Well whaddya know? We got another 0.3" since 3 am, bringing my total to 2.1", which somehow sounds like less of a bust than 1.8", lol. Woke up once and saw some light snow and looking at the radar since 3 am I can definitely see another 0.3" (looks like it should've been more, but that's what I measured). Snowing very lightly now at 25F.
Reports of 4-7" on LI, 3-5" for most of NYC including 4.3" in Central Park, breaking their almost 4 year streak without a 4"+ storm (last storm over 4" was 8.3" on 1/28/22, although everyone says they've undermeasured a few times - there's a whole cottage industry on critiquing CPK's snowfall measurements, lol), 3-5" in NENJ (Union up to Bergen), including 4.2" at EWR.
However, I'm not sure anywhere else in NNJ or CNJ got over 3", especially S of 78, apart from NE Middlesex County, as it's the furthest NE part of the NWS-Philly counties; saw a report of 3.2" from Carteret, which is ~8 miles NE of me and reports of 3+" in southern SI, which is 7-8 miles E of me and being NE definitely made a difference.