Seton Hall Declines Postseason

Running_SHU

Redshirt
Apr 3, 2003
19
17
3
This doesn't surprise me at all. Tournament runs from 4/1 thru 4/5. That's too long to wait.
Beside, why give any additional schools out there a opportunity to scout our roster live & in person.
Sort of why many schools are cancelling their Spring football games.
Agree - there's momentum to keep playing now when you're fresh off BET games and the mindset is to keep playing, but having to wait a couple weeks is tough. The players probably thought they'd be playing sooner which is why they initially said they wanted to keep playing.
 

lloyde dobler

All-Conference
Jan 26, 2004
685
1,007
82
As a Seton Hall fan, I like watching my team play basketball. I’ve watched a lot less meaningful games than the Crown tournament. I’d watch a preseason game if I could.

If there’s some recruiting benefit to not playing, I guess that’s a silver lining. But, personally, I wanted to keep watching SHU games.
By the first week of April, after no games for three weeks, I‘m on to baseball.
 

Garyshu1971

Freshman
Jul 13, 2025
42
70
17
isnt this brand new tourney half as big as last yr? Start date is riduliculous
If it's not suitable, TBEC should tell her so and not let her sign up. These other big time schools and conferences are living up to the deal. And the players are pros so they have agreed to play, If you make a deal, you do it to the maximum. That's the way you do business and this sure is a business. Seton Hall should be grateful for the opportunity Fox has presented them.
 
Last edited:

Piratz

All-Conference
Mar 24, 2004
1,265
2,499
113
Everything has gotten so fragmented, our 2024 NIT run was probably the last of an era. Why risk the injuries if you’re the players going to be FA’s in exhibition play like this?

I appreciate the season we had in the context of where we were last year. We had excitement. We got ranked. We were relevant. It was disappointing that we ended just 10-10 in the BE with so many near wins against top teams, but hey, cest la vie.

Looking forward to next season already with renewed confidence the program can compete.
 

NCAAsorBust

Junior
Jan 14, 2026
366
306
63
Everything has gotten so fragmented, our 2024 NIT run was probably the last of an era. Why risk the injuries if you’re the players going to be FA’s in exhibition play like this?

I appreciate the season we had in the context of where we were last year. We had excitement. We got ranked. We were relevant. It was disappointing that we ended just 10-10 in the BE with so many near wins against top teams, but hey, cest la vie.

Looking forward to next season already with renewed confidence the program can compete.
It ended long before 2024. 2024 had something like 8 teams jump ship. Oklahoma and SJU would've been 1 seeds. Players went from no say to too much say. The swinging of the pendulum has made the fan experience 1000 times worse.
 

Garyshu1971

Freshman
Jul 13, 2025
42
70
17
Everything has gotten so fragmented, our 2024 NIT run was probably the last of an era. Why risk the injuries if you’re the players going to be FA’s in exhibition play like this?

I appreciate the season we had in the context of where we were last year. We had excitement. We got ranked. We were relevant. It was disappointing that we ended just 10-10 in the BE with so many near wins against top teams, but hey, cest la vie.

Looking forward to next season already with renewed confidence the program can compete.
The conference made a deal. You live by it. The players are pros. No excuses.
 

knowknow

Freshman
Jul 4, 2025
31
62
18
The conference made a deal. You live by it. The players are pros. No excuses.
This is all true. The question is what does the contract say? Are the players required to play in a post season tournament? Are there financial penalties if a player develops (dare I say) general soreness right before the game? What if certain players have it written into their contracts that post season play is discretionary? Would Seton Hall not sign a player if the player told you up front it's NCAAorbust? The players have a seat at the table now.
 

HallGuy2323

Junior
Jun 3, 2020
587
387
63
It’s pretty pathetic that SHU gets invited to play in something that FOX is promoting and says no. But wants Fox to support the conference. Like who the heck is SHU to turn down anything??
If anybody deserves blame it is FOX. After years of very obvious and major decline in post season tournaments in both basketball and football it’s their fault for throwing money at a basically dead platform.
 

radecicco

All-Conference
Jun 24, 2013
657
1,000
93
I don’t know what the right answer is but it would have kept the team together for two more weeks. Now everyone is going their own way.
 

VegasPJ1

Junior
Feb 19, 2023
503
352
47
If it's not suitable, TBEC should tell her so and not let her sign up. These other big time schools and conferences are living up to the deal. And the players are pros so they have agreed to play, If you make a deal, you do it to the maximum. That's the way you do business and this sure is a business. Seton Hall should be grateful for the opportunity Fox has presented them.
You might want to check how many Power 5 teams also declined. So many so that b-ball power RU got an invite and accepted. 😂
 
  • Love
Reactions: Silkcity Pirate

ironlung75

Redshirt
Apr 8, 2006
31
31
18
I enjoyed the NIT run personally, but the program suffered. More time was there for players to not get the recruiting attention required. How did we do the year after we won the NIT. I think this is the right decision.
 

NYShoreGuy

Senior
Jan 7, 2006
1,318
672
113
I enjoyed the NIT run personally, but the program suffered. More time was there for players to not get the recruiting attention required. How did we do the year after we won the NIT. I think this is the right decision.
Calendar it was open season for portal now April 7
 

Fishjam

All-Conference
Mar 27, 2016
587
2,059
93
Fox should put there time and effort into developing events like the Crown to be played in November and December.

Many Big East teams are starving for quality opponents and revenue in the OOC. Give me an 8-team Crown tournament in November that pays the teams rather than a Maui MTE which costs Seton Hall hundreds of thousands of dollars to play in.

I understand Fox is looking to capitalize on the March Madness frenzy and sports betting craze when the NCAAT field starts to dwindle down but it's a lot to ask teams to wait 2+ weeks to play for minimal game. A $300k prize sounds great but comes to $20,000 per player if divided among the whole roster.
 

NCAAsorBust

Junior
Jan 14, 2026
366
306
63
This is all true. The question is what does the contract say? Are the players required to play in a post season tournament? Are there financial penalties if a player develops (dare I say) general soreness right before the game? What if certain players have it written into their contracts that post season play is discretionary? Would Seton Hall not sign a player if the player told you up front it's NCAAorbust? The players have a seat at the table now.
A seat that they could negotiate games they play in? Good thing all of them wanted to go to Maui, just think if half of them decided the flight was too long. They’re negotiating not to play. Minor leaguers are supposed to be looking to showcase their abilities to impress someone, anyone and everyone to give them a shot at a higher level. Is a seton hall education going down the toilets that it’s teaching young people not to bet on themselves? I like that the coaching staff wants to start building for next year but players who don’t want to play, get me 12 new ones.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: HallGuy2323

PhishingPirate088

Sophomore
Mar 10, 2022
213
120
43
It is good for them. But it shows you the absolute lack of interest in this tourney.
I don’t care either way but we are a totally irrelevant basketball team with a MORE irrelevant athletics department in general

I would say we are borderline d1 in how we run athletics

So if schools that run actual big time athletics departments want to participate good for them and who are we to say anything to them putting it down
 
  • Like
Reactions: Garyshu1971

knowknow

Freshman
Jul 4, 2025
31
62
18
A seat that they could negotiate games they play in? Good thing all of them wanted to go to Maui, just think if half of them decided the flight was too long. They’re negotiating not to play. Minor leaguers are supposed to be looking to showcase their abilities to impress someone, anyone and everyone to give them a shot at a higher level. Is a seton hall education going down the toilets that it’s teaching young people not to bet on themselves? I like that the coaching staff wants to start building for next year but players who don’t want to play, get me 12 new ones.
Our players, without the benefit of any college degree, negotiated contracts that did not require them to appear in any post season tournaments. They will also file tax returns with W-2s that exceed any W-2 I have ever received. The executives at Fox Sports in their fancy Ivy League suits find themselves selling the Crown Tournament featuring the Rutgers Scarlet Knights, of all teams, You're taking it personal. It's just business and you're taking it very, very personal.
 

NCAAsorBust

Junior
Jan 14, 2026
366
306
63
Our players, without the benefit of any college degree, negotiated contracts that did not require them to appear in any post season tournaments. They will also file tax returns with W-2s that exceed any W-2 I have ever received. The executives at Fox Sports in their fancy Ivy League suits find themselves selling the Crown Tournament featuring the Rutgers Scarlet Knights, of all teams, You're taking it personal. It's just business and you're taking it very, very personal.
it’s pretty clear you’re clueless when you mention a W2. It’s the dead give away. None of these players are employees. Who is their employer? You’re just spewing garbage of something you have no idea what you’re talking about. They don’t receive a w2. They all get 1099s. It’s clear listening to you talk about “business” is a waste of time.
 
Last edited:

HallGuy2323

Junior
Jun 3, 2020
587
387
63
isnt this brand new tourney half as big as last yr? Start date is riduliculous

I don’t care either way but we are a totally irrelevant basketball team with a MORE irrelevant athletics department in general

I would say we are borderline d1 in how we run athletics

So if schools that run actual big time athletics departments want to participate good for them and who are we to say anything to them putting it down
I’m sure all 48 people in the arena for the crown games will surely miss us. What a major event we turned down.
 

PhishingPirate088

Sophomore
Mar 10, 2022
213
120
43
I’m sure all 48 people in the arena for the crown games will surely miss us. What a major event we turned down.
I don’t care if we turned it down or not. But for us to put it down and call it a joke is ridiculous

We are a fringe D1 athletics department, we shouldn’t make fun or call anything a joke. If the schools who wanted to play wanted to go for it good for them
 

SHUMike

Redshirt
Jan 13, 2013
6
14
3
Them turning down the Crown is a total lack of respect for the fans that donate big money to the program. It is a lack of respect to the fans that contribute to their NIL. It is a lack of respect to the fans that travel all over to support the team.
And the funny thing is, none of them will be back next year.
We should be getting our money's worth too.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: cubbob

HallX2

Senior
Mar 25, 2005
2,541
718
73
it’s pretty clear you’re clueless when you mention a W2. It’s the dead give away. None of these players are employees. Who is their employer? You’re just spewing garbage of something you have no idea what you’re talking about. They don’t receive a w2. They all get 1099s. It’s clear listening to you talk about “business” is a waste of time.
I would say that it would a difficult classification to defend. It has all the “hallmarks” Of employer/employee. Pun intended. But serious on the employee classification
 

PQR

Freshman
Jan 31, 2020
93
98
18
Them turning down the Crown is a total lack of respect for the fans that donate big money to the program. It is a lack of respect to the fans that contribute to their NIL. It is a lack of respect to the fans that travel all over to support the team.
And the funny thing is, none of them will be back next year.
We should be getting our money's worth too.
Even though they’re paid, the players are kids. Whether it’s because they were bitterly disappointed at their inability despite their effort to win the crucial games all season or if it’s because they’re a team of 10 new guys without a strong connection to the school, or if it’s disappointment with the lack of student support doesn’t matter. Sha is right to gage the team psyche by letting them decide. A performance like that of other BE teams in last year’s NIT won’t help us. Especially given our style of play without 100% commitments we’re getting blown out. Better To sit it out.
 

HallGuy2323

Junior
Jun 3, 2020
587
387
63
Them turning down the Crown is a total lack of respect for the fans that donate big money to the program. It is a lack of respect to the fans that contribute to their NIL. It is a lack of respect to the fans that travel all over to support the team.
And the funny thing is, none of them will be back next year.
We should be getting our money's worth too.
Wow you are really overreacting.