Left Coast Pirates has made it a habit to criticize Willard and get Holloway off the hook every chance he gets. LCP has bashed Willard for years. Loves Sha probably because he's blinded by the memories of 30 years ago when Sha was a player, and he's the guy who replaced the hated Willard.
I was never a big Willard fan either, but Sha will never be in Willard's class as a coach. Willard is a better than average coach. Sha is a guy without much of a clue about how to run a major conference program. He uses defense, pressing, and "playing hard" to mask his many shortcomings as a basketball coach. Anyone can get guys to play hard. Real coaches build programs, run high level offense, manage in-game adjustments well, and constantly continue to learn, improve, and adapt to the trends in the sport (among other things). Sha does none of that.
both coaches have their flaws, both coaches haves their positive attributes.
I absolutely defend Holloway strongly, because I believe that many here don’t understand how drastic the landscape of college basketball changed from Willard to Holloway. This has been debated at length in the past and I don’t have the energy for a long draw out conversation again. But you will never convince me that it is not night and day what they had / have to deal with at Seton Hall during their tenures.
My biggest issues with Willard, were the following; similar offense structure issues to Sha, missed out on opportunities to elevate the program to higher heights when he had his best teams, always had one foot out the door, and was an arrogant jerk at times and didn’t treat all the people around the program with the respect they deserved.
I never felt that Kevin Willard bled blue and that goes a long way with me personally.
Who knows maybe Sha isn’t the right coach in this NIL / transfer portal structure. Someday we will have a new coach and you can compare his track record to who comes next.
But I don’t agree with comparing Sha’s tenure solely to the success Willard had at the end of his.
For those who want to believe what Shu09 says about me, I challenge you to go back and listen to our farewell episode for Willard.
I don’t think we could have done a more fair job of highlighting all the various aspects of his time at Seton Hall.
https://on.soundcloud.com/utGfvMZW5ByLlWo6pT