Noteworthy, but these metrics, CA and NY, responsible for 22% of our national GDP are "treading water". For those who have a penchant for arguing such things, I'm not sure if they rounded to the 20th or 100th decimal place.*** I am sure they applied the same metrics to all states so the comparative nature holds water. Also, there is a source note if you want to read the Moody's original.
View attachment 1078839
I'd be curious as to whether there's ever a time where you can't make a map that looks like this. I'm guessing there have been times that CA and NY would show up as green by these metrics and MS, AR, and AL still show as red. And probably less often, occasions when California or NY are red and those states are still treading water.
Also, I suspect in most states, you could pretty easily subdivide further. I'm sure TX and CA have regions that may not be doing as poorly as the MS Delta, but are still struggling as much or more than other regions in Mississippi.
Also, haven't found the actual source, but have found some other sources reporting on it, and he makes a lot of comments about people making between $25k to $35k feeling worse than in the past. Well no ****. We're in an inflationary environment and still spending and borrowing a **** ton of money at the federal level, and you are essentially moving down the income range if you're looking at a fixed bracket even from six months ago. Gas and supposedly rents are coming down, so maybe you'll start to see a reversal in that as those income ranges are probably hit the hardest by gas, rent, and food, but there's a reason inflation has been historically seen as worse than a recession. All the people that voted for the covid shutdowns and COVID spending should have their personal wealth confiscated.
ETA: Not sure it's the actual source, but here is a slide deck that I think is from Mood's discussing the source.
https://ncreif.org/__static/jdj5jdewjdvored6mvv4vxjea09htk5n/NCREIF-Zandi-October-2025.pdf
Some interesting slides on immigration and federal debt.