He’s going to get us to higher places. I’m so thankful that I got to play for him. There’s a lot going on in college basketball, but he’s the best coach. I’m so grateful for him.”
 

pmvon

All-American
Jan 30, 2007
7,614
7,169
0
1. Why is this happening?
2. Paul got way to much guff from fans.
3. Played his asssss off
4. Has no RU legacy now. One year rental guy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: malaka27
Nov 15, 2001
15,044
15,615
0
This is what he said in March


“Pike's the best coach in the country; he's an incredible person.” Mulcahy said in March, after Rutgers’ season-ending loss to Hofstra in the NIT. “You play a year for him or however long, he's got you for life. He believed in me when a lot of others didn’t. He’s taken a lot of heat because of me. He does it for everybody. He believes in all of us. He deserves all the things he worked for. He’s going to get us to higher places. I’m so thankful that I got to play for him. There’s a lot going on in college basketball, but he’s the best coach. I’m so grateful for him.”
Well, Pike certainly is up at bat now. Let’s see what he comes up with.
 

RutgersNo1

All-Conference
Sep 28, 2021
2,614
2,987
0
There was always big money involved it's just bigger and on the table now. Also, I'm hearing that money is not the driving force behind Paul's decision.
If his unhappiness was the main factor, he would have been long gone.
 

mikebal9

All-Conference
Oct 15, 2005
5,731
4,961
113
I have no insider knowledge at all. BUt to me, that message says he wants to be a point guard. If that's the case, and he was told that he won't be playing PG here any more, than he did what was best for him.
In the right offense, Paul is a great point guard with excellent court vision and basketball IQ. Oddly, I thought playing alongside Gavin and Simpson, he could have been that for us. I feel like the addition of Noah was probably the straw that broke Paul's back.
 
Nov 15, 2001
15,044
15,615
0
I have no insider knowledge at all. BUt to me, that message says he wants to be a point guard. If that's the case, and he was told that he won't be playing PG here any more, than he did what was best for him.
In the right offense, Paul is a great point guard with excellent court vision and basketball IQ. Oddly, I thought playing alongside Gavin and Simpson, he could have been that for us. I feel like the addition of Noah was probably the straw that broke Paul's back.
If that’s the case, he should have announced he was leaving two months ago, so Pike could find a legit replacement.
 

mikebal9

All-Conference
Oct 15, 2005
5,731
4,961
113
If that’s the case, he should have announced he was leaving two months ago, so Pike could find a legit replacement.
I keep reading this, and everyone thinks a kid should make a decision immediately. For example, the day we got Noah, Paul should have transferred out. To me, Paul just isn't that kid. He gave himself time to cool off, think it through, speak to the people he trusts, and make a well-informed decision. I know it sucks for the team, but it's definitely a more mature way to make a decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MURF87

Russ Wood

Heisman
Oct 12, 2011
94,313
45,143
0
If his unhappiness was the main factor, he would have been long gone.
Not necessarily. Not everyone is in "I'm getting the hell outta here as soon as possible," mode.

Idk what's in Mulcahy's mind but it is possible that he was unhappy but also struggled with the decision to return to RU or entering the portal.

It doesn't have to be an either or thing. Both can be true.
 

RutgersNo1

All-Conference
Sep 28, 2021
2,614
2,987
0
Not necessarily. Not everyone is in "I'm getting the hell outta here as soon as possible," mode.

Idk what's in Mulcahy's mind but it is possible that he was unhappy but also struggled with the decision to return to RU or entering the portal.

It doesn't have to be an either or thing. Both can be true.
If he's been struggling with the decision, the team wouldn't expect him to be back and the experts/insiders wouldn't say he's 99% back.
 

AshCatchEm

Heisman
Jan 8, 2016
13,811
19,736
113
Not necessarily. Not everyone is in "I'm getting the hell outta here as soon as possible," mode.

Idk what's in Mulcahy's mind but it is possible that he was unhappy but also struggled with the decision to return to RU or entering the portal.

It doesn't have to be an either or thing. Both can be true.
If you're the captain of a boat and the boat has left the dock already for the next season, you don't jump into the water and swim to shore leaving the boat adrift. The time to depart was earlier. Aka when the portal was still open.

Idk how any self respecting Rutgers fan can have any respect for this kid abandoning the team this late.
 

ru66

All-American
Jul 28, 2001
12,175
6,255
0
All the BS aside what RU needs and always needed was $ and not words.
 

mikebal9

All-Conference
Oct 15, 2005
5,731
4,961
113
If you're the captain of a boat and the boat has left the dock already for the next season, you don't jump into the water and swim to shore leaving the boat adrift. The time to depart was earlier. Aka when the portal was still open.

Idk how any self respecting Rutgers fan can have any respect for this kid abandoning the team this late.
A captain of a boat and a captain of a college basketball team are drastically different. One would leve people at sea to literally die. One would leave a basketball team a little short at guard.
 

AshCatchEm

Heisman
Jan 8, 2016
13,811
19,736
113
A captain of a boat and a captain of a college basketball team are drastically different. One would leve people at sea to literally die. One would leave a basketball team a little short at guard.
One would screw over a team he represented for 4 years and the man who stuck by him even when he was playing like literal horseshit*
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ru7580
Dec 4, 2010
5,866
5,255
0
So….that is what he believes and finds meaning in it….then more power to him

Again….who are you to judge ?

Seems like you are one of those who preach tolerance and acceptance until one disagrees with you
I'm within my rights to make a comment on a public statement, as are you and Paul. Proselytizing one's particular brand of superstition doesn't earn them a free pass.