OT: 2023 NY Giants Season Thread
- Thread starter Tango Two
- Start date
- Status
Did Taylor just audible to a run play with no timeouts left?
I dunno. I still think he would, especially if the QB changed the play. With no timeouts there, you have to ensure multiple shots at a TD and 3 points minimum no matter what. Any coach in the league would be pissed off at that, even if the TD was scored.
True, plus they lost the opportunity to kick a FG if the two end zone passes went incomplete. That was very bad.
I'm not saying it's right but I'm a total hypocrite between NFL and college assigning blame for plays like that.
If that played happened Saturday, I would have 100% blamed HC/OC for not making sure the QB knew the situation and options. Coaching staff has to make it clear to the QB.
NFL - mostly blame the QB for it.
If that played happened Saturday, I would have 100% blamed HC/OC for not making sure the QB knew the situation and options. Coaching staff has to make it clear to the QB.
NFL - mostly blame the QB for it.
These kind of things happen to really bad teams....Giants did ALMOST everything right to win, but somehow find a way to lose. Absolute unacceptable play by a QB in the NFL - should really never be allowed to take another snap again after this game.
Tyrod Taylor is a good QB with a ton of experience. If anyone can lead a game winning drive he can.
Don't know why they went with two low percentage long pass plays. Just get the 1st down.
I wouldn't call him a good QB - experienced? Yes! He is a backup QB for a reason. Not sure I understand the 2 bombs on 3rd and 4th down. Very questionable decision making.
Hell of a game. End of first half blunder cost the Giants. Bill defender had a fistful of jersey on that final play too.
But I survive in my knockout pool.
But I survive in my knockout pool.
He was held the entire 10 yards of the end zone
Not a quick grab A full 2 second full ten yard hold
Not a quick grab A full 2 second full ten yard hold
I see how bad the hold was in the after show. That stopped the receiver just enough to not elevate high enough.
Justin Pugh "Straight off the couch" intro.
NFL Fans Ripped NBC’s Rules Analyst for Awful Breakdown of Bad No-Call on Final Play of Giants-Bills
Paraphrase “Well it could be deemed that he was slightly impeded From making the catch blah blah blah “
He held him the entire F-in pattern for a full 10 yards and he couldn’t jump and/or lift his left hand up while also not being able to fully jump for ball. But otherwise I can’t say for sure if he was at least slightly impeded from making the catch.
F OFF.
The refs in the Rutgers game Saturday were an embarrassment to their profession
Can’t wait for robot umpires in baseball
Top 9…3-1 count …ball four , pitch 2-3 inches low called a strike. Next pitch game ending GIDP
Plus the 1st base umpire was caught wanting crowd to cheer for him when he called a runner 3 feet safe out . Umpire should be removed from playoffs for being that bad or letting crowd influence calls.
Umpire rant over for now. Maybe until 12:07 this Saturday
He held him the entire F-in pattern for a full 10 yards and he couldn’t jump and/or lift his left hand up while also not being able to fully jump for ball. But otherwise I can’t say for sure if he was at least slightly impeded from making the catch.
F OFF.
The refs in the Rutgers game Saturday were an embarrassment to their profession
Can’t wait for robot umpires in baseball
Top 9…3-1 count …ball four , pitch 2-3 inches low called a strike. Next pitch game ending GIDP
Plus the 1st base umpire was caught wanting crowd to cheer for him when he called a runner 3 feet safe out . Umpire should be removed from playoffs for being that bad or letting crowd influence calls.
Umpire rant over for now. Maybe until 12:07 this Saturday
When you see that kind of incompetence in NFL officials... how can we ask Big Ten officials to be better?
Oh.. they already called a PI in the end zone. Cannot do it again... obviously. Crazy.. you don't think that was the message? Time is running out.. just keep doing PI.. stop the TD. Hell that last was an untimed play and Buffalo seemed ready to interfere as often as needed. I wonder if we got an all-22 view if there were multiple PIs on all those last plays.
Oh.. they already called a PI in the end zone. Cannot do it again... obviously. Crazy.. you don't think that was the message? Time is running out.. just keep doing PI.. stop the TD. Hell that last was an untimed play and Buffalo seemed ready to interfere as often as needed. I wonder if we got an all-22 view if there were multiple PIs on all those last plays.
The guy that was playing quarterback for USC vs. Notre Dame on Saturday ?
He didn't look so good to me in that one.
Threw 5 Int's all last year----threw 3 in the 1st Half Saturday night.
We got to him a great deal but IMO all the great players have a bad game now and then.
He was due.
Don’t the Giants have a pretty hefty contract tied up in a QB already? Not sure if drafting a QB is in the near future
And a pretty good one when he's not getting sacked 17 times in 6 1/2 quarters. If this disaster continues to unfold the way it looks, I'd take that top 5 pick and trade down once or twice in the 1st for low 1st and a bevy of 2nd and 3rd rounders. Add a couple of interior linemen, a DL and (if Barkley leaves) a RB.
I’m starting to read some reports a lot of people like the kid from UNC a lot too. Most still like Williams more but starting to see talks of Maye possibly going #1.
Pretty good? This the same guy that Tyrod Taylor looked a lot better than a few days ago? Jones stinks - it's always an excuse with him. Always.
That Giant offensive line they're putting out there is as bad as I've seen.
And it's been bad for a while.
Gotta make it tough on any qb.
Tyrod looked a lot better then Jones?
I thought he moved around well, and got rid of the ball quickly, but he, even with the help of Barkley behind him, led the team to zero TD's.
- Status