Isaiah Coleman 28 & 8 vs Auburn

TheHall87

Junior
Jun 3, 2001
171
286
63
Why would he stay in an offensive system with no other shooters and slow pace?

He got paid and got in a better offensive system to showcase himself
Having a point guard to set Coleman up would have helped him immensely.

He was plenty productive last year until Jenkins (and Dylan) went down and stripped the offense bare.

He averaged over 21 a game in the six full BE games before Jenkins was injured. Over 20 BE games he averaged 17.4 per even with a couple of atrocious nights.

That said we were never going to pay him close to market value.
 

Hall Is Life

Redshirt
Oct 15, 2019
36
48
18

shu67

Freshman
Jun 12, 2021
136
76
28
Wasn't he supposed to be 6'5" when he was at SHU? I guess all of the NIL money (gold) he got weighed him down so much he lost some height carrying it around!
 

HallGuy2323

Redshirt
Jun 3, 2020
40
22
8
Wasn't he supposed to be 6'5" when he was at SHU? I guess all of the NIL money (gold) he got weighed him down so much he lost some height carrying it around!
lol, it’s insane how badly basketball players lie about their height. Now it’s because they get “measured in their shoes”. I guess they wear heels.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shu67 and Piratz

hallstorm

Redshirt
Aug 11, 2017
5
14
3
Wait a minute….

this is a thread based on a player’s output for a scrimmage? For an essential single practice that doesn’t count?

This board loves to follow how ex players do on other teams and the start a thread on how we missed out.

We need another Anthony Nelson or Jordan Walker thread. How are they doing overseas?
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: shu67 and SHUSource

NYShoreGuy

Sophomore
Jan 7, 2006
411
171
43
Wait a minute….

this is a thread based on a player’s output for a scrimmage? For an essential single practice that doesn’t count?

This board loves to follow how ex players do on other teams and the start a thread on how we missed out.

We need another Anthony Nelson or Jordan Walker thread. How are they doing overseas?
Jordan Walker pro ball Lithuania 9 pts 5 assists last game
 

NIL BAD

Redshirt
Aug 15, 2025
23
14
3
Along with a very good offensive game Zay had the physical skills to be an elite defender. Unfortunately he was very inconsistent on both ends. We never knew what version of Zay we were gonna get, yet he was still one of the better players in the league.
 

lr591902

Redshirt
Nov 18, 2012
12
17
3
I am not sure we could offer him enough money to return. I think he had lost focus as he did not like the style of play or the way Sha ran the team. I think he and his family thought a change of scenery would be beneficial. Always like IC, i hope he has a great season similar to Khadary last year.
 

radecicco

Sophomore
Jun 24, 2013
138
185
43
No problem with Coleman looking for more $$$. What boggles my mind are a few posters saying they didn’t want him back, he wasn’t a good player, he was inconsistent or lacked focus, was just chucking shots,etc, etc, etc. He was a second year player with upside being asked to carry a lousy team.
 

Halldan

All-Conference
Staff member
Jan 1, 2003
177,985
1,292
113
The question was asking price. Word leaked from decent sources that he wanted $1.5M. There was no way in hell the Pirates had that money to give when the ask was made.

We had to wait until the court case (never a given) was resolved before we had that kind of money. And then the question would have been do you really want to give that kind of money to a 6-3 wing?
 

TheHall87

Junior
Jun 3, 2001
171
286
63
The question was asking price. Word leaked from decent sources that he wanted $1.5M. There was no way in hell the Pirates had that money to give when the ask was made.

We had to wait until the court case (never a given) was resolved before we had that kind of money. And then the question would have been do you really want to give that kind of money to a 6-3 wing?
I look at this from both sides.

I can see the real concerns about asking price and the ability/want to pay.

At the same time sometimes you might have to overpay to keep a talent to show that you're serious about trying to compete.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shupat08

NYShoreGuy

Sophomore
Jan 7, 2006
411
171
43
The question was asking price. Word leaked from decent sources that he wanted $1.5M. There was no way in hell the Pirates had that money to give when the ask was made.

We had to wait until the court case (never a given) was resolved before we had that kind of money. And then the question would have been do you really want to give that kind of money to a 6-3 wing?
Let's see him avg shooting percentage of 50 40 80 and see what he does against Iowa state before some here want to build him a statue
 

Halldan

All-Conference
Staff member
Jan 1, 2003
177,985
1,292
113
His asking price was one he knew would never be matched and he settled for a lot less after he left. He wanted out after last season when by midseason he started to play selfishly and not for the team.

Hunted points and played no defense. You do not award a 6-3 wing with $1.5M for that.

I have no ill will towards him but I'm not rooting for him like I did for Richmond and Davis as I did last season.

,
 

Seton75

Senior
Jun 3, 2001
35,077
445
83
His asking price was one he knew would never be matched and he settled for a lot less after he left. He wanted out after last season when by midseason he started to play selfishly and not for the team.

Hunted points and played no defense. You do not award a 6-3 wing with $1.5M for that.

I have no ill will towards him but I'm not rooting for him like I did for Richmond and Davis as I did last season.

,
I too have no ill will towards Isaiah. I do hope I need to go to the Ok St web site to get his stats over the season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUSource

Seton75

Senior
Jun 3, 2001
35,077
445
83
Exactly.

In the 70s, in Avon, we had a terrific guy who was a retired vet and now worked for the town public works. He went to Kellys after work and tied a load on. The cops would be waiting for him on the Avon side of the bridge and they would escort him home. And then, things really changed. I remember being at a bar and we all wanted to drive home with one of our friends who was known as our best drunk driver. Even today, surprised and elated I survived all the insanity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SHUSource

dehere23

Junior
Feb 28, 2015
203
250
43
Is that the type of guy you want as your No. 1 option, especially if you are looking to rebuild the program? If that’s what it’s come to, count me out.
I hear you, but let's also be real. The Coleman stuff about him being a "me first" player didn't seriously come out on our boards until he was long gone. When someone even insinuated he might be playing this way during the season -- which I did -- we were smacked down. Coincidence? Of course not. If we had been able to retain Coleman, the stuff that's come out wouldn't see the light of day here or been amplified how it has been amplified. Since he's gone, the "narrative building" starts. Likewise, while a DUI is an irresponsible and dangerous act (and one that occurs too often), you would have a line of posters excusing it if Coleman was back here and projected to be our best player.

The issue with losing Coleman isn't that he's worth these absurd amounts being tossed around, or whether he can grow into the best player or second best player on a NCAA team. The issue is once again losing our best player without replacing him. A junior Coleman -- who quickly became overrated last year when he had a few strong scoring games in a row -- would be in the argument for a potential preseason all league team IMO.
 

Halldan

All-Conference
Staff member
Jan 1, 2003
177,985
1,292
113
A junior Coleman -- who quickly became overrated last year when he had a few strong scoring games in a row -- would be in the argument for a potential preseason all league team IMO.
Not based on this